Every November 20, transgender and gender diverse persons across international cities and countries come together to observe the Transgender Day of Remembrance (TDOR). In the 1990s, what started as a community-led web project, “Remembering our Dead”, in response to the incessant misreporting and deadnaming of deceased transgender persons by local media outlets, grew into a global movement of collective mourning. This TDOR, we try to reframe this question of remembrance against the backdrop of another public process that erases transgender persons from dignified access to democratic participation and our shared silence over this democratic backsliding as a nation.The disenfranchisement of transgender persons in the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise by the Election Commission of India is unprecedented. Across the 12 states and union territories examined, registered transgender electors declined by approximately 30.84%, compared to an overall decline of 11.92%. The decline for transgender electors was more than 2.5 times the overall rate.Source: Estimated % change in the elector population is calculated through a cross-tabulation of the Statistical Records maintained by the Election Commission of India and the SIR Summary details released by the Chief Election Officer of Various State Election Commissions.The disproportionate impact of the SIR exercise on a socio-economically disadvantaged group begs critical scrutiny. This investigation examined electoral roll statistics maintained by the ECI, government records accessed through RTIs, and first-hand narratives from affected persons to understand why transgender electors are disappearing from India’s electoral rolls at a substantially higher rate than other voters.What the data indicatesEstimating the extent of democratic disenfranchisement that transgender and gender non-conforming persons face in India becomes a difficult project to embark upon due to multiple factors. First, in terms of data, the most credible demographic data available for statistical comparisons, like the Census 2011, has been termed as skewed by various LGBTQ+ community organisations, activists and social workers for underestimating the community’s population in India. The critique of the Census 2011 methodology is not limited to anecdotal accounts. For instance, the Census 2011 recorded 43,769 transgender persons in the undivided state of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, while the Integrated Household Survey (Samagra Kutumba Survey) 2014, conducted in the newly bifurcated Telangana alone, pegged the number at 58,918 just three years later.Source: Census of India, 2011 (Table D-1: Population by sex, “Other category”. Telangana Samagra Kutumba Survey (Integrated Household Survey), 2014.The anomalies one observes across different data sets for particular states raise difficult questions about the practice of population estimation for marginalised social groups who were historically targeted through state-sanctioned documentation and audit practices, such as the criminal registries under the Criminal Tribes Act 1871 and its various post-independence iterations.Second, the aspiration to be counted in an unequal democracy needs to be politically unpacked beyond the technocratic logic of “data-driven development”. Transgender and gender diverse persons in India remain divided over their information being put on the State radar as a disenchanted response to how they are treated by the State. In 2025, the Supreme Court of India, in Jane Kaushik v. Union of India judgement, characterised the Government of India’s sustained inaction on transgender rights as a form of “omissive discrimination”. These unequal terms and conditions to be part of a democracy make transgender persons consciously or structurally opt out of the State’s evidence-based policy-making approach. Therefore, a transgender person’s illegibility as a citizen becomes an active result of State practices.For a closer reading of the alarming levels of disenfranchisement of transgender persons in India, one needs to compare the Census 2011 (with all its caveats) with the statistical records of the Election Commission of India. The Census 2011 estimated the population of transgender individuals above the age of six years to be 357,171 persons in 2011. In 2024, this section of the population should necessarily have crossed the age of 18 to be eligible to vote. Using this estimate as a fixed baseline, we can compare the number of electors registered under the transgender gender category across the last three general election cycles. In the last Lok Sabha election (2024), less than 14% of the enumerated transgender persons in the Census 2011 were recorded in the electoral rolls.Source: Statistical Records of Elections maintained by the Election Commission of India (2014-2024). Census of India 2011 (Table D-1, Population by Sex, “Other” category). These figures show the number of registered transgender electors in each Lok Sabha election as a share of the Census 2011 population estimate.The above data visualisation should be read alongside its statistical and social limitations. Prominent transgender rights activist, Chandramukhi Muvvala, in a 2022 meeting with the Chief Election Officer (CEO) of Telangana State Election Commission, cautioned, “In our city (Hyderabad), there are a large number of transgender persons who have left their natal families and birthplace out of fear of violence and persecution. The majority of them still find their names in the electoral rolls of their natal locality with their dead name and birth-assigned sex, but without practical access or ability to vote in the said constituency. Many official documents required to apply for a new voter ID card using Form 6 or to make changes to the existing voter ID card using Form 8 remain difficult to obtain without family support. It effectively moots our right to vote”.Institutional backsliding of the ECIOver the last three decades, transgender rights organisations and community activists worked with various State Electoral Officials and knocked on judicial corridors to make voting and contesting for elections more accessible to transgender persons. In 2013, the Expert Committee on issues related to Transgender Persons noted that the Election Commission of India, under the provisions of Rule 4 of the Registration of Electoral Roll, 1960, had included the “other” gender marker in its Forms 6, 7 and 8 templates for electors who did not want to be described as male or female. This was in line with the Preamble of the 2015 Charter of the Association of World Election Bodies (A-WEB), an international body whose formation was pioneered by the Election Commission of India. Paragraph 4 of the Preamble explicitly commits to:“Upholding human rights and committing to the promotion of gender equality and the inclusion of people with disabilities and other marginalised communities in the electoral process.”Following the 2014 landmark judgement of the Supreme Court in NALSA v. Union of India, the Election Commission directed the Chief Electoral Officers of all states and UTs to make necessary modifications to all forms relating to electoral enrolment. The State Election Commissions were directed to reach out to transgender communities in a focused manner. Further, the Election Commission of India constituted the National Advisory Committee on Inclusive Elections (NACI) to “identify various marginalised communities such as transgender persons, PVTGs (Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups), homeless people/nomadic groups, sex workers, women in difficult circumstances, and ensure their electoral participation”.Source: Election Commission of India notification issued on 22nd May, 2023.Zainab Patel (alias Radhika Nandgiri), a transgender woman and former member of the National Council for Transgender Persons who attended the NACI meetings, said that “changing the gender category of transgender persons from ‘others’ to ‘TG’ on the Electoral Forms/Rolls, appointing transgender persons as Block-level Officers (BLOs) to facilitate enrolment, pushing for sensitisation modules for the election machinery by India International Institute of Democracy and Election Management (IIIDEM), and appointing transgender leaders as Election Mascots were some of the policy suggestions made to the Election Body” were some policy recommendations that the ECI took note of.The impact of these policy measures and community coordination was evident in the gradual increase in enrolment among transgender electors over the last decade.Source: Tabulated from Statistical Records maintained by the Election Commission of India (2014-2024).States and UTs with migratory hotspot cities, existing networks of traditional transgender kinship systems (deras, gharanas, jamats), and the presence of non-governmental and community-based organisations witnessed higher enrolment numbers. For an auditing body (electoral management) like the Election Commission of India, the gradual increase in enrolment of a marginalised social group epitomised its ability to convert the citizenry of diverse lived experiences into a datafied population.Yet, the present year has seen a backsliding of decades of community-led advocacy work on the political participation of transgender persons.A preliminary tabulation of electors’ summary data from Assam, Bihar, Delhi, Goa, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Kerala, Odisha, Puducherry, Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal paints a grim picture of current SIR-based electoral exclusion. The total electorate fell from 62.6 crore electors before SIR to 55.1 crore afterwards, a net decline of 11.91%. Transgender electors recorded the sharpest proportional decline. Their numbers fell from 35,870 to 24,811, a reduction of 30.8%, which is more than 2.5 times the overall percentage decline.Source: Tabulation of released SIR data. The estimated % change in the elector population is calculated through a cross-tabulation of the statistical records maintained by the Election Commission of India and the SIR Summary details released by the Chief Election Officer of Various State Election Commissions.Delhi (-65%), Maharashtra (-49%), Karnataka (-43%), and Uttar Pradesh (-37%) saw the largest declines in the number of registered transgender electors. Interestingly, these are the same states and UTs that had to carry out special enrolment drives in the past to reach out to the transgender communities – Delhi in 2023 and Maharashtra in 2017.Citizenship, family and voter mapping practicesWhile the above statistics discuss the extent of the bureaucratic fallout, its deeper mechanisms and nature require us to delve into the evolving link between citizenship and electoral rolls, as well as the logistics of voter-mapping practices.Ashwin [name changed], a trans masculine person working in Bangalore, shares his ordeal. “I applied for my voter ID during the SIR drive in Karnataka. I had left my natal family, which is based in Maharashtra, ten years ago when I was being pressured into marriage. Since then, I have not been in touch with my family, and they do not know where I am. However, I found my parents’ names in the 2002 voter list and filed my application. I thought there would be no problem. Eventually, I got a notice saying that my name and my father’s name did not match. I thought the error might be due to a language difference between Marathi and Kannada. When I reached out to my BLO, she asked me to get my father’s documents, such as Aadhaar or a passport, so they could validate my parentage. I come from a small village. My parents never had a passport. I am not in touch with them. I tried to search among some of my college documents. I found a one-sided copy of my father’s Aadhaar card and my caste certificate. Nonetheless, I was determined to discuss with the BLO why an adult needs parentage documents when he is no longer in active association with his family. The BLO was unable to understand my situation and pressed the argument that everyone under the age of 40 had to show some form of documentation regarding their family. My name and gender on my primary documents differed from those on my supporting documents. The irony of the situation is that I have been part of sensitisation training of government officials on how to document transgender persons in an affirmative way, and here I was on the receiving end of zero governmental learning. Eventually, I scheduled a hearing with the ERO (Electoral Registration Officer) to escalate the matter. He told me that even if he overlooks the mismatch in my name and gender across a few documents when he uploads the documents on the ECI’s digital system, the system will reject the documents automatically, and the error will be reviewed by a different person in the hierarchy, whom the applicant cannot meet personally to explain their situation.”Ashwin’s predicament points to a contradiction in our popular understanding of voting rights in India as “individuated”, in which the voter is the bearer of the right to vote. A careful examination of voter mapping practices in India may reveal logistical limitations to this assumption. Historically, the framework of voter mapping in India has been based on the household, the static elemental unit of an ever-growing matrix called a “Nation”. The individual (voter) was not considered a fundamental unit in mapping practices. It was too mobile a building block for a mammoth and decentralised exercise like datafying the world’s largest voting population. Therefore, between the immovable verticality (lineage) of the household and the radical horizon of human movement (migration/displacement), the household became the organising point for mapping a newly independent nation.The Election Commission of India and its subsidiaries made periodic changes to the electoral roll at the household level based on life eventualities such as births, deaths, migration, missing status and other informational/clerical changes. However, the instrumentality of the household in voter mapping practices formalised a disenfranchising logic that links one’s access to adult suffrage to a progeny-based endorsement. Citizens who are no longer in active association with their natal family or who face hostility from their birth family vis-à-vis their gender identity risk being estranged from their right to vote.As political scientists Anupama Roy and Ujjwal Kumar Singh point out in their book, Election Commission of India: Institutionalising Democratic Uncertainties, the task of the ECI was limited to the management of the electoral rolls (electoral management) and not to ascertaining one’s citizenship (people management).A bare reading of the Constitution and the Representation of the People Act of 1950 and 1951 indicates no such overlap between the administrative functions of voter registration and determining citizenship. The concept of citizenship in Articles 5 and 6 of the Constitution was deeply informed by the political realities of a post-partition India. The Constituent Assembly left the power to future governments to legislate on the notion of citizenship, given the contentious task of bringing together a fractured geography into a unified polity. The political reading of this nation-building process becomes evident in the enactment of the Citizenship Act of 1955. Unlike its present form, the original Act was based on the broader principle of jus soli (right of the soil/birthplace) rather than jus sanguinis (right of the blood/descent) because one’s membership in a nation could not be contingent on one’s membership in a family, keeping in mind the social uprooting and separation thousands of civilians experienced in the Indian subcontinent.Therefore, one’s birth in a particular geography, irrespective of one’s descent, came to be the dominant assimilating logic of post-partition India. When read in consonance with Article 325 of the Constitution of India, which states, “no person shall be ineligible for inclusion in the electoral roll on the grounds of their religion, race, caste, or sex”, it provided safeguards to the citizenship status of socially marginalised and displaced persons.Over the following decades, the Citizenship Act 1955 was successively amended to shift from the principle of jus soli to jus sanguinis, intertwining family lineage with the nation. It was cradled in the notion that India had reached a critical mass through integrating different communities into the constitutional scheme of a democracy. Further, in the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision in Inderjit Barua & Others v. Election Commission of India, 1984, the ECI’s authority evolved and overlapped with the executive task of identifying citizens. Regardless, these legal and administrative developments remain divorced from the continued criminalisation and persecution of transgender and gender diverse communities in India.First question their identity, then their citizenshipKatyayini Saksham, a vocal cultural critic and Bahujan transgender woman from Delhi, discusses, “In India, we are witnessing an ongoing silent genocide of transness. Every day since the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act 2026, my community and I have been denied access to basic public amenities like gender-affirming health care. The State first wouldn’t let us live in our truth; if we choose to do it regardless, they deny our existence, and if we still live through that turmoil, they disenfranchise our voices by making it harder for us to vote.”When the fallout of the SIR exercise fathomed alongside the central government’s rushed introduction and passage of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act 2026, one comes to realise how the colonial logic of elimination gets legislatively implemented. The 2026 Act not only sets aside the principle of self-determination but also rationalises the legislation through the spectre of the “fake transgender”. This politics of authenticity, riding on the coattails of the government’s track record of “omissive discrimination,” finds its sharpest summarisation in an exchange before the Supreme Court of India. On May 4, 2026, while hearing Senior Advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi’s submissions in a batch of petitions challenging the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, Chief Justice Surya Kant raised concerns about the misuse of self-identification to claim reservations and other welfare entitlements. The irony was writ large. Senior counsels had to remind the highest constitutional court that transgender persons have no reservation to misuse in the first place.The existing law bureaucratically declares any gender non-conforming or transgender person without a transgender ID card as an imposter. It hides the fact that till date, less than 10% of the transgender persons recorded in the Census 2011 have been issued a transgender ID card by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment. To put it in perspective, the Union Minister for Social Justice and Empowerment has effectively declared 9 in every 10 transgender persons to be criminals awaiting to be apprehended by the Public and the Police.This narrowing of recognition is doubled down by the ECI’s systematic exclusion of transgender persons from modes of political participation. SIR resorts to progeny-based rules in its digital infrastructure, ERONET, to flag entries that show a mismatch in name, gender or parent’s name. As seen in Ashwin’s case, it shifts the test of citizenship from international borders to the Indian family, and the appellate authority to address public grievances from the locality to technology.But the biggest constitutional travesty remains the NDA government’s ticking time bomb of a move to base public services (welfare programmes, opportunities and employment) on the voter ID card. On November 3, Union minister for panchayati raj, Lallan Singh, announced that “voter identity cards will serve as the basis for identifying beneficiaries and processing payments for welfare schemes under the panchayati raj ministry”. It signals a dangerous political precedent. The ruling Union government, under the awkward realisation of its own failure to motivate transgender and gender diverse persons into the fold of democracy through meaningful redistribution of material rights, representation and recognition, has shifted to a full-blown political onslaught against transgender persons to evade public scrutiny and constitutional accountability.On TDOR, let us remember this too.Vaivab Das is a PhD scholar at the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi and a Fulbright Nehru Doctoral Fellow at the University of California, Berkeley. They research at the intersections of gender, elections and law.