The popular political earthquake that has shaken the Donald Trump presidency and the Republican party at all levels, has also sent a resounding message to the victorious Democratic party: Transform the party from the negativity of opposition to the worst elements of Trumpism towards an independent programme to deal with the multiple challenges facing ordinary Americans — the sort that drove Americans to deliver their verdict in ways not seen since the midterm elections of 1946 and straight after Watergate in 1974. Hence, let’s speculate about the possibility of a socialist Democrat in the White House after the 2028 presidential elections. There’s no question that Democratic socialists and their aligned politicians have done very well in the recent midterm elections. The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) have over 120,000 members spread across all fifty states.But DSA candidates largely won in safe seats rather than in marginals and they do not constitute the balancing factor within the new Democratic caucus. The heart of the party remains centrist and largely anti-socialist and pro-capitalist, though many see the need for reforming the harsher edges of the market and corporate power.And what about the bloc within the Democrats in Congress that are not only centrists and opponents of socialism but are also former military, intelligence operatives or law enforcement? What’s the impact of that bloc and how has it grown or retained its influence in the party? And they often won their seats in bright red areas. And how do they plan to hold onto them, especially in the House elections in 2028? What are the political ramifications of that on any moves to the Left in the Democratic party?On top of that, if that were not enough, any socialist candidate would face huge pressures from their own party, the entire GOP bloc, the corporate and other donor class that basically funds American elections, a corporate media that’s a cheerleader for capitalism, and even broad swathes of the electorate who look for the American dream not from the state but their own hard work – who buy that myth and the myth that drove them to come in their millions to the land of opportunity? History shows undemocratic features built into systemA look at the history of the founding of the American republic also reveals how farsighted founders attempted to design a constitutional system precisely to prevent a governing majority rooted in ordinary largely propertyless Americans. James Madison, one of the founding fathers who later went onto the presidency (1809-1817), authored Federalist Paper number 10 as a case in point. Madison argued that “…democracies have ever been spectacles of turbulence and contention; have ever been found incompatible with personal security or the rights of property; and have in general been as short in their lives as they have been violent in their deaths.” He further argued, “But the most common and durable source of factions has been the various and unequal distribution of property. Those who hold and those who are without property have ever formed distinct interests in society.” The solution to that? “…the majority, having such coexistent passion or interest, must be rendered, by their number and local situation, unable to concert and carry into effect schemes of oppression.” Divide and rule.In Federalist Paper 51 Madison advanced the separation of powers and a complex social structure to protect minority property-owner rights from majority ‘factions’. In Federalist paper 68, Alexander Hamiliton promoted and defended the Electoral College as a bulwark to insulate the election of the president from the passions of the mass.What this shows is that there were self-conscious designs built into the US Constitution from the beginning that aimed at thwarting the will of the majority, and that many of those elements have continued to do that 250 years later.But those elitist tendencies were also contested from the very beginning, as they are today.Pessimism of the intellect therefore suggestsAnd after all that, say a socialist is elected to the White House – after all Bernie Sanders’s 2016 campaign came close to the nomination but was thwarted by the Clinton political machine. Say that machine, like the GOP machine in 2016, fails in 2028 just because mass politics has moved on – George Floyd, No Kings, Palestine, a brewing general strike in 2028, the broad support for socialism among younger and working class voters, and the sheer popular appeal of a Zohran Mamdani or Alexandria Ocasio Cortez? What would be the chances of a radical socialist presidency in regard to both domestic politics and policies, as well as the treacherously tricky domain of foreign and national security, the power of the military-industrial complex? Of course, there is nothing in principle or in legal or constitutional terms that prohibits a socialist presidency. The problem is more structural bias rather than absolute prohibition. The American system works rather differently to achieve more or less an effective prohibition and radical constraints, at least for the foreseeable future, stacking the odds against a socialist presidency implementing a radical programme. The most compelling impediments to election and governing by a socialist president are the very structures of the Democratic party, the mysteries of the undemocratic Electoral College, corporate and billionaire donor networks, corporate media’s framing of socialism as enemy of American freedom. If that’s not enough, there are numerous effective veto points in the system: Congress, the courts at numerous levels especially the Supreme Court – currently stacked with pro-Trump appointees, and federalism itself with its dispersal of power and sheer geographical and other diversities. These forces, these deep structures, represent formidable, probably insurmountable, barriers to scaling up from locals like New York City to the national level. Also read: Socialism is as American as Apple PieConversely, right-wing ‘radicalism’ is not so constrained and indeed enjoys numerous advantages over the Left in the White House. Look at how Trump-style disruption has proven to be so much more achievable than equivalent left-wing transformation. This is because Trumpist strategy mostly relies on dismantling institutions and deregulating, and on executive personnel power, and, critically, alignment with powerful factions within the capitalist class. A socialist agenda on the other hand needs to focus on massive redistributions, enactment of numerous across the board new public services and provisions, and the restraint of military power in a Pentagon system that even Trump has failed to fully control. Socialism will require positive and constructive new legislation built on sustained majorities that the system itself is designed to frustrate.The terrain of foreign policy, national security underpinned by a military industrial complex that even a conservative president – Eisenhower back in 1961 – warned against is even more treacherous. The military in domestic politics and government is a hard, tangible power – the power of military contracts that fuel jobs in factories and in and around hundreds of military, naval and air bases -and therefore votes. The funding of congressional candidates by the arms industry has widespread effects on election campaigns and voting behaviour in the districts and in congress. More or less any reasonably socialistic programme that pushes soft power, multilateralism, eschews forever wars and unilateralism comes up against the iron fist of the military industrial complex, a bipartisan consensus that has outlived the anti-forever wars refrains and promises of both major party candidates since 2020, and Trump’s since 2016. And there are still alliance commitments – NATO, AUKUS, 5 eyes – and around 800 US military bases worldwide. Of course, there are tools that the executive can use but large-scale durable change to a different kind and level of US hegemony – let alone its total abandonment – looks unfeasible. Yet, optimism of the will?But just look at the sheer significance of mass discontent, as shown by the recent election results and in numerous other ways including exit polls and the numbers collected by the Harvard Crowd Counting Consortium. Surely, crises and mass discontent must at the very least expand the chances of change even if the outcome remains uncertain? And are therefore worth trying for? The US people are hit by extremes of inequalities, show a collapse in their levels of trust in national institutions, exhibit large-scale anti-war attitudes, have mobilised against Israel and for Palestinian rights, and significantly show a level of cross-spectrum support including elements of MAGA anti-elitism, which create key openings? But do the socialists or anyone else on the Left have the capability and capacity to weld together behind a coherent socialist programme, the forces of what remain fragmented movements against various grievances?There are mass movements at least and even plans for a general strike led by major unions like the autoworkers that would raise the political pressure for change. But could that actually deliver what Gramsci would call a genuine counter-hegemony? Sustained actions on a mass scale by BLM and anti-racist and anti-fascist forces, people against war and for Palestine, and workers organisations in 2028 could definitely disrupt business-as-usual, and radicalise broader publics and, thereby, strengthen the hand of a socialist president. Converting the control of the streets and neighbourhoods, and of strikers’ power and strikes into durable alternative institutions and governing capacity remains the decisive and historically elusive step.On the basis of the analysis above, what is most likely are partial shifts in the structure and exercise of power, rather than any serious, durable systemic rupture. A socialistic White House may well succeed in cutting some or reallocating to social programmes some of the gargantuan military budget, may even prioritise diplomacy and soft power, place human rights and other conditions on foreign aid programmes, and perhaps adopt strategies for income and wealth redistribution. To be sure, these would be significant progressive reforms and gains. But they would not come close to dismantling the corporate system of power or the military industrial complex and its imperial global programmes.What this illustrates seems clear enough. Formal democracy and its embeddedness in the fabric of capitalist order has the capacity to absorb, dilute, domesticate and isolate radical challenges. Any really radical let alone revolutionary breakthroughs would require electoral success, massive and sustained street mobilisations as the foundation of enduring organisational power, broader racial-class coalitions, conjoined with international solidarities that could withstand the inevitable counter-mobilisations and the powerful effects of systemic blockages, constraints and opposition.Not impossible, especially if there’s a disastrous war, another global financial meltdown, and attendant further collapse of the authority of the two party system. Inderjeet Parmar is a professor of international politics and the associate dean of research, School of Policy and Global Affairs, City St George’s, University of London. He is a Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences and writes the American Imperium column at The Wire. He is the author of several books including Foundations of the American Century and is currently writing a book on the history, politics and crises of the US foreign policy establishment.