On November 16, senior officers of Indian Accounts and Audit Services gathered in the national capital to celebrate the 6th National Audit Diwas. India’s constitutional audit office has celebrated this day since 2021. This year also, I have missed attending the event in the national capital as well as in Bengaluru, where I have lived ever since 2011. However, there is something within my heart that tells me not to miss writing down my thoughts about why this constitutional institute matters for the robustness of India’s democratic life.I have often been asked how someone who studied literature and linguistics, and spent youthful years volunteering with environmental movements in India came to fall in love with public audit. My love story within this constitutional institute’s work started somewhere in the year 2002. I was a young environmental activist and my work involved keeping a track of news getting published in Gujarati and English language newspapers.The Times of India’s Ahmedabad edition had carried a news article about indiscriminate market borrowing by Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Limited (SSNNL), a Gujarat state owned PSU. A curious young activist within me told me to go down the history lane and check how Narmada Bachao Andolan talked about the first efforts by SSNNL to borrow money from the capital market in India by issuing bonds. In its October 30, 1993, issue, the Economic and Political Weekly had talked about the company accessing capital markets, and in an article published in the same weekly on October 15, 1993, senior NBA activist Himanshu Thakkar had questioned, ‘Can Sardar Sarovar Project ever be financed?’This made me curious to read the exact comments from that CAG audit report on Gujarat (commercial) for the year ending March 31, 2001. So, a few weeks after, I called up my journalist friend Rajeev Shah and requested him to share his copy of the said audit report. Holding a copy of a CAG audit report and reading it cover-to-cover made me wonder if the audited entity paid attention to the critique and started the course correction as outlined in recommendations that CAG auditors make.I was someone who had gone to Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi, to pursue a second Masters’ in Arts degree, but I never pushed myself to write a civil services exam. So until 2002, I couldn’t have spelled out a full form of IAAS without making a mistake.However, once I started reading CAG audit reports and used audit findings to raise public accountability concerns, there was no stopping. In 2003, while working as a young researcher with South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People, I used to spend hours at the Indian Institute of Public Administration library and the first floor of JNU’s library, trying to access what CAG audits told the nation on the question of irrigation dams. In October that year, I then started writing a monthly column for India Together; my articles mostly picked up CAG Audit findings.Writing about CAG findings once in a month allowed me to understand that side of public auditing which was beyond scams and corruption. Soon, I started getting readers’ feedback and although I was not working for a daily newspaper, those comments encouraged me to keep writing.For those who are interested in understanding the importance of CAG of India, my recommendation would be to pick up M.S. Ramayyar’s 1967 book, Indian Audit and Accounts Department: Its Evolution, Organisation and Functions. In 1990, a four volume history of CAG of India was published thanks to meticulous research by R.K. Chandrasekharan, who had spent many years with IAAD and was a former Deputy CAG of India. Writing a foreword to this publication, the then CAG director T.N. Chaturvedi stated, “No organisation can and should insulate itself to well-meaning criticism from within and without. There is a continual self-appraisal with reference to the improvements in methodologies and techniques by other SAIs near and far”. There have been two more volumes of history of the Institute written by Vijay Kumar that spans the period 1991 to 2007.Why do these words still ring in my ears? Well, sadly after his tenure as CAG of India (1984-1990), Chaturvedi went on to join a political party, contested a Lok Sabha election unsuccessfully and was elected as member to Rajya Sabha from Uttar Pradesh twice in 1992 and 1998. The constitutional and public accountability ethics demand that someone who gets to serve as the CAG of India does not aspire for such designations.C.G. Somiah, who was the eighth CAG of India (1990-1996) wrote his memoirs The Honest Always stand Alone (Niyogi Books, 2010). By the mid-1990s, as Somiah’s tenure was about to end, K.P. Joseph wrote an incisive article in Economic and Political Weekly titled ‘Selecting the next CAG’. Similarly, in an article written for EPW in 1986 titled ‘Accountability of Government Audit in India’, Joseph highlights the issues that plague India’s Supreme Audit Institution. The concerns articulated by Joseph still remain relevant, as three PILs await hearings at the Supreme Court of India.In 2017, one of these three PILs filed by Anupam Kulsrestha, a former Deputy CAG of India cites from the constitutional assembly debates to point out why it is important to keep the appointment free from political intervention. At present, the procedure doesn’t offer citizens an assurance that the appointment is not influenced by political, executive and legislative pulls, since only a panel of names is suggested by the cabinet secretary to the prime minister who then recommends his selection to the President.In October 2005, I wrote an article terming the government’s move to limit CAG’s mandate of auditing PSUs as ill-advised. This was followed by another article in December 2005 where I argued that CAG’s audits of PSUs must stay. The commercial audit wing within the IAAD was also writing to the then president appraising him about how ill-advised this move was. I was pleasantly surprised when some senior IAAS officers requested me to attend their press briefing in 2006.In 2007, former deputy CAG, B.P. Mathur published a book titled, Government Accountability and Public Audit: Reengineering the CAG of India (Eastern Book Corporation), where he puts forward several suggestions for the much needed reforms in this constitutional institute’s internal functioning.In November 2008, the biannual conference of Accountants General that took place during the tenure of Vinod Rai as CAG of India had a dedicated portal that carried four thematic papers, videos and texts of speeches and group discussions as well as press briefings. It was during this conference that CAG auditors felt the need to bring amendments to CAG (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Services) Act, 1971. So many years from that moment, there has not been any revisions to the legislation.After 2014, the delays in audit findings seeing the light of the day has worsened. Around Covid-19 lockdown, it was increasingly being felt that there was a systemic slowing down of audit cycle – the time taken from the start of audit to finalization of the audit report – so researcher Abhishek Punetha and me decided to do a comparative analysis of time taken in finalisation of an audit report across tenure of Vinod Rai, Shashikant Sharma and Rajiv Mehrishi as CAG of India, relying on publicly available reference dates. Before this, Abhishek and I had analysed the delays in tabling of CAG audit reports in state legislative assemblies. To effect accountability, one of the recommendations that we suggested was that the CAG of India shall publish on its website dates when a finalised audit report was sent to the governor’s/President’s office and another column stating whether the said report has been tabled in assembly/parliament or not.In August 2009, one of my octogenarian readers, a former IAAS officer wrote to me in a personal correspondence: “All major countries have revised audit legislation in recent years, but India has not made any attempt for almost 40 years. The India Audit department is terminally ill and a proper diagnosis of what is wrong and some first aid measures are needed immediately. The Indian Audit Department has excellent employees, who can work very well, if there is proper leadership, which is totally absent now.”That reader ended his feedback saying, “I wish you good luck in your efforts to improve audit in our country”. I wondered whether writing one article a month on the audit findings indeed qualified as making sincere efforts to improve audit in our country. So even as I came back to academic research beginning my PhD in 2010 and taking a teaching position at a prominent liberal philanthropic university, I continued to voice my concerns on the work of this important constitutional institute.Himanshu Upadhyaya is Associate Professor at Prestige University, Indore. Views expressed are personal.