New Delhi: The Supreme Court has suspended the life sentence of two convicts – Bipinchand Kanhaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya in the Bilkis Bano rape case that occurred during the 2002 Gujarat riots, and granted them bail. Joshi and Modhiya are part of the group of 11 convicts, all associated with a Hindu mob, serving life terms for gang-raping Bano.During the anti-Muslim riots of 2002, when Hindu mobs attacked Bano’s village and started setting Muslim homes on fire, she and 16 relatives fled for their lives. She was 19, mother to a three-year-old daughter and was pregnant with her second child. Rioters snatched her three-year-old daughter from her and killed her. Nearly 2,000 people, mostly Muslims, were killed in what was one of the worst religious violence in the country.All the men convicted of the crimes were freed in 2022 after a Gujarat government order. Their release and subsequent felicitation by right-wing activists had caused much outrage. But it was not clear at that time if the Union government okayed their release. Also read: In Her Own Words: What Bilkis Bano Went Through in 2002The Gujarat government had decided to release the prisoners despite objections from the Central Bureau of Investigation whose chief said that no leniency should be shown and that the crimes were “heinous, grave and serious”. The convicts were released in August 2022, coinciding with 75 years of India’s independence. In 2024, the Supreme Court overturned the order.Pain, shock and disbeliefThe 11 rioters were jailed in 2011 for life in the gang rape and murder case. Fourteen members of Bano’s family were killed in the violence, including her daughter, whose head was smashed on the ground by her perpetrators in Limkheda, in Gujarat’s Dahod district.On October 28 this year, 24 years after the anti-Muslim riots, a Supreme Court bench of Justices M.M. Sundresh and P.B. Varale granted bail to two of the convicts – Joshi and Mordhiya – stating that the two had been incarcerated for more than 17 years. The order, however, was uploaded on the website only on November 15.Bano has expressed shock and disbelief over the Supreme Court’s order suspending the life sentences and granting bail to the two men.In a statement, Bano said, “I make this statement even when words come slowly through fresh tears of pain, shock and disbelief. I still cannot believe that once again, for the second time, an order has been passed by the Supreme Court without calling me up and without hearing me. I learnt of this through press reports.”Former judge, Jyotsna Yagnik, who convicted 32 people – including Maya Kodnani, who had been part of Chief Minister Narendra Modi’s cabinet – for the Naroda Patiya massacre of 97 Muslims in Ahmedabad during the 2002 communal riots believes that Bano too had the right to be heard. Speaking to The Wire, Yagnik said, “At an international scenario, concepts of victimology have gripped so well, that while administrating criminal justice it cannot be ignored irrespective of the fact as to which authority deals with the issue on the hand. A victim must be heard in view of BNSS as well. Justice must be seen and felt for the victim as well. This case has crippled the victim for her whole life.”She also noted that it is only a grant of bail and not the final hearing or verdict. “The suspension of sentence is temporary and it is after 17 years of incarnation,” she said.Also read: ‘Justice for Bilkis’: In Protests Across India, a Singular DemandHuman rights campaigner Shabnam Hashmi added, “The Bilkis Bano case is one of the most horrific instances of targeted communal and sexual violence, and the long struggle of a survivor to hold those responsible accountable”Hashmi believes that the top court’s decision to suspend the life sentences and grant bail to two of the convicts is deeply disturbing and a serious setback to a survivor’s long and difficult struggle for justice. “The Supreme Court had itself quashed the illegal remission granted to the convicts in 2024. It is shocking that now it has gone against its own judgment,” Hashmi told The Wire.Bile-churning bloody memoriesOn February 27, 2002, a train with Hindu pilgrims returning from Ayodhya stopped at Godhra, a small town in Gujarat’s Panchmahal district, approximately 150 kilometres from the state capital, Gandhinagar. After an alleged altercation occurred between the Muslim vendors working at the station and the passengers inside the Sabarmati Express, a fire is said to have erupted in one of the coaches of the train, killing 59 people.Even after two decades have passed since the incident, the details of what happened before the fire remain unclear.Consequently, on February 28, 2002, Hindu mobs set out blaming Muslims for the deaths of the pilgrims, resulting in waves of violence. Rapes, loots and murders took place, with Muslims being the major target. The violence lasted for more than two months.The Gujarat government, then headed by now Prime Minister Narendra Modi, had alleged that most of the dead were karsevaks who had gone to Ayodhya to campaign for the construction of the Ram Mandir.For Junaid Pathan, who was barely 12 years old when the riots shocked his home, even thinking about the riots, or reading a news flash saying ‘Gujarat Riots’, feels like bile churning in his gut. “Bilkis baaji is one of the many, many women who were violated like this, seeing her get closer to punishing the perpetrators gave a sense of closure to several other victims of the riots, but now it feels like all our wounds are burning again,” he said.Another witness of the 2002 riots who wanted to remain anonymous said that the Muslim community never forgot the riots and would never forget this travesty of justice too. “They are mocking her pain,” they said.On the matter, Mujahid Nafees, Convener of the Minority Coordination Committee (MCC), Gujarat, said, “We respect the authority and independence of the Supreme Court, and we fully recognise that every accused or convicted person has legal rights available under the law. But the rights of the survivor cannot become invisible in the process. Bilkis Bano must have an effective opportunity to be heard when a judicial decision directly affects the custody and release of persons convicted of crimes against her and her family.”He added that, “Bilkis Bano cannot be treated as a bystander. She has fought for justice for more than two decades. She has endured unimaginable violence, lost members of her family and repeatedly approached the justice system. At the very least, she deserves to know when proceedings concerning the release of the convicted persons are taking place and to have her concerns regarding her safety and dignity placed before the Court, in accordance with law.”Modi, the chief minister of Gujarat at the time of the riots, was heavily and internationally criticised for not using his office to prevent the days of massacre. In 2008, the Supreme Court appointed a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to investigate major cases from the 2002 violence. In 2012, the SIT filed a closure report stating there was “no prosecutable evidence” against Modi and 63 other officials regarding allegations of a larger conspiracy. In December 2013, a Metropolitan Magistrate court in Ahmedabad accepted the SIT’s closure report and rejected a protest petition filed by Zakia Jafri – widow of former Congress MP Ehsan Jafri, who was killed in the riots.Finally, in June 2022, a three-judge bench of the apex court dismissed Jafri’s final appeal, upholding the SIT’s findings. The court ruled that there was no material evidence of a state-sponsored conspiracy and noted that administrative failures during spontaneous mass violence do not automatically prove criminal complicity.