Kolkata: A book stall run by the Students’ Federation of India (SFI) outside Calcutta University came under attack on Wednesday (November 18) evening as the Communist Party of India (Marxist) student wing clashed with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh-affiliated Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) on College Street, Kolkata’s book district. Crude bombs, loud firecrackers, bricks, stones, water bottles, pieces of wood and eggs were hurled at the stall, according to the SFI and videos from the spot.The videos showed SFI members running to gather books from their tables before they could be damaged and students holding plastic chairs over their heads to shield themselves from eggs. The stall’s banner was torn and the police barricades separating the two groups were broken. In one video, SFI supporters alleged that an egg had been thrown at the national flag.Though police were present, there was little visible effort to bring the violence under control for much of the evening. No arrests or detentions had been reported till the filing of this report. The SFI blames the ABVP for the attack. The ABVP denies throwing bombs and says its own stall was also attacked. At the centre of the stall under siege was an unlikely bestseller: a book on Syama Prasad Mookerjee, founder of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh and the BJP’s tallest Bengali icon.Three days of troubleFor the past four years, the SFI’s Calcutta University regional committee has set up its bookstall, Sangrami Boipatra, outside the university gates in November to mark the anniversary of the Bolshevik Revolution, with police permission. This year it was scheduled from November 17 to 19 and was to be inaugurated by veteran Left Front leader Biman Bose. This time, the ABVP also sought permission for a stall of its own at the location. According to the SFI, the police told the organisers on the night of November 16 that their stall would not be allowed at the designated spot under any circumstances. On the morning of November 17, when students and SFI activists gathered to set it up, the police stopped them, citing obstruction to traffic.The students began a sit-in on College Street, holding books. The SFI alleged that the police assaulted several activists and students during the protest. Forty-one people were arrested and released from Lalbazar, the Kolkata Police headquarters, later that evening.The student groups clash. Photo: By arrangement.The SFI returned on Wednesday, saying it had secured the necessary permission. ABVP members arrived soon after, insisting that the spot had been allotted to them. According to the SFI, ABVP supporters and outsiders obstructed the stall as it opened and repeatedly attempted to disrupt its functioning through the day, while the police looked on. Students and book lovers remained at the site throughout the day to protect the stall.Oishee Mandal, a Calcutta University student and SFI member, said ABVP supporters tried to tear down the stall. “Police intervention saved our stall from being demolished. However, they tore the banner Sangrami Boipatra. They broke the barricades and tried to assault us. First, they tried to stop our book stall through the police on Tuesday. Since they could not, the ABVP tried to attack our book stall on Wednesday,” she told reporters.Also read: West Bengal: Adivasi Youth Turn Homes Into Libraries Even as Bookstalls Are Under Attack Across the StateThe police eventually allowed the two groups to set up stalls side by side, with barricades in between.In the afternoon, Bose and CPI(M) leader Sujan Chakraborty visited the stall. According to the SFI, ABVP supporters hurled abuse at them and shouted “Go Back” slogans at Bose as he left. One ABVP supporter was seen on video waving a shoe as the slogans were raised. Bose replied that he had not come there to stay and that there was no need for the slogans.Tensions flared again in the evening after anti-SFI slogans were raised, followed by the hurling of bombs, bricks and eggs. The SFI subsequently closed the stall, marched to the Jorasanko police station to protest against alleged police inaction, and got an FIR lodged there.On November 19, bad weather prevented the organisers from setting up tables and chairs, prompting the SFI to move the stall online.ABVP’s versionSwadhin Halder, Kolkata city secretary of the ABVP, gave a very different account. He told The Wire that the SFI had set up its stall on the road without permission on November 17, disrupting traffic near Calcutta Medical College and causing trouble for commuters.Halder also denied that the ABVP threw bombs. “No bombs were thrown from our side. Bombs were actually thrown at our stall as well,” he said. When asked whether this had been captured on video, he said it had not, but maintained that bombs were indeed thrown.A scenes from Esplanade in central Kolkata on November 18. Photo: By arrangement.On the slogans directed at Bose, Halder said students had reacted to what he described as anti-national statements made by Bose to the SFI. He said he did not know who had raised the slogans and maintained that it was an individual’s act rather than the organisation’s position. However, he added that the ABVP did not support Bose’s statements.“There should be a sense of courtesy from all sides. If courtesy is maintained by the other side, we will cooperate. If not, we will not accept anything,” he said.BJP changes its tuneThe clashes have prompted a shift in the BJP’s position. After the attacks on Left bookstalls during Durga Puja, senior BJP leaders publicly condemned the incidents more than once.However, on Wednesday night, following the clashes, West Bengal Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari suggested that the CPI(M) was using books to stay relevant.“This is not about books. Those who do not go to the polls, who lose elections, are doing all this. They are nowhere on the ground,” he told reporters, referring to the Left’s demand that the civic elections be put off.“If they have the guts, tell their leaders to give up the hammer, sickle and star and fight the municipal polls on the book symbol. If even one of their leaders saves his security deposit, then say the people are not with the chief minister,” he said, with regards to the book symbol among the Election Commission’s free symbols.SFI demands campus polls“Throughout the entire incident, the police administration remained a silent spectator,” said Jishu Chakraborty, secretary of the SFI’s Calcutta University regional committee. “The RSS and BJP are fundamentally opposed to books and Bengali culture. They want to destroy the democratic atmosphere. That is why books are being attacked.”Students and activists hold up books in protest. Photo: By arrangement.Tajbul Haque, a member of the SFI’s state committee, linked the incident to the attacks on Left bookstalls during Durga Puja.“The attack carried out today by ABVP supporters and outsiders in front of Calcutta University is not an isolated incident,” he said. “Through planned attacks on books and educational institutions in West Bengal, the BJP is attempting to destroy Bengal’s tradition of education and culture,” said Haque.Also read: With Books Held High, College Street Walks in KolkataSahil, president of the regional committee, accused the state government of stirring trouble on campuses and demanded that the state government “immediately hold students’ union elections. Only then will it become clear whom the students support.”The bestsellerThrough it all, the book that sold best at the SFI stall was about the BJP’s own icon. Syamaprasad Mukhopadhyay in the Light and Darkness of History was displayed on Wednesday near the main entrance of Calcutta University, barely ten yards from the ABVP stall.It is a booklet of fewer than 100 pages. Its author, Ashis Lahiri, is a writer, translator, lexicographer and independent researcher in the history of science. He shared the 2001 Ananda Puraskar with other editors of Everyman’s Dictionary, English-Bengali.SFI leaders said they wanted people to read the book and judge Mookerjee against the historical record. They pointed to his tenure as vice-chancellor of Calcutta University from 1934 to 1938, alleging that he had attempted to undermine the students’ anti-British movement. The book also refers to a 1942 letter in which Mookerjee wrote to the then-Bengal governor, John Herbert, expressing support for the British during the Quit India movement.Lahiri told The Wire that he began working on Mookerjee about four years ago, when it looked as though the BJP might come to power in Bengal.SFI book protest on College Street, Kolkata. Photo: By arrangement.“I noticed that all political parties highlight their own icons. This party did not have a prominent Bengali intellectual to highlight, so I figured they would heavily promote Syama Prasad Mookerjee since he has a strong educational background,” he said.Once the BJP came into power and began projecting Mookerjee in line with its ideology, Lahiri said he felt the party was exaggerating his stature and “hiding his real face.”“My goal wasn’t to blindly unmask him as a bad person, but to present what history actually says, and reveal authentic facts alongside their pros and cons,” he said. “Since he is a controversial figure, I ensured every single detail was factual. That is my strong point, since I am not a professional historian.”Also read: A Saffron Lesson on How to Close the Bengali MindHe was blunt about what those facts pointed to. “Through this, I demonstrated that Syama Prasad was a communal person who failed step by step despite his relentless efforts to stay relevant,” he said. “My approach is to analyse facts objectively, but I am forced to admit that his actual historical face wasn’t very pretty.”To show how little support Mookerjee commanded among voters, Lahiri pointed to an election in Howrah.He said: “When he ran for election in Howrah in 1945, he received only 346 votes as a prominent Hindu Mahasabha leader, while his relatively unknown Congress opponent, Nagendranath Mukherjee, received over 10,100 votes. Syama Prasad reacted by angrily blaming the people of Howrah for the loss.”Lahiri added that he was very happy with the sales, but not surprised by the book’s popularity. He said he had not expected opponents of the book to physically attack the stall or throw books.“However, as Newton’s law states, every action has an equal and opposite reaction, and this backlash is exactly why Syama Prasad’s book is selling so well right now. I would have been more surprised if this hadn’t happened,” he said.