Media

#PrimetimeWatch: Pitroda’s Comment Becomes Ammo for Channels on Pak National Day

A daily round-up of trends and patterns on news television.

New Delhi: Technocrat Congress politician Sam Pitroda said about the Balakot airstrikes, “Attacks happen all the time, they happened in Mumbai. We could have sent our planes, but that is not the right approach. Eight people come and do something, but you do not go after an entire nation.”

Prime Minister Narendra Modi tweeted in response that the Congress chief’s “most trusted advisor and guide” has “kick-started the Pakistan National Day celebrations’’ by “demeaning India’s armed forces”.

In Kashmir, a 12-year-old boy who had been held hostage by militants was killed.

Opposition parties finalised their seat-sharing formula in Bihar, and the Left parties were not included.

How did TV channels cover these developments? What got the most attention?

English channels

Times Now

The channel had headlines like “Rahul’s aide insults Pulwama martyrs” and “Pak our neighbour, need for dialogue” which pinned the blame for Pitroda’s comments directly on the Congress president.

Anchor Navika Kumar asked a number of leading questions to Gandhi’s opponent in Amethi, Union minister Smriti Irani: “Smriti Irani, has he insulted martyrs by asking for proof of Balakot airstrikes?”

Irani’s reply was, “This is one of the most distasteful statements I have ever heard. Pitroda reflected the true nature of the Congress party. Have not seen any statement which reprimands Pitroda.”

The channel also ran an interview of Rajnath Singh with Kumar, about the acquittal of the Samjhauta blast case accused. The Union home minister, while distancing himself from prefixing a religion’s name to terror, said the courts have given the final verdict.

NDTV 24X7

In Left, Right and Centre, the channel discussed Pitroda and the Centre’s failure to curb terrorism.

Anchor Nidhi Razdan questioned the need for Pitroda to speak about Balakot. However, she also asked, “The issue is why do security establishments keep getting hit?”

Congress spokesperson Pawan Khera said the fact remained that the failure of internal security was a major issue. “ He also asked, “If citizens ask this question, what is anti-national about it?”

Bhaskar Ghosh of the BJP said the government has been going after terrorists aggressively.

On which of these issues is resonating with voters, Gilles Verniers, a professor at Ashoka University, said large aggregate or national issues are not a substitute for daily life concerns such as joblessness, access to healthcare or education.

Republic TV

The channel ran the hashtag #CongForPakistan. Editor and anchor Arnab Goswami took direct jibes at the Congress. “Ask Sonia Gandhi if she would be happy if one inch of her country of birth Italy was given away?” “Is she Italian or not?”

The channel also had a headline, “Vadra Cong openly backs Pakistan” and another, “Jaish kills forces, Congress wants ‘facts’”.

A historical perspective was also provided to the diatribe. “In April 2013, when China invaded Ladakh, Salman Khursheed even defended it,” said the anchor, adding “tell me did the Congress party compromise our security or not?”

As eight people in the panel spoke simultaneously, he insisted, “I ask the questions but never get the answers?” And then said this debate was over. “Let’s move to the third!”

India Today TV

The channel had a story on “Pak terror exposed” as it ran clips of a 12-year-old boy’s family appealing to terrorists to release him. “Family cries for son’s release” a headline said.

The channel reported that two terrorists had taken Atif Mir hostage and used him as a human shield when surrounded by forces. It said his parents pleaded to them over loud-hailers: “This is not jehad, plead you to leave our son.”

Hindi channels

Zee News

On Zee News too, news on the boy’s killing was run with the heading: “Atankiyon nay 12 saal kay bachchay ko maar dala? (Terrorists killed a 12-year-old?)”

Anchor Sudhir Chaudhary used the opportunity to proclaim: “All those voices are silent today which opposed the parading of a man on a jeep’s bonnet and backed stone-pelters in Kashmir.”

He then quickly shifted to how India has slipped to 140 rank from 133 in the World Happiness Index which evaluates the perceived happiness among people in 156 nations.

“India is becoming a nation of unhappy people, staying happy is the master key of live,” he said and wondered “if our growing population is the cause of our growing unhappiness”.

Aaj Tak

The channel ran a story on the Centre banning Yasin Malik’s Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front. Headlines said, “37 FIRs against JKLF” and “Bharat ka khana, Pakistan ka gaana ban (Ban on eating Indian, praising Pakistan)” and “Yasin Malik par chal gaya chabuk (Yasin Malik lashed)”.

Politicians were also shown reacting to the development.

NDTV India

In its Chunav India Ka programme, the channel discussed the rumour around former Union minister Jitin Prasada planning to leave the Congress and join BJP.

On the reasons behind the supposed move, anchor Nidhi Kulpati said, “He was interested in Sitapur seat – but his name came in first list from Dharuhera.”

Congress spokesperson Alok Verma said though there was speculation, nothing concrete has emerged. He also refused to confirm that senior leaders Priyanka Gandhi and Jyotiraditya Scindia went to assuage Prasada.

ABP News

In its programme Master Stroke, the channel discussed the seat distribution among the opposition mahagathbandhan in Bihar.

It referred to the coming together and sharing of seats by five alliance partners, with the Rashtriya Janata Dal getting 19 of the 40 seats, Congress nine, Rashtriya Lok Samata Party five, and former chief minister Jitan Ram Manjhi’s Hindustani Awam Morcha (Secular) and Vikasshil Insaan Party three each.

The channel also said that Sharad Yadav, who broke away from Janata Dal (United) and floated his own Loktantrik Janata Dal, would contest on the RJD symbol.

However, the channel questioned why no senior leader was present during the announcement. In the absence of RJD leader Tejashwi Yadav the proceedings were conducted by party spokesperson Manoj Jha.

Join The Discussion