Bolpur (Bengal): Ratan Sheikh was not in handcuffs when the police walked him into an abandoned brick kiln at Uchkaran village in Birbhum on Sunday (November 15) night. They had brought him there, they say, to recover a gun he had hidden. By their account, he pulled it out, opened fire and was shot dead when they fired back. His body came to the hospital with several bullet wounds.Then, a villager says, the police did something else. They called this person over and showed him a gun, a bullet, some pieces of glass and something that looked like a file. Then they piled the lot together and set it on fire.Sheikh was the fifth man killed in a police encounter in West Bengal in four months, and the fourth in less than three weeks. Six months into the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government coming to power, Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari is far from apologetic. “If the police are attacked, they will not shower flowers,” he said. He said the police have been given a free hand to deal with criminals and with crimes against women.One script, five timesThe killings have come one after another. On July 8, Prabhas Mondal, the main accused in the rape and murder of a 12-year-old girl, was killed at Baruipur in South 24 Parganas.Around midnight on October 27, Prahlad Das, 23, accused of raping and murdering a 17-year-old schoolgirl near the stage of a cultural event, was killed at Gaighata in North 24 Parganas.The same day, Samaul Sheikh, accused of murdering and dismembering BJP worker Sujit Mondal at Dhulian in Murshidabad’s Samserganj, died in CID custody.On November 9, Dilip Roy, accused of the rape and murder of a 12-year-old girl in Raiganj, was killed near the Bihar border.The November 13 encounter in Bolpur is the latest one.Each time, the story has been the same. The accused is taken out to reconstruct the crime, often at night, often not handcuffed. A gun appears. The police say they fired in self-defence. In Baruipur, Gaighata and Samserganj, they say the accused fired several rounds, yet rights groups say no officer was seriously hurt in any of the three incidents.“What is surprising is that the same explanation is being repeated in case after case,” advocate Shamim Ahmed told The Wire. “In every case, the accused is taken for a reconstruction of the crime scene with his hands free, and somehow a loaded pistol becomes available to him. And then the incident is simply given a name – encounter!”Also read: As Key Accused in Bengal Minor’s Rape and Murder Is Killed in Encounter, Police Can’t Escape ScrutinyHe said none of the cases has videography, footage from the police vehicle or footage from body cameras. “After the first encounter, the police could have learnt from the incident and ensured videography during subsequent operations.”He warned that the chief minister had already taken sides. “The chief minister’s comments, made even before the investigation has begun, could influence the inquiry,” he said.Police encounters became a feature of BJP-ruled Assam from 2021. Critics now say Bengal is copying the Uttar Pradesh “model”, where the political leadership openly endorses “encounter” killings as swift justice for heinous crimes.Ratan Sheikh. Photo: By arrangement.Out of jail, to a kilnRatan Sheikh’s last three days do not add up.On Friday, November 13, he walked out of prison on bail. According to police sources, Sheikh, from Santra village in Nanoor, faced 36 criminal cases for theft, robbery and snatching. On release, he went to the Pakurtala area of Layekbazar. That same day, a plain-clothed officer, Biswajit Das, rode up on a motorcycle to arrest him in another case. Sheikh allegedly shot him below the knee and ran. Das is being treated at SSKM Hospital in Kolkata.The police have not said how a man out of prison for only a few hours came to have a gun. Nor have they said why they moved to arrest him almost as soon as he was free.Police, however, said that they eventually caught him at a relative’s house in Nawabhat, near the Birbhum-Purba Bardhaman border, and that he told them he had hidden the gun in a brick kiln at Uchkaran. Uchkaran is 76 km away and in the opposite direction. Sheikh had no motorcycle and no car at his disposal. The police have not explained when he made that journey, across open fields and brick kilns, to hide the gun.Police took him to Uchkaran at night, without handcuffs, to have him dig the weapon out with his own hands. They displayed bullet marks on their vehicle as proof of a gunfight. They have not said what weapon he used that kept firing without running dry, or where that gun is now.The bullet marks on a car, shown as purported proof of a gunfight.On the night of November 15, the district police called a press conference, and then cancelled it. “There are multiple bullet wounds on Ratan Sheikh’s body,” said Dibakar Sardar, acting superintendent of Bolpur Subdivisional Hospital. “Further details will be known after the post-mortem examination.”On November 16, Birbhum Superintendent of Police Vidit Raj Bhundesh promised “an independent and impartial investigation”. He did not clearly state what steps the police was taking to investigate a killing by its own men. He had no answer for why the operation happened at night, why Sheikh was made to fetch the gun instead of officers recovering it, why he was not handcuffed or why nothing was filmed. To each point he gave the same reply. “It was a question of police self-defence.”He did not respond to queries from The Wire.The cameras came down in AugustIn Samserganj, the trail goes back two months before the killing.Samaul Sheikh was arrested in August for the murder of one Sujit Mondal. When Adhikari publicly complained that the case was stalling, the local police chief was transferred and the CID took over. Samaul’s family says Mondal’s body has still not been found. Only a leg has turned up, and no one has proved it is his.On October 26, a court handed Samaul over to the CID for a reconstruction of the crime, for which he was taken out from jail. The next day, he was dead. The CID says he was shot in a first-floor room he had rented since August, in a market near Samserganj’s old Dak Bungalow.Also read: Two Encounters in a Day, Rising Crimes Against Women: Bengal’s Law and Order Leaves More Questions Than AnswersA fact-finding team from the Association for Protection of Democratic Rights (APDR) went there on November 2. The market’s owner, Mustafizur Rahman, told them the police had taken down every CCTV camera in the building in August and that they had taken the keys to the room as well. It remained locked until the police opened it with those keys on October 27. No camera saw Samaul climb the stairs. A shopkeeper next door said he never heard shots fired.The officer-in-charge of Samserganj police station, Kunal Kanti Das, told the team that none of his officers was in the room. According to APDR, only two CID officers, one of them a deputy superintendent, took Samaul upstairs. Das said questioning inside a room must be filmed, and that any encounter must be followed by a judicial inquiry.The police say Samaul grabbed an officer’s gun in a scuffle and fired three rounds. The room is about 10 feet by 10. His wife, Rajeda Bibi, said the only wound on his body was a single bullet on the right side of his head, above the ear. APDR vice-president Ranjit Sur said a real struggle for a service weapon leaves stray shots, other injuries and defensive wounds. A single shot to the head, he said, is the mark of an execution.Samaul drove a vehicle carrying bidis. He leaves behind Rajeda and two children, aged eight and five. She had seen him in Jangipur Jail the day before he died. He told her he would soon get bail.APDR wants a judicial inquiry under a sitting high court judge, the CID officers suspended and charged with murder, a second post-mortem conducted outside the district and Rs 50 lakh and a job for Rajeda.Midnight in GaighataOn the same day, in Gaighata, Prahlad Das was taken out for a reconstruction at midnight, again with his hands uncuffed.“Even in broad daylight, the police illegally take prisoners with a rope tied around their waist or in handcuffs. Taking him [Das] at night with his hands free is therefore deeply suspicious and motivated,” APDR said. An escaping prisoner is to be shot in the legs, it pointed out, and a police revolver should not be easy to snatch if officers carry it as the rules require. “We do not find the police account credible at all.”The group also counted a string of deaths in police custody since Baruipur, in Kandi, Halisahar and Bijpur, Canning and Dubrajpur. In none, it said, has anyone been punished.The numbersThe government’s defenders point to crime, and those numbers are terrible too. State Crime Records Bureau figures obtained under a Right to Information Act request by former Rajya Sabha Member of Parliament Saket Gokhale and released by the Trinamool Congress show 2,454 rapes, 600 murders and more than 32,000 cases of grievous hurt between May 1 and September 24.The National Crime Records Bureau recorded 1,110 rapes in the state in all of 2023.BJP leaders say the figures reflect FIRs the previous government suppressed. Some senior IPS officers, speaking anonymously, say crimes against women, POCSO offences and violent assaults are rising.Rights activists say such crimes generate exactly the kind of anger that encounters feed on. Kill a man accused of raping a child, they say, and the crowd sees instant justice delivered, while the state’s failure to stop the crime goes unexamined.Also read: Three Bengal Content Creators Critical of BJP Government Face Police Action, One Still in CustodyFilmmaker Kamaleswar Mukherjee called the killings unconstitutional. “Who will live and who will die cannot be decided in this manner,” he told The Wire. “Those who derive pleasure from pulling the trigger ultimately face terrible consequences. Our political leaders should learn from those examples.”“They are promoting belief in encounters, satisfying the desire for retribution among a section of society and developing strategies to carry out the entire process without opposition,” he said.Sur fears the worst is yet to come. “Ultimately, the BJP will extend this policy of encounters into the political sphere. Joint attacks involving security forces, the police and the RSS will begin across the state,” he said, referring to the BJP’s founding outfit, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh.The BJP-RSS combine has faced such allegations in the past as well.APDR has filed a case over the Baruipur killing and is collecting evidence on Samserganj. In Birbhum, Sur said, the police and the RSS together stopped rights workers from doing their job.Activists also tie the killings to a wider climate of fear. They allege the government plans to hand land to corporate outfits and take back plots poor farmers received under Operation Barga, the Left Front’s landmark sharecropper reform.‘Calcutta 71’ againIn Santiniketan, the news reached Asim Chattaraj, director of the cine club Rohitashwa, on Monday (November 16) morning.“We saw in Mrinal Sen’s film Calcutta 71 how young Naxalites were killed in encounters. Now we are hearing that criminals and dissenters are being shot dead. It is horrifying,” he said. “The sounds of people running desperately to save their lives, their gasping, screams and cries, all those memories of terror seem to be returning,” he said.Nanoor, where Ratan Sheikh came from, knows violence. The area has seen decades of clashes between landowners and sharecroppers and between parties fighting for territory, along with bomb attacks, massacres and captured villages. Communist Party of India (Marxist) ex-legislator Ananda Das was murdered in front of his home there.But even Nanoor has never seen a silence like these. Across party lines, the poor and the middle class of Nanoor have fallen silent.This report, first published at 10.14 pm on November 18, 2026, was republished at 8.45 am on November 19, 2026, with additional details.