Is there obscenity in love? Or is love sacred?Should love be hidden from society? Or should love be celebrated?What place does love hold in Indian tradition, and in Hindu tradition?With simple sincerity, Rahul Gandhi has placed these questions before India, especially before its Gen Z and its women and girls. He did it through his own family. At the launch of his mother’s memoir, he recalled the love between his parents. It was unusual for a politician to be so candid. It was rarer still to speak of intimacy with warmth, not contempt. He spoke of a woman held with tenderness, not force. A debate has since broken out on the expression of love, and on speaking of love in its physical form.The outrage carries an irony. India celebrates the great Indian wedding like few nations on earth. Yet the love a marriage is meant to hold must stay hidden. The wedding is a public festival. The love inside it is a private embarrassment. A husband’s embrace, recalled by a son, draws trolls.There is a larger irony still. Sexual trolling is now so normal that it has become part of political discourse. An Amnesty International study of the 2019 election found that one in seven tweets mentioning 95 women politicians was problematic or abusive. The coarseness did not stay online. Expletives are routine on OTT shows and in films, and have crept into the slogans of student agitations. Most of this abuse is aimed at mothers and sisters. The insult is built on the body of a woman.Yet it was a son’s tender words, not the slurs, that drew the outrage. This morality is selective. Rape threats against women on social media do not bother it. Domestic violence does not bother it. What it cannot tolerate is a son speaking of the love between his parents.Look again at the picture he drew. A woman of a particular generation, seated at the table as an equal and at ease with love. Sonia Gandhi turns 80 next month. Her whole generation of Indian women deserves a closer look.File photo of Rajiv Gandhi and Sonia Gandhi. Photo: FlickrThe generation that changed IndiaThe women now in their seventies and eighties grew up with a new Constitution. Their life journey is the journey of independent India. They were promised equality, something no Indian women before them had known. This was my mother’s generation. It grew up in Nehru’s India, where a woman could aspire to cross the threshold of her home, to dream and to fly. Cinema caught that hope. ‘Panchhi Banoon’ in Chori Chori and ‘Aaj Phir Jeene Ki Tamanna Hai’ in Guide were not merely songs but also anthems of a new woman.That generation turned aspiration into practice. It saw the end of purdah and the ghoonghat in large measure. In every mohalla and village there are older women who read the newspaper diligently and hold opinions on politics, cricket and everything else. They walked into offices and schools as teachers, clerks and officers. They ran small businesses, earned from crafts and tuitions, and through self-help groups added to family incomes. At home, often against resistance, they redefined what a wife and mother could be.They went crazy for Dev Anand, Rajesh Khanna and Gemini Ganesan. They believed in love, aspired to love and expressed it. They were the silent agents of change in a patriarchal society. They pioneered the change. They powered it. They laid the foundation.Above all, they invested in their daughters. They sent daughters and granddaughters to college and then to work. Those young women became comfortable with fashion, with their femininity and with their bodies. If girls even in remote villages now live differently, it is partly their grandmothers’ doing. Three generations of women now ask for the same three things, dignity, freedom, and love.Daughters who want to flyWomen have moved faster than men in recent decades, in education, in independent thinking and in decision making. For seven years in a row, more young women than young men have enrolled in higher education. In 2024 a higher share of women than men turned out to vote.Watch the students who came out against paper leaks. Young women stood shoulder to shoulder with young men, dressed as they chose. They felt safe in the crowd. This generation is at ease with who it is. It wants families and relationships that love it, not ones that guard it. It wants to live with gay abandon. It wants to be secure at work and safe on the road at night. It wants to fly.Beneficiaries or citizensTo his credit, Prime Minister Modi read this change early and addressed women as an independent constituency. He reached out to them with schemes, cash transfers, reservation and personal appeals, and harnessed their support well.But his social philosophy stops there. It sees women as beneficiaries to be served, not persons to be freed. The RSS sees a woman only as daughter, wife or mother. It treats family, caste and religion as her proper boundaries, and her safety as a privilege within them, not a human right. Its worldview has had no qualms about targeting women with verbal violence online and physical violence in riots, when they stand on the other side of the divide.Building on the foundationRahul Gandhi’s idea of a woman’s liberty is revolutionary and at complete variance to this. He sees a woman as a citizen of India, with identity, rights and freedom equal to anyone else. She must have full control over her opinions, her decisions and her body. The state must give her equal opportunity and protect her right to choose her partner and to love. The state is not her repressor. It is her liberator.When he told young women in Pune to smash the patriarchy, he was not inventing a new cause. He was acknowledging an old one. The call honours the women of his mother’s generation, who chipped away at patriarchy in kitchens, classrooms and offices without ever naming it. They laid the foundation. He is brave enough to ask India’s girls to build on it. You belong to yourself, he told them. That is the Constitution speaking in a single sentence.Economic utility is not emancipation. A woman can earn for her family and still not belong to herself.Why it stungThis is why a tender sentence drew such fury. Those who mocked it recognised themselves in the call to smash the patriarchy. Their order is a home where affection is hidden and authority is displayed. Rahul Gandhi’s memory described the opposite home.Ironically, their sense of shame is not even Indian. It is borrowed from Victorian Britain, which taught a colonial elite to look at its own temples with embarrassment and to frown on gaiety and openness. Hindutva claims to safeguard Hindu tradition, but it inherited that Victorian shame.Rahul Gandhi’s own reply was a twelfth century Hoysala sculpture of Shiva and Parvati seated together on Nandi. In the classical Uma-Maheshvara image, Parvati sits on Shiva’s lap. In Valmiki, a grieving Ram asks the trees whether they have seen Sita. Jayadeva sang of Radha and Krishna. Meera walked out of a royal household for a love she refused to hide. The Indian imagination found love worthy of temples and of god.Gurdeep Singh Sappal is a Permanent Invitee to the Congress Working Committee and former editor/CEO of Rajya Sabha Television.