Death asks the same question of every human being: what do we do with the body once life leaves it? Because we cannot bear the idea of merely discarding the dead, every civilisation has built a ritual around surrendering the body to one of the primary elements. Fire offers transformation; earth offers containment; water offers dissolution; the sky offers release. By returning the body to nature, humanity transforms a practical necessity into an act of profound spiritual meaning. In her memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, Sonia Gandhi shares previously undisclosed details about the difficult choices and quiet rituals surrounding the last rites of her firstborn son. Sonia Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi had lost their prematurely born baby shortly after his birth in 1969. Under traditional Hindu custom, a newborn is not cremated but typically immersed in a sacred river – a practice known as jal pravah, or water burial. Children below two are spared the pyre because they are already considered pure and free of worldly attachment and sin. Pregnant women, unwed girls, victims of sudden, unnatural deaths such as murder, suicide, violence, drowning, snakebites, or more recently Covid, are also not cremated. Tradition views unfulfilled life cycles as spiritual disruption. Their bodies are often weighted down with heavy stones and immersed midstream into a sacred river.To Rajiv Gandhi and his extended family, raised within Indian tradition, the river was a gentle threshold, an ancient current trusted to carry the dead from one realm to the next. Yet Sonia could not bring herself to surrender her child to the water. If not the water, where could the infant belong in a city where death is strictly partitioned by faith? In India, even in death, bodies are sorted by religious identity, leaving a child born into a secular, interfaith marriage without an obvious resting place.Sonia knew that taking the baby to a public or Christian cemetery would ignite the particular cruelty reserved for public figures, even in their most private hours. Turning to the Parsi burial grounds offered no solution either. Although Rajiv’s late father, Feroze Gandhi, had been born a Parsi, he had not practiced the faith’s customs. Sonia’s refusal of river immersion stemmed from maternal protection in the face of an unbearable memory. Not long before, at the Okhla barrage on the Yamuna river, she had witnessed a man’s swollen corpse drift into a heap of garbage while stray dogs tugged at it from the muddy bank. The river, stripped of its comforting metaphor, was reduced to current, debris, and scavengers. The body, unprotected by ritual, was back to unguarded nature. Because Sonia could not unsee what the Yamuna held, placing her baby in a river felt, in her own words, “so alien and heartless to my tiny child, already deprived of his chance to live”.What Sonia Gandhi recoiled from at Okhla was not Hindu faith. It was the haunting aftermath of water burial: the truth of what the river is believed to be and what it actually holds. A sacred river in India is rarely one thing at once. It is a complex sanctuary of faith where caste, ritual, and survival meet beneath the surface.The gotakhors – expert divers from the Mallah caste of boatmen and fishermen – inhabit the exact nightmare that horrified Sonia Gandhi at Okhla. They exist because jal pravah does not make bodies vanish. They confront the unspoken bargain at the heart of sacred ritual: that even when a soul is entrusted to eternity, caste-based labour still decides whose hands must reckon with the weight of the dead.The gotakhors occupy a space defined by sharp contradictions in the river economy. Born into a caste-bound job at the bottom of the ritual hierarchy, their lives, identity and livelihood are inexorably linked to the river itself. Above the river’s surface, they ferry pilgrims and priests to temples and sacred sites, facilitating the very socio-religious order that grants them proximity to the sacred while denying them an esteemed status within it. Beneath its surface, they transform into expert divers performing the stigmatised, hazardous labour of retrieving sunken corpses discarded in the river or water burials of people deemed ineligible for proper last rites. Their compensation seldom extends beyond small change and cheap alcohol, a meagre comfort in the face of a harsh reality that serves to numb them to their fate.Government restrictions aimed at protecting the river have stripped away their sources of livelihood – commercial fishing, riverbank agriculture, and sand-mining. Left with few alternatives, they turn to the depths of the river for sustenance. Devotees throw coins into the sacred river to compensate for and relieve them of the guilt of their sins. The Gotakhor’s survival depends on retrieving these coins from the river bed. Though outlawed through decades of environmental directives, the jal pravah ritual endures. Because the sacred river is asked to be two incompatible things at once: an infallible mother that purifies every soul and a low-cost cemetery. For the devout, it remains the designated exit for those exempted from fire. For the poor who cannot afford the wood for cremation, immersing an unburned corpse is the only affordable farewell left, adding to the already high levels of pollution.Every civilisation is judged, in the end, by how it solves the problem of the corpse. While we build societies around politics, law and art for the living, the truest measure of a culture’s values, social hierarchy, and spiritual honesty is revealed in what it does with human mortality. Asha Thadani is a photographic artist based in Bengaluru. All photos are by her.