New Delhi: West Bengal Governor R.N. Ravi praised the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) at an event held in New Delhi to mark the organisation’s centenary year on Tuesday (November 17). Calling the RSS the “the nation’s shield”, he said that as long as it existed, India and its future were secure. He said the country had strayed from its path after independence by engaging in “appeasement” on religious lines.After referring to the Khilafat Movement, launched by Indian Muslims after World War I, Ravi accused the Congress party of remaining silent during the “massacre of Hindus” during the contemporaneous Moplah Rebellion in 1921. However, his remarks omitted significant facts regarding the Congress’s past role in emancipatory movements and during other historical junctures. His speech circled around political claims that originate and circulate within the RSS and its offshoots.Ravi made these remarks at the ‘Bharat Gaurav Utsav 2026’ held in the Civil Services Officers Institute (CSOI) auditorium in Chanakyapuri. The event also marked the tenth anniversary of the Chanakya Varta Publishing Group, which publishes writings emerging from the Sangh Parivar.Former RSS general secretary (sarkaryavah) Suresh ‘Bhaiyyaji’ Joshi, Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) patron Dinesh Chandra and the Sangh’s all-India contact head, Ramlal, were present at the occasion. The event featured the release of a book titled Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh: Tithi Darpan, compiled by Vijay Kumar.Governor Ravi was the chief guest, while Joshi presided over the ceremony.Similarities in the speeches of Bhaiyyaji Joshi and the GovernorA notable feature of the governor’s speech was that it echoed many of the ideas and claims in Joshi’s address. Both described India’s present as a period of renewed awakening. They claimed that the country was capable of global leadership and claimed the RSS was key to India’s security and future.Joshi referred to “six golden chapters” in history chronicled by Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, the Hindu-nationalist inspiration of the RSS. The seventh golden chapter, Joshi said, was being written today, and it began after Shivaji’s coronation, which took place in 1674.Ravi returned to the present, saying, “The country has undergone a transformation. A consciousness has awakened within society, fostering a favourable environment…India is now awakening, and we are witnessing the results and positive outcomes.”Also read: Senior RSS Leader Bhaiyyaji Joshi Steps Down as Ram Temple Trust Patron Amid ‘Fund Theft’ RowJoshi said that India and its culture have endured despite numerous invasions and setbacks because India was invincible, Mrityunjay, the conqueror of death. No force can destroy India, and the country has a role to play in promoting the welfare of the world, he stressed.Echoing a similar view, Ravi remarked, “It is distinctive of India that whenever its identity or spiritual foundations have come under severe attack or been called into question, a force has emerged from within to reawaken society ensuring that India is not only saved from destruction – for India is eternal, sanatan. It renews and strengthens its power.”Suresh ‘Bhaiyyaji’ Joshi, former sarkaryavah (general secretary) of the RSS. Photo: Ankit Raj/The Wire HindiDescribing India as capable of leading the world, Joshi said, “Don’t be surprised if, ten years from now, the entire world chants ‘Bharat Mata Ki Jai’.”Ravi, too, said that the world was looking to India with hope, and expected it to lead. “The world knows that India is capable of leading – and that it is already doing so.”His speech characterised communism as a negative ideology. Ravi, meanwhile, accused certain people of spreading confusion and creating disorder in the country without naming any recent movements, including the one against “vote theft.”Left-wing leader Neha Bora and other progressive figures have been active in these movements.Ravi said, “We are seeing how some people in the country are trying to weaken our strength by spreading confusion and sowing disorder. We also know they will not succeed, because we are confident that this awakened India will never accept such negative thinking.”The two speakers also expressed similar views about the RSS. Joshi said the organisation aimed to strengthen and empower India by bringing society together through volunteers guided by “good values”. Ravi described the Sangh as the “nation’s shield”, saying, “As long as the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh exists, India is safe. India’s future is secure.”Also read: The Vishwaguru Complex: Supremacist Rhetoric and National DeclineHe addressed Joshi as Rishi and extolled RSS founder Keshav Baliram Hedgewar.The Governor said that the organisation had reached this point through the dedication, sacrifice and selflessness of thousands of pracharaks and millions of volunteers.The Sangh and people associated with it have repeatedly faced allegations of involvement in violent incidents, including Gandhi’s assassination and the demolition of the Babri masjid.Views about KhilafatIn his speech, Ravi interpreted India’s independence movement, saying it was shaping up as an organised mass campaign, but by 1916, compromises with communal forces had begun. He noted that separate representation for the Muslim community in the British Indian Legislative Councils was proposed, and the organisation leading the independence movement agreed to it.This was a reference to the Congress party and the Lucknow Pact of 1916, accepting the Muslim League’s demand for separate electorates.However, Ravi’s statement presented this development solely as a process of dividing society.The historical context of the Lucknow Pact was the December 1916 Congress–Muslim League joint plan demanding constitutional reform and self-government under British rule. This plan also provided for separate electorates for Muslims and, in some provinces, representation greater than their share of the population.A separate electoral system was undoubtedly a political compromise, and it was criticised at the time. But to present it as the Congress party’s surrender to communal forces overlooks that it intended to present a joint political demand to British rule.Ravi referred to the Khilafat movement, which began in 1919 saying, “A few years later [1924], the Caliphate was abolished in Turkey, and the rebellion against ending it took place not in any Islamic country but in India, where it even turned violent. Thousands of Hindus were massacred, and thousands were forcibly converted. At the time, the organisation leading the freedom movement remained silent. Not only did it remain silent, it joined its voice with ‘theirs’ in calling for the restoration of the caliphate.”This statement is historically inaccurate. The Khilafat Movement began in 1919, followed by the Non-Cooperation Movement in 1920 and the Moplah Rebellion in 1921. The period saw clashes involving Khilafat supporters and Non-Cooperation volunteers, as well as confrontations with the British-Indian police.Also read: Attempts To Add Communal Colour to the Moplah Rebellion Are WrongThe Moplah Rebellion, meanwhile, was a distinct uprising against British authority and landlords. Ravi attributes the uprising to the Khilafat Movement and the support it received, but this overlooks the agrarian grievances and local conditions that also contributed to the rebellion.Accuses Congress of ‘appeasement’He did not name the Congress, but Ravi then said that India had “lost its way” after independence, when it could have moved towards a “glorious destiny” instead.He alleged that appeasing communal forces had set in motion divisions in the country along the lines of language, region, race and religion. He said that India’s diversity had come to be viewed as a source of difference rather than as a foundation for unity.However, Ravi did not clarify which policies or incidents he was referring to. He neither named any government nor provided any concrete example to support his allegations.‘Sangh is a family of ascetics’In his address, Ravi spoke highly of the RSS. He said, “We all know that the Sangh is a family of dedicated ascetics who simply do the work.”Recalling the founding of the Sangh, the governor said the circumstances in which it was established were far from ordinary. Referring to the Lucknow Pact and the Khilafat Movement, he alleged that the country had lost its direction during those years.“In those circumstances, a group of ascetics devoted to the nation came together as one family, and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh was formed. Since then, despite facing many obstacles and challenges, it has continued to serve the nation,” he said, without describing how it had done that.The governor said that he had never seen it put its achievements on display. He said, “The Sangh is marking its centenary year. I haven’t heard of it holding an exhibition of its achievements, as people and organisations usually do when they reach such a milestone. But the Sangh has done no such thing. It has continued working to accelerate its efforts to build society.”Also read: RSS Still Unregistered in India, ‘RSS Friends’ Registers With US Govt as ‘Foreign Agent’The RSS has been celebrating its centenary through numerous events spanning India and other countries, where, too, it has attracted controversies and opposition.Political remarks of a governorR.N. Ravi’s speech is significant because he holds the constitutional post of Governor of West Bengal. The governor’s role is not one in which to express allegiance to any political party or organisation.Under Article 159 of the constitution, the governor pledges, while taking the oath of office, to uphold the constitution and the law and to work for the welfare of the people of the state.In 2010, while examining the role of governors in B.P. Singhal v. Union of India, the Supreme Court said they are expected to remain politically neutral and owe their allegiance to the Constitution, not to any political party. The court clarified that governors are neither employees nor agents of the Union government.This does not mean that a governor cannot attend public or cultural events, or that they have no right to express views on history, culture and society. But when a governor attends an organisation’s event, describes it as the nation’s shield, calls its founders and leadership sages and revered figures, and targets Opposition parties and their political views and movements, questions arise about how impartial they remain while they hold a constitutional office.Should someone holding a constitutional post make political and ideological claims about any organisation – especially when their speech presents a lopsided view of historical events.Who is R.N. Ravi?Born in Patna, Bihar, R.N. Ravi briefly worked as a journalist before joining the Indian Police Service (IPS) in 1976. He later served in the Central Bureau of Investigation and the Intelligence Bureau. After retiring in 2012, he was appointed chairperson of the Joint Intelligence Committee under the Prime Minister’s Office in 2014, and became Deputy National Security Advisor in October 2018.He has represented the Indian government in peace talks with Naga organisations since 2014 and was appointed the governor of Nagaland in 2019. Naga groups and activists repeatedly accused him of trying to derail the peace process.In July 2020, a dispute arose after Ravi wrote to then Nagaland chief minister Neiphiu Rio, saying law and order had deteriorated in the state and that he would have to intervene. The state government issued a detailed statement asserting that the situation in Nagaland remained normal and peaceful.In 2021, he was appointed governor of Tamil Nadu, where his tenure was controversial due to his clashes with the then chief minister M.K. Stalin government. In 2022, the secular progressive alliance leading the state government sent a memorandum to President Draupadi Murmu urging her to dismiss Ravi. It was alleged that Ravi incited communal hatred and posed a threat to peace in the state.In July 2023, Stalin wrote to President Murmu again, saying that the governor was unfit for the office he occupied. Calling for his removal, Stalin accused him of “disparaging” Tamil culture, engaging in “cheap politics” and stoking “communal hatred”.Ravi was appointed governor of West Bengal shortly before this year’s Assembly elections. At the time, then chief minister Mamata Banerjee said the decision might be connected to the upcoming state elections.Translated by Naushin Rehman. Read the original on The Wire Hindi.