Listen to this article:
Professor Sheila Bhalla, professor emerita at the School of Social Sciences, JNU, a respected teacher, a labour economist of repute and a committed activist, passed away in Puducherry on September 5.
Canadian by birth, she was introduced to trade union activities early in her life by her father. She studied at the London School of Economics, where she met and married G.S. Bhalla, and decided to make India her home. Sheila and G.S. Bhalla joined the Panjab University in 1969, and after teaching there for about six years, moved to Jawaharlal Nehru University, where she became a member of the faculty of the newly established Centre for Economic Studies and Planning and he joined the Centre for Studies in Regional Development. She retired from the Centre for Economic Studies and Planning in 1992 and went on to become professor emerita. She was also associated for long with the Institute of Human Development as a visiting professor.
Sheila Bhalla had a remarkably multifaceted personality. She ran a large household which apart from the two of them, their four children and an ailing mother-in-law, also included a constant stream of visitors comprising not just friends, colleagues and comrades but also a large number of relatives of G.S. Bhalla from Punjab.
In her workplace, she was often required to take a disproportionate burden of administrative responsibilities from which other colleagues shied away. For over two decades after her retirement, she would travel from her home in Gurgaon every morning and go to work at IHD about 30 kilometres away – and, until G.S. Bhalla was alive and working, drop him at JNU on the way – and do the same trip back in the evening.
Until the very end of her life, she took care of all these responsibilities with remarkable ease. In fact, she never let them become the highlight of her life or allowed them to distract her from her scholarly work and her other commitments. While everyone was in awe of this super-efficient woman, the only thing she would be interested in talking about, and she would never tire of it, was the research that she and everyone else was doing. She would show up at every seminar and conference in the School of Social Sciences in JNU, and made sure to participate in every protest of workers, peasants and university teachers.
Sheila Bhalla was known for meticulous empirical research. Changing conditions of rural employment, occupational diversification in rural areas and agricultural development remained subjects of her lifelong scholarly engagement.
Her research on the impact of the Green Revolution on rural labour in Haryana, an inspiring example of meticulous field-based research, remains a seminal reference for the impact of technological change on rural society. Her detailed survey of 153 villages in Haryana in 1972 showed that intensification of cultivation in the early Green Revolution period was associated with an increase in demand for labour. Unlike what was later found to be the case in rice-growing regions, Sheila Bhalla found that this increase in demand for labour in Haryana was associated with an increase in prevalence of long-term labour contracts. Sheila Bhalla’s writings present the most lucid analysis of long-term labour contracts, a feature that remains important in the canvas of rural labour relations in Haryana till date, and the changing mechanisms of labour control in Haryana.
By the early 1990s, she realised that labour absorption in agriculture had started to fall. This led her to argue for the need to augment investment in manufacturing and services sectors along with further investments in agriculture to ensure that increase in agricultural productivity was accompanied by creation of employment opportunities in non-agricultural sectors. She was elected to be the conference president of the Annual Conference of the Indian Society of Labour Economics held in December 1995 in Pondicherry. Her presidential address dwelt on this theme and argued that it is important to move workers out of low-productivity on-farm activities into non-farm sectors. She argued that doing so required a three-pronged strategy: creation of appropriate infrastructure for development of rural and town industries, protection and modernisation of artisanal production, and development of small scale industries that work as ancillaries of large factories.
In the early 2000s, she started looking at the nature of occupational diversification among rural workers, and when she found that rural workers displaced from agriculture were getting absorbed predominantly in the urban informal sector, she turned her eyes to the problems of informal labour. Since the mid-2000s, the informal sector became an important focus of her work as she looked at unorganised sector enterprises and informal labour. Her paper for the National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector was key to conceptualising the nature of informality in employment and thus correctly identifying what constituted the informal economy of India.
Having been a user of statistics on the Indian economy throughout her professional life, Sheila Bhalla was keenly interested in the Indian statistical system. Her 2014 paper in the Economic and Political Weekly, based on her work with the National Statistical Commission, remains a crucial document that warned of the weakening of the official statistical organisations, the effects of which have become all too apparent in recent times.
Apart from being a meticulous scholar, Sheila Bhalla was a strong supporter of the struggles of peasants and workers, and a firm believer in the politics of the left. Even at an advanced age, she would not miss a rally of the peasants and workers in Delhi. Notwithstanding the COVID-19 pandemic, she made it a point to visit the Singhu and Tikri borders to express her solidarity with the Kisan struggle. As recently as in September 2020, she participated in protests at Jantar Mantar and joined in raising slogans against the farm laws and corporatisation of agriculture.
She was closely associated with the All India Agricultural Workers Union (AIAWU) and the All India Kisan Sabha (AIKS). She not only regularly participated in protests and demonstrations, she would regularly meet the AIKS and AIAWU leadership to discuss issues that she thought she needed to bring to their attention. She wrote an important paper in the Journal of Peasant Studies in which she related agrarian change in Haryana to the evolution of the struggles of AIAWU and AIKS units in Haryana. She attended the 33rd All India Conference of the AIKS in Cuddalore in 2013, and on her return, wrote an important paper on diversion of agricultural land to non-agricultural uses, on which she wanted the AIKS to have a more comprehensive understanding.
I believe, it is only fitting that a tribute to Professor Bhalla focuses on her scholarly work and commitments. Her writings are indispensable for anyone interested in learning about the history of agrarian change and labour in modern India. I would, therefore, like to end my tribute to Professor Sheila Bhalla by presenting to the readers a bibliography of her scholarly work.
A Bibliography of Writings of Professor Sheila Bhalla
1976: “New Relations of Production in Haryana Agriculture”, Economic and Political Weekly, 11 (13).
1977: “Agricultural Growth Role of Institutional and Infrastructural Factors”, Economic and Political Weekly, 12 (45–46).
1977: “Changes in Acreage and Tenure Structure of Land Holdings in Haryana, 1962-72”, Economic and Political Weekly, 12 (13).
1979: “Real Wage Rates of Agricultural Labourers in Punjab, 1961-77: A Preliminary Analysis”, Economic and Political Weekly, 14 (26).
1981: “Islands of Growth: A Note on Haryana Experience and Some Possible Implications”, Economic and Political Weekly, 16 (23).
1983: “Tenancy Today: New Factors in Determination of Mode and Level of Rent Payments for Agricultural Land”, Economic and Political Weekly, 18 (19–21), pp. 835–854.
1985: “Work Force Structure 1981: The Turning of the Tide?”, in Mishra, G P, (eds.), Regional Structure of Development and Growth in India, Volume I, Ashish Publishing House, New Delhi.
1987: “Budget 1987-88 Focus on Expenditure”, Economic and Political Weekly, 22 (15)
1987: “Trends in Employment in Indian Agriculture, Land and Asset Distribution”, Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 42 (902-2018-2593), pp. 537–560.
1989: “Employment in Indian Agriculture: Retrospect and Prospect”, Social Scientist, 17 (5/6), pp. 3–21.
1989: “Technological Change and Women Workers: Evidence from the Expansionary Phase in Haryana”, Economic and Political Weekly, 24 (43).
1990: “A Theoretical Framework for a Study of Rural Labour Market”, Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 33 (2), pp. 103–118.
1991: “Speeding up Agricultural Growth: Implications for Labour Absorption”, Paper prepared for the National Seminar on Rural Development (26-27 April, 1991), Lucknow. Online copy can be found here.
1993: “Patterns of Employment Generation”, The Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 39 (1), pp. 1–12.
1993: “Test of Some Propositions About the Dynamics of Changes of the Rural Workforce Structure”, The Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 36 (3), pp. 428–439.
1993: “The Dynamics of Wage Determination and Employment Genera- tion in Indian Agriculture”, Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 48 (3), pp. 448–470.
1994: “Poverty, Workforce Development and Rural Labour Markets”, The Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 37 (4), pp. 609–622.
1994: “Globalisation, Growth and Employment”, in Bhalla, G S, and Agarwal, Manmohan, (eds.), World Economy in Transition: An Indian Perspective, Har-Anand Publisher, New Delhi.
1996: “Workforce Restructuring, Wages and Want: Recent Events, Interpretations and Analysis”, The Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 39 (1), pp. 1–12.
1997: “Trends in Poverty, Wages and Employment in India”, Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 40 (2), pp. 213–222.
1997: “The Rise and Fall of Workforce Diversiﬁcation Processes in Rural India”, in Chadha, G K and Sharma, Alakh N, (eds.), Growth, Employment and Poverty: Change and Continuity in Rural India, Vikas Publishing House Pvt Ltd, New Delhi 1997.
1998: “Trends in Poverty, Wages and Employment in Rural India”, in Chadha, G K and Sharma, Alakh N (eds), Empowering Rural Labour in India: Market, State and Mobilisation, Institute for Human Development, New Delhi.
2000: “Behind Poverty: The Qualitative Deterioration of Employment Prospects for Rural Indians”, in Acharya, S S, Singh, Surjit, and Sagar, Vidya, (eds.), Sustainable Agriculture, Poverty and Food Security, Rawat Publications, Jaipur.
2002: Multiple Activities and Multiple Income Sources of Rural Non-farm Entrepreneurs and Their Households, Poverty Among them and Links with the Land: A Study in Eight Villages of Andhra Pradesh and Haryana, Working Paper, Institute of Human Development, New Delhi.
2002: “Rural Non-Farm Employment and the Unorganised Sector in India”, The Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 45 (4), pp. 695–717.
2003: “The Restructuring of the Unorganised Sector in India”, Report on a Project Funded under the Planning Commission Scheme of Socio-Economic Research, Institute for Human Development, New Delhi. Online can be found here.
2005: India’s Rural Economy: Issues and Evidence, Working paper, Institute of Human Development, New Delhi.
2005: “Rural Workforce Diversiﬁcation and Performance of Unorganised Sector Enterprises”, in Rural Transformation in India: The Role of Non-farm Sector, Institute for Human Development, New Delhi, pp. 75–104.
2006: Recent Developments in the Unorganized Rural Non-farm Sector, Working Paper No 28, Institute of Human Development, New Delhi.
2006: (with Karan, Anup K, and Shobha, T) “Rural Casual Labourers, Wages and Poverty: 1983 to 1999/2000”, in Mehta, Aasha Kapur, and Shepherd, Andrew, (eds.), Chronic Poverty and Development Policy in India, Sage Publications, New Delhi, pp. 86–147.
2007: “Common Issue and Common Concerns in the SAARC Region: Employment Generation and Poverty Reduction”, Indian Journal of Labour Economics, 50 (2).
2007: “Inclusive Growth? Focus on Employment”, Social Scientist, 35 (7/8), pp. 24–43, issn: 09700293. Online copy can be found here.
2009: Deﬁnitional and Statistical Issues Relating to Workers in Informal Employment, Working Paper No 3, National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector
2014: “Behind the Post-1991 ’Challenge’ to the Functional Eﬃciency of Established Statistical Institutions”, Economic and Political Weekly, 49 (7).
2014: Scarce Land: Issues, Evidence and Impact, Working Paper No 02/14, Institute of Human Development, New Delhi. Online copy can be found here.
2017: “From ‘Relative Surplus Population’ and ‘Dual Labour Markets’ to ‘Informal’ and ‘Formal; Employment and Enterprises: Insights About Causation and Consequences”, Agrarian South: Journal of Political Economy, 6 (3), pp. 295–305, https://doi.org/10.1177/2277976017745460
Vikas Rawal is professor at the Centre for Economic Studies and Planning, JNU.