New Delhi: Perhaps the matter would have been brushed under the carpet in a few days. But an emphatic denial, loaded with an allegation of an unexplained “conspiracy”, has made it impossible to ignore. This, in sum, is the drama that has unfolded in the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) over a purported list of 209 candidates in Uttar Pradesh – an episode that has lifted the lid on a possible disharmony in functioning between the state administration led by Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, the BJP organisation and the central leadership.The figure of 209 is particularly significant because a party needs 202 seats to form a government in the 403-member Uttar Pradesh Assembly.On November 15, the BJP issued a rare clarification, dismissing as completely false, baseless, imaginary and fabricated certain reports suggesting that a purported list of 209 candidates for the Uttar Pradesh Assembly election had been prepared and sent to the central leadership by the party’s state unit.“The BJP categorically denies this fake and false news,” read the statement, which was jointly signed by Uttar Pradesh BJP president Pankaj Chaudhary and Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.While it was understandable for Chaudhary, as head of the party’s state unit, to issue a clarification, the inclusion of Adityanath’s name and signature – signed in his capacity as Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh – on a BJP UP letter pad was highly unusual.Although Adityanath is a member of the BJP national executive and one of its primary star campaigners during elections, he does not hold an operational post within the BJP organisation. Moreover, Adityanath had made no public claim regarding the finalisation of candidates.Had the BJP state chief issued the clarification alone, it would have sufficed. That Adityanath stepped in – or was made to step in, as some political observers are speculating – indicates a deeper predicament and confusion within party ranks.BJP UP unit’s joint press statement, signed by state president Pankaj Chaudhary and Chief Minister Adityanath. It says that reports of the UP BJP preparing a list of 209 candidates for the 2027 Assembly elections and sending it to the central leadership were ‘false, baseless, imaginary and fabricated’.Chaudhary and Adityanath stated that the “misleading propaganda” surrounding the 209 seats “is a calculated conspiracy.” What made the statement particularly intriguing, however, is that they did not identify the source of this alleged conspiracy.Who would stand to benefit from a “conspiracy” against the ruling party other than the Opposition – unless, of course, the BJP leaders were pointing to elements within their own ranks?Also read: BJP Strongman’s Show of Strength Shields Yogi, Targets Centre, and Exposes Party Rift Ahead of UP Polls“It appears that certain elements are spreading this fabricated rumour with the aim of creating an atmosphere of confusion, disbelief, and fear among loyal party workers. The Bharatiya Janata Party appeals to all its officials, workers, and the general public not to believe such baseless and misleading news in any way and to consider only information released from the party’s official platforms as authentic,” the joint statement read.The two leaders further asserted that no such list had been prepared or sent to the central leadership by the BJP or its state unit. “The BJP is a disciplined and cadre-based political party, with a highly streamlined, democratic, and thorough organisational process for selecting candidates for assembly or any other elections, which has not even begun,” they said.Whether this episode represents a case of internal sabotage, the surfacing of latent strife within the BJP or a calculated political strategy remains unclear at this moment. However, joining the dots suggests that Adityanath’s inclusion in the clarification note may have been necessitated because sources close to him were the origin of the information in the first place.If true, the news reports appear to have been part of an effort to project Adityanath as the leader firmly in command when it comes to candidate selection for the upcoming election.Consequently, the clarification issued under his own signature looks like a damage-control exercise and a pushback from the party’s central leadership. Finalizing candidates in such a unilateral manner risks alienating party workers and rival ticket aspirants, who could defect to greener pastures ahead of the polls, especially when the party has launched a drive to add over a crore voters allegedly deleted after the SIR.This incident is expected to add fresh fuel to Samajwadi Party president Akhilesh Yadav’s popular analogy of the two engines of the “double-engine” government colliding with each other – a metaphor he uses to highlight a lack of coordination, internal competition and disagreement within the saffron party.Also read: ‘1.27 Crore Hindu Voters Deleted’ In UP SIR? In Prayagraj, Many Muslim Voters Struggle to Get Back on the RollsMeanwhile, Congress state legislature party leader Aradhana Misra remarked that the BJP was no longer fighting against the Opposition, but rather its members among themselves.While BJP leaders have largely remained tight-lipped, key clues can be gleaned from the news report that initially circulated the claim about the 209 seats last week.On November 9, India TV published a report – across both its digital and broadcast platforms – claiming that a list of 209 candidates, categorised as “Category A” seats (meaning the most winnable), had been finalised and dispatched from Lucknow to Delhi, where a final stamp of approval was awaited.Citing “top sources,” the report stated that Adityanath – described as the “man in command” in Uttar Pradesh – had gathered multi-tiered feedback from the ground across Assembly segments, and on that basis compiled a list of 209 candidates he was confident would win.According to what top sources said as per India TV, Adityanath conducted this selection exercise using his own feedback mechanism. The channel reported that sending a list this early was an attempt to foster “harmony” between the BJP’s central leadership and its state unit on candidate selection. This was unlike in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, when it was believed that disharmony in the candidate selection process hurt the party.The report also noted that sources close to Adityanath informed the channel that the 209 candidates were chosen strictly on the basis of winnability, although it did not disclose the names of the constituencies or the prospective candidates.On November 14, Devendra Parashar, the political editor of India TV who broke the story, stood firmly by his reporting. In a post on X, he stated that anyone claiming anything contrary to what he had reported through his sources either had no idea of the facts or was outright lying. “It’s not easy to accept a leak,” Parashar wrote.Hours before the joint statement was released from Lucknow, BJP state president Chaudhary made two notable observations while speaking in Kannauj. First, Chaudhary stated that he had no knowledge of the source behind the 209-candidate claim and distanced himself from it entirely.“As the state president of the Bharatiya Janata Party, I have not held any such meetings with anyone,” he told news agency ANI, explaining that before a ticket is finalised by the party, inputs and suggestions are gathered from the district and regional levels.These are then brought to the state level, where the party’s core committee and election committee deliberate on them, before the matter is forwarded to Delhi, where the central parliamentary board makes the final decision, he added.“If someone circulates such news, I would prefer not to comment on it. The BJP has followed a consistent system for the past fifty years: decisions are made through an organisational framework, involving collective consultation and consensus. The BJP is not a family-run party where a single individual can make such decisions; rather, the process is entirely collective,” Chaudhary said.Also read: Amid Media Focus on ‘Fractious’ Opposition, BJP’s Collective Decision-Making Died a Quiet DeathThe second part of Chaudhary’s remarks – in which he condemned those who stray from the main party ideology and organisation – has set tongues wagging in Uttar Pradesh’s political circles. Attributing his own political rise to the BJP’s organisational strength, Chaudhary emphasised that the BJP is an ideology-driven party whose workers operate on those core principles.“The BJP forms the government on the strength of its organisation; it is the people within the organisation – our party workers – who ensure that the government’s achievements reach the grassroots level,” Chaudhary said.However, the precise import and context of the loaded remarks that followed remain a mystery. “What is the existence of those people who have broken away from the organisation of this party and formed a party? BJP is an ideology-based party and our workers operate as per those ideas. If you break away from that ideology, then you will not be able to survive. There have been splits within the Congress – the Trinamool Congress emerged, the NCP was formed – and they survived; but no BJP leader who has broken away from the party has managed to survive,” Chaudhary stated.Whom Chaudhary was hinting at in these comments is still unclear.The “209-seat” fiasco comes at a time when political voices close to Adityanath have been holding the party’s centre responsible for politically sensitive issues, such as the backlash over the University Grants Commission (UGC) guidelines.At the same time, Adityanath’s recent claim that 1.27 crore Hindu voters were deleted from the electoral rolls following the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) – which in a way questions the competence of the party cadre in getting people’s names added to the voter list, especially of its core voters – has not been emphatically backed up by other senior BJP leaders. They have instead rallied in defence of the party organisation and party workers.For instance, Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Prasad Maurya – widely regarded as Adityanath’s internal rival for the Chief Minister’s post – posted on November 13 that in the BJP, “the organisation comes first”.He added that drawing on this organisational strength and the tireless efforts of its workers, the BJP was entering the electoral fray for the 2027 Assembly elections determined to form a government with a sweeping majority for the third consecutive time.Also read: On the Backfoot, BJP Returns to Familiar ‘Infiltrator’ Narrative to Battle Resentment Over SIR in UPMeanwhile, Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav argued recently that by raising the claim of 1.27 crore missing Hindu voters, Adityanath was subtly floating the idea that these figures pointed to a “Delhi conspiracy” aimed at engineering his defeat – especially amid friction within the double-engine government, since voter-list irregularities effectively put his own central government in the dock.Yadav also linked Adityanath’s remarks to Union home minister Amit Shah’s recent visit to Lucknow for the party’s state executive meeting, saying that the claim surfaced immediately after Shah’s tour.Back in 2017, when the BJP and its allies swept 325 seats in Uttar Pradesh to dethrone the Samajwadi Party – riding on a campaign built around the popularity of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the organisational machinery of Amit Shah – the party’s central leadership sprang a surprise by choosing Yogi Adityanath, then a Hindutva hardliner MP with influence concentrated in the Gorakhpur region, as chief minister.Since then, an undercurrent of tension has persisted between the Adityanath-led state government and the BJP’s organisational wing, with Deputy CM Keshav Prasad Maurya frequently emphasising that the organisation is supreme and serves as the true source of power enjoyed by the government.With Adityanath seeking a record third consecutive term in India’s most populous state, will the BJP’s internal rumblings grow louder as election day draws near?Omar Rashid is an independent journalist.