Women

'Those Who Spread Hatred Cannot Win': Hundreds Protest Handling of Kathua, Unnao Rape Cases

"Silence is no longer an option."

New Delhi: Hundreds of people took to the streets in multiple cities across India to protest against the Modi government’s lack of action against the accused in the gang rape of an eight-year-old girl in Kathua, Jammu and Kashmir and of a minor girl in Unnao, Uttar Pradesh.

A young woman holds up a sign at Sunday’s ‘Not in My Name’ protest against the Kathua and Unnao rapes. Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

Despite the level of brutality in both cases, BJP leaders either unambiguously stood in defence of the accused or went out of their way to evade questions.

“Silence is no longer an option. If we do not speak today, those who spread hatred, those who want to break the country, those who want to destroy the Constitution, will win.”, the appeal for Sunday’s protest said. Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

After facing flak for his silence, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday said, “The incidents of the recent days are a challenge to social justice. The incidents which have been in public discussion the past two days would be considered shameful by any civilised society. As a society and as a country we should feel ashamed.”

A view of Sunday’s protest. Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

Curiously, Modi refrained from referring to Kathua or Unnao by name, adding that such incidents are an attack on human values regardless of the state or area they have occurred. In Kathua, policemen that were supposed to be investigating the case stand implicated, while a politician from the ruling BJP is the main accused in Unnao.

“Now that all the accused in the Kathua case have been arrested and a detailed charge sheet filed, and it is up to courts to judge the matter, what does he mean by saying that none of the guilty in the crime would be spared? They have already been arrested and put in jail,” a former IAS officer wrote on social media. Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

“The incidents of the recent days are a challenge to social justice. The incidents which have been in public discussion the past two days would be considered shameful by any civilised society. As a society and as a country we should feel ashamed,” Modi added.

“The horses returned home, unable to tell/ How the gods died in a poisoned temple.” – from ‘The Nomad’s Daughter’, a poem by Manash Firaq Bhattacharjee. Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

The protests in Delhi were organised under the ‘Not in My Name’ banner.

The organisers held similar countrywide protests in 2017 to raise their voice against increasing incidents of communal violence against minorities.

Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

“Silence is no longer an option. If we do not speak today, those who spread hatred, those who want to break the country, those who want to destroy the Constitution, will win. We cannot let them win. For if they win, we lose our country. If they win, we lose our dream of an India that promised equality, liberty and fraternity to all its citizens,” reads the pamphlet circulated by the ‘Not in My Name’ organisers.

Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

“Muslims live in fear of the shape of the next round of attacks, even as the rights of Dalits and adivasis enshrined in the Constitution are being questioned. And today, the impunity of those in power makes them defend the rape of women and even of an 8-year-old girl. Those in power shield raposts and take out marches to defend the brutal rape and killing of a child who was targeted simply because she was a Muslim,” it added.

Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

In Delhi, the protestors had four demands:

One, the immediate dismissal of the Adityanath government in Uttar Pradesh for protecting a rapist and for abetting the death in police custody of the father of the rape victim in Unnao.

Two, the immediate arrest of two BJP ministers who led rallies of the Hindu Ekta Manch in Kathua, for hate speech and creating enmity between people.

Three, the immediete arrest of all Hindu Ekta Manch office bearers and leaders for hate speech.

And four, immediete security arrangements for all the families of the victims, and state support for arranging a competent prosecution team.

Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

Protestors from different age groups thronged Parliament Street in Delhi, Bandra in Mumbai, Chandigarh, Bengaluru and Ajmer as many gave rousing speeches, recited poems and sang ‘Hum honge kamiyab (we shall overcome)’.

Meanwhile, the CBI made a second arrest in the Unnao rape case on Saturday as it detained the woman who allegedly took the victim to BJP MLA Kuldeep Singh Sengar on the day of crime.

Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

Modi’s Handling of Kathua, Unnao Rape Cases an ‘Existential Crisis’

Holding him responsible for the “terrifying state of affairs”, 49 retired civil servants, in an open letter on Sunday, urged Prime Minister Narendra Modi to reach out to families of Kathua and Unnao rape victims to “seek their forgiveness”.

Credit: Karnika Kohli/The Wire

“Given your supremacy within the party and the centralised control you and your party president exercise, you more than anyone else have to be held responsible for this terrifying state of affairs … We have had enough of these belated remonstrations and promises to bring justice when the communal cauldron is forever kept boiling by forces nested within the Sangh Parivar,” they added.

‘Credit goes to people of India, not Modi’

In a message on social media, another former IAS officer wrote that he was “stunned” by the news headlines, “PM Modi Silences Critics On Rape Cases, 2 Ministers Quit Soon After”. In fact, credit for the resignations of J&K Industries Minister Chandra Prakash Ganga and Forest Minister Lal Singh, and the arrest of Kuldeep Singh Sengar, the main accused in the Unnao rape case, “goes to the people of India, not PM Modi.”

Had PM Modi taken cognisance of the Kathua case when it occurred in January and the two ministers participated in the Hindu Ekta March in favour of accused, and acted against them, I would have saluted him. Had he taken action when BJP Ministers were continuously interfering in the investigations and investigations team changed several times, I would have saluted him. It was because of their ministers’ continued interference in investigations that advocate Deepika Singh Rajawat had to file a PIL in the Jammu High Court to request a court monitored investigation… Had he intervened at that stage, I would have saluted him. In that case Deepika wouldn’t have to file the PIL. Then the Jammu Bar Association started threatening Deepika from contesting the case… The leading members of the Jammu Bar Association are affiliated with the BJP. Had [Modi] asked them to stop and let Deepika do her job without interference, I would have saluted him…

Now that all the accused in the Kathua case have been arrested and a detailed charge sheet filed, and it is up to courts to judge the matter, what does he mean by saying that none of the guilty in the crime would be spared? They have already been arrested and put in jail. I would have still given him some credit if those ministers had been “dismissed” from the cabinet. But no, they were given a respectful exit through their “resignations”.

In the Unnao case … even the attempt of suicide by the rape victim in front of the chief minister’s residence didn’t wake up the PM. He maintained a studied silence in the hope that this too shall pass. But some enlightened citizens and lawyers filed a PIL in the Allahabad High Court which ordered Sengar’s arrest.

Join The Discussion