Every teacher knows the particular silence of a lecture hall left empty on purpose. It is not the silence of a holiday, when the benches are bare and the building sleeps. It is the silence of an argument that has moved out of the room to be made on the street. On Friday, November 20, that silence fell over classrooms in multiple countries at once. From London to Amsterdam and beyond, students put down their pens at the same hour and walked on to the streets. More than 50 student and youth organisations had called a common walkout under a slogan of admirable bluntness: “Fight for Our Future, Not Their Wars.” The young have been angry in every generation. What is remarkable is that the present generation has decided to rebel together, without regard for frontiers.The grievances range from the right to education and housing to the cost of living, from climate justice to rearmament and the erosion of democratic freedoms. The older habit of mind treats the leaking school roof, the unpayable rent, the short-term contract and the defence estimate as separate misfortunes, each to be bewailed in its own season. The young see them as connected, all arising from how the nations spends its money. A state that can conjure billions for armaments and underscore poverty the moment teachers or hospitals present their accounts has revealed its priorities more honestly than any manifesto. President Eisenhower understood as much when he observed, in 1953, that the price of a single modern bomber was a brick school in more than 30 cities. The arithmetic has only grown more brazen and widespread since.The inheritance these students claim is indeed historically very striking. In May 1968 the occupation of the Sorbonne and the Latin Quarter spread to the factories, and some ten million workers brought France to a halt. Wordsworth, recalling another French upheaval, wrote that to be young was “very heaven”, and one understands the sentiment, though 1968 ended, as such dawns usually do, in a more ambiguous morning. In Soweto in 1976, schoolchildren who refused an education designed to prepare them for subordination exposed apartheid to a world that conveniently overlooked it. Across Latin America students stood against the generals; in the United States the civil rights and anti-war movements drew their moral stamina from the young. Education, for all such activists, exists to produce citizens who can question, not subjects who merely comply.Yet those earlier rebellions were, for the most part, national affairs. The students of Paris did not wait for Berlin to join them, and the schoolchildren of Soweto had no counterparts demonstrating in Rome. What distinguishes the present moment is that the young have understood something their governments have been slow to admit. Clearly, the problems they face cross borders freely. The arms trade, climate breakdown, speculative finance, forced displacement and the hoarding of wealth all move freely across frontiers, while the people who bear their consequences are told to petition their own ministries, in their own language, within their own constituencies. The students have answered with a protest that carries no passport and asks for no visa.The present mobilisation carries that conviction into a thoroughly contemporary setting. French pupils protest overcrowded classrooms and a shortage of teachers; German youth object to the revival of conscription and the quiet normalisation of preparation for war; students in Italy, Belgium and Spain have made common cause. The manifesto demands an end to rearmament and compulsory service, public investment in education and welfare, social and climate justice, and solidarity with oppressed peoples with Palestinians among them.It is a question the young are entitled to put, for they are the ones who will have to pay. They inherit a warming planet they did not heat, public debts incurred in decades when they were children, a housing market that has placed the very idea of a home beyond the reach of a salary, and an arms race whose logic seems to require that they, and not their elders, be the ones to serve in it. A generation asked to pay in full for decisions taken without its consent may be forgiven for wishing to inspect the bill. It is a reasonable demand to know what they are being asked to pay for.There is a graver issue here, concerning the health of democracy itself. In country after country dissent is handled as a problem of public order rather than as the lifeblood of a free polity. Student protesters meet surveillance, disciplinary proceedings and the baton, and those who speak against war or for a besieged people are quickly cast as agents of some alien interest. Julien Benda, in The Treason of the Intellectual, wrote of the intellectuals who betrayed their calling. Today the intellectuals are told to be silent, and it is the students who refuse. Chomsky wrote that intellectuals must speak truth to power. Now it is the 19 year olds who are showing resistance.The test is whether the young can find allies in teachers, trade unions, farmers, climate campaigners, the precariously employed. Those of us who watched the Punjab farmers hold the approaches to Delhi know how much endurance depends on such alliances. Camus put the point in six words, “I rebel, therefore we are”; revolt that begins in a single grievance becomes political only when it discovers that it is not alone.That discovery is what makes the internationalism of November 20 more than a gesture. India, with its own record of student conscience from the freedom struggle to the resistance to the Emergency, has no reason to regard this as a foreign spectacle. The young who marched on Parliament this summer over a discredited examination system were asking, in another idiom, the same thing as their counterparts in Paris and Berlin: why are the costs of other people’s decisions assigned to them? The answer, here as there, will not come from the lecture hall alone. It will come when the young are joined by those who already hold some power, and who must decide whether to stand beside them or to wait, as the powerful usually do, until the moment has passed.It would be foolish to romanticise any of this. But it would be worse to condescend to it. What 1968, Soweto and the anti-war years bequeathed was the stubborn belief that ordinary people, the young among them, may intervene in history instead of merely being delivered to it.By next week the benches will be full again, as they always are, and the silence of Friday will have been drowned in timetables and coughs. What matters is whether the argument that walked out of the classroom has been carried into something more durable as a budget, a curriculum, a law. The young are proposing, politely, to scrutinise their inheritance. They are asking to change what they are handed.Shelley Walia is formerly Professor of Cultural and Literary Theory and UGC Emeritus Fellow at Panjab University, Chandigarh. He has been Senior Fellow at the Rothermere American Institute, University of Oxford. He writes on education, culture, war and international relations.