Law

SC Advocates' Body Expresses Concern Over Justice Arun Mishra's Behaviour With Lawyers

'We request Hon'ble Justice Arun Mishra to be little more patient in dealing with lawyers,' the resolution reads.

New Delhi: In the context of Justice Arun Mishra threatening senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan with contempt action during a hearing, the Supreme Court Advocates on Record Association has passed a resolution.

The Executive Committee of the SCORA expressed deep concern over the incident, which happened during the hearing in the Indore Development Authority case before the Constitution Bench headed by Justice Arun Mishra on Tuesday. The resolution read:

“Several members of the bar have repeatedly been raising such grievance about the unwarranted treatment and passing personal remarks by Hon’ble Justice Arun Mishra.

“We request Hon’ble Justice Arun Mishra to be little more patient in dealing with lawyers.”

The association reminded that the duty to maintain dignity and decorum of the Court is cast upon both lawyers and judges.

Also read: Judges and Recusal: The Issue Is Propriety, Not Bias

Senior advocate Vikas Singh has written to president of the Supreme Court Bar Association to convene an urgent Executive Committee meeting and pass a resolution condemning the incident and seeking an apology from Justice Arun Mishra.

“Terrorising the lawyers under the threat of contempt and not allowing them to argue under the threat undermines the fundamentals of the justice delivery system,” Singh said in the letter.

As a first step of protest, the advocates should refrain from standing up when the judges enter the courtroom, Singh suggested.

On Tuesday, Justice Arun Mishra told Gopal Sankaranarayan that his arguments in the case concerning interpretation of Section 24 of the RFCTLARR Act were repetitive and threatened him with contempt if he persisted with the submissions.

“You are making a mockery of the justice delivery system! We are hearing patiently. And You are commenting on every query? Retorting on every query? If you make one more retort and I will take contempt against you and make sure it is seen through!…Now If you have any new points, you may only make them!” Justice Mishra told the senior advocate.

At this point, Sankaranarayanan excused himself from the hearing and left the courtroom.

At the start, Justice Mishra had also expressed displeasure at the advocate addressing the bench as “you”.

Sankaranarayanan was one of the lawyers who had in October, demanded Justice Mishra’s recusal from the matter, the judge having earlier rendered the Indore Development Authority decision which is under reconsideration before this five-judge bench.

This article originally appeared on LiveLaw and has been reproduced with permission.