New Delhi: Leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi told the Supreme Court on Monday (November 16) that the Election Commission of India has failed to provide any proof that the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) was a unanimous decision taken by the Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and two Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.In a rejoinder affidavit in the Supreme Court, Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders have said that the poll body’s counter affidavit filed on October 26 says that the SIR was approved unanimously by the three commissioners, but it does not include any particulars or dates on which such approval was given. Nor, it says, does it contain the relevant notings or meetings to provide evidence that such approval was given.“No minutes of the meeting, file notings, recorded approvals, agenda, deliberations or other primary material evidencing the participation and approval of all three members have been produced with the counter-affidavit,” the rejoinder says.Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders have petitioned the Election Commission’s conduct of the SIR and the decision-making process within the commission through a writ petition. The petition also raises concerns about alleged voter deletions, changes to Form 6 and the functioning of ECINET. The case is scheduled for hearing on November 17 before a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant.The Wire has previously reported that the EC’s counter affidavit only underscored doubts over the SIR and how decisions were being taken within the top election body – from saying that the commission neither released nor authorised the release of internal notes, to admitting to confusion created over the use of Form 6, and failing to explain the wrongly excluded voters in Goa.Also read: ‘EC Has Not Taken a Decision on the 2025 SIR, No Info Available on 2003 Exercise’: EC’s Confounding RTI ResponseThe rejoinder said that the counter affidavit stated that the SIR had been unanimously approved at the very outset, “evidently recognising that it goes to the heart of the controversy, and yet did not annex the single page of noting or minutes that would have substantiated it”.It said that the court should not take into account “a bare assertion of unanimous decision of the Election Commissioners without perusal of the relevant recorded files”, when the poll body itself has stated that such decisions are recorded on official files.The rejoinder also said that the counter affidavit contradicts its own Right to Information (RTI) response, in which it admitted that the “the commission has so far not taken any decision on initiating a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) across the country in 2025”.“The counter affidavit does not explain when the decision to undertake a nationwide SIR was taken, where the decision was recorded, whether it was taken at a meeting or by circulation or how the RTI responses stating that no such decision had been taken are to be reconciled with the contents of the order dated 24.06.2025,” the rejoinder said.The rejoinder has further stated that while the objections raised by the two Election Commissioners Sandhu and Joshi are part of the case, and each member of the EC has been made a separate party in the case, the EC should have filed a separate counter affidavit to clarify their position. Instead the counter affidavit has been signed by a Deputy Election Commissioner on behalf of the CEC and the two ECs, who are all senior to him.“The petitioners submit that, where the very question is whether decisions attributed to the commission were taken with the knowledge, participation and approval of all its members, a general statement made by an administrative officer, on behalf of the Election Commission of India and all the Election Commissioners who are superior to him, cannot take the place of the relevant primary records or the direct explanation of the members concerned,” the rejoinder said.The rejoinder said that the two Election Commissioners wrote to the Cabinet Secretary separately is “itself inconsistent with the picture of unanimous functioning” presented by the Election Commission.“That two members of the commission found it necessary to address the Cabinet Secretary, and to issue a joint direction of their own, is itself inconsistent with the picture of unanimous functioning sought to be presented in the Counter-Affidavit,” it said.With regard to Form 6, the statutory form for enrolling new voters that has been a major point of contention, since it was amended in July for online applications, the rejoinder said that the counter affidavit by the Election Commission attempts to distinguish between the declaration attached to it, while admitting that it had been “entered into” the online page.“The respondents’ description of the declaration as a separate component does not alter the fact that an applicant accessing the online Form 6 process was required to encounter and complete the additional declaration as part of that process,” it said.The INDIA bloc leaders have further submitted that the concerns raised over the functioning of the ECINET that hold the voter registration and electoral rolls have not been addressed. They said that the functioning of the ECINET, the inability of local electoral officials to access the software to re-enrol voters as seen in the case of Goa where 97 electors were removed but could not be re-added have not been addressed, and instead the EC counter affidavit said that 88 electors were re-added through Form 6 applications.Also read: ECINET Audit Finds State-Level Access Could be Restricted by Election Commission, VIP Tags for VotersThe rejoinder said that “the counter-affidavit does not deny that the software lacked a facility to restore these electors; on the contrary, it confirms that the remedy adopted was a fresh application in Form 6 rather than restoration of the original entries.”The rejoinder has also pointed to the office order cited by the EC and said that it was brought in 1997 and does not pertains to the “design or configuration of electoral-roll software, the modification of statutory forms or application procedures, or the institution of litigation or appeals.”“The respondents have miserably failed to demonstrate how the said order, issued prior to the introduction of ECINET and the subsequent centralisation of electoral-roll database operations, specifically authorises the decisions and actions questioned in the present petition, including the relevant IT architecture and access arrangements, modifications to statutory application procedures, or the filing of appeals in the name of the commission,” it said.The rejoinder has also referred to the appeals made by CEO West Bengal officials against those voters who were cleared by tribunals and said that if the appeals were instituted as acts of the commission, “the respondents must disclose the decision of the commission authorising the same, together with the relevant approval and delegation records”.Separately the INDIA bloc leaders have also filed a set of “interrogatories” directed at the CEC, Sandhu, Joshi and senior ECI officials involved in the SIR asking for numbers and details of each files, electronic communications including on WhatsApp as well as the specific occasions when the two ECs recorded their objections on file.For our full coverage on the SIR and the issues it has brought to citizens, click here.