Media

#PrimetimeWatch: Naxal Attack, IT Raids on Kamal Nath’s Aides Dominate Discussion

A daily round-up of trends and patterns on news television.

New Delhi: Five people, including BJP MLA Bhima Mandavi, were killed when Naxals triggered an improvised explosive device in Dantewada district of Chattisgarh on Tuesday.

In violation of EC guidelines to not refer to forces in campaigning, Prime Minister Narendra Modi tells first time voters to dedicate votes to Pulwama martyrs and those who conducted the Balakot airstrike.

PM attacks Congress for corruption after IT raids on Madhya Pradesh chief minister Kamal Nath’s aides result in huge cash haul. Opposition alleges misuse of Central agencies to target political opponents.

How did the television channels report these stories and more.

English channels

NDTV 24X7

Through its headlines, “BJP convoy attacked in Chhattisgarh” and “Naxal attack 48 hours before polls”, the channel discussed the attack.

Senior editor Vishnu Som said the director general of state police told him that the MLA was advised not to take this route as it was not properly sanitised. “But he decided to take this route despite the warning. It was a convoy of three vehicles and Bhima Mandavi’s vehicle was hit”. There was also a gunfight between Naxals and other security personnel.

Anchor Nidhi Razdan said the bigger issue is “why attacks keep happening”.

Also Read: Election Commission Stalls Release of Modi Biopic

Congress spokesperson Shama Mohamed recalled the attack of 2013, in which 27 party people, including senior Congress leader V.C. Shukla, were killed. “We need better intelligence to see that these things do not happen,” she said.

Som added that this is the “second worst attack” in the region. The channel also spoke about the intensity of the blast through headlines like “Blast leaves huge crater” and “Massive blast splits bullet-proof jeep”.

Former DGP of Andhra Pradesh Noel Swaranjit Singh gave a deeper insight into the episode, saying, “Those who live by the sword, die by the sword.” Questioning the slain MLA’s connections, he also asked: “Did he have any truck with Naxals in the past when he was in government?”

Noel said “for 15 years there was a government which could not weed out Naxals. If someone would rear a snake, it would come to bite them.”

He also insisted that “there was no intelligence failure, the MLA was told not to take the route – but he forced the police to act the way they did.”

Senior advocate Sanjay Hegde, who has often travelled in Chhattisgarh, said, “Everyone knows which roads to avoid and take. Even lawyers disconnect their phones.” But, he said, “Politicians in election times seem to take risks.”

On the reasons behind the inability of successive government to eliminate the violence, he said, “There is too much money invested in Chhattisgarh insurgency, money from industrial houses and mining lobby, too much money sloshing around the system. You need benevolent forces or NGOs to prepare the ground.”

Times Now

In its programme “Rapid Fire”, the channel used “#281CrCashLog” and headlines like “Pay offs to Delhi AICC under lens” and “PM brands it notes for votes” along with the IT raids story.

In the discussion, opposition leaders attacked the BJP, saying it was being “selective” in crackdown on black money. Samajwadi Party spokesperson Ghanshyam Tiwari referred to an Election Commission letter to the finance ministry in this regard. He charged that “a nervous BJP is allying with IT to make a tamasha of corruption

Anchor Navika Kumar then asked: “Even if I agree with your logic that BJP is nervous – but have these notes been found in BJP office”.

Tiwari countered saying “IT is investigating it. The Yeddyurappa diaries revealed that Karnataka was looted, but did the IT department then even ask a question to Jaitley, Rajnath or Gadkari who were named in the diaries?”

BJP national spokesperson Tom Vadakkan said, “it has been established beyond doubt that papers presented in Karnataka were fabricated. This time a large amount of money stolen from government’s exchequer in Madhya Pradesh has been recovered. This money was for children’s nutrition but it was being misused for polls.”

Waris Pathan of AIMIM said, “We are all against corruption – when it comes to misuse of funds meant for children. But Modi government is using the agency for its own benefit.”

Kumar said in the expenses list recovered during the raids, “AICC Delhi” and “AICC Election Bond” have been clearly mention. She said the worst kept secret of elections is that CMs have to generate funds for central leadership.

Republic TV

It too looked at the IT raids through a pro-Centre lens. Headlines like “MP raids: 8 million mothers, children betrayed” and “Loot the poor, fund party?” and a “#CongHawalaCashNote” indicated the channel’s belief.

Anchor Arnab Goswami insisted that “people who looted owe an explanation to the people of the country”.

Journalist Sanjeev Srivastava said “while money has been found, the diary was too inconvenient” a way to implicate the Congress.

It was also pointed out by another participant speaking for the opposition that “if Sahara and Birla diaries were not admissible in court, then how can we believe these?”

BJP spokesperson Nalin Kohli said “in this case there was a credible link between the seizure and from where the money came and thus the notings form substantial evidence”.

Tauseef Ahmed Khan of Trinamool Congress questioned by Income Tax authorities only go after the opposition and not corrupt BJP leaders.

India Today TV

The “Election Express” of the channel drove into Puducherry to look at what voters want.

The programme looked at “poll issues in quaint Puducherry”. “Puducherry will witness a high-stakes battle for one Lok Sabha seat in the second phase of elections on April 18. Can chief minister V. Narayanasamy of the Congress win back the seat he lost in 2014?” it asked.

The programme showed one respondent say, “When God needs a break, he comes to Pondicherry” while another asserted, “We want to elect those who conserve water bodies.”

Hindi channels

NDTV India

In ‘Chunav India Ka’, the channel looked at elections in Bihar. It carried headlines like “CBI opposed Lalu bail plea” saying the agency charged that he was “Not applying for health reasons, but due to elections”.

Rashtriya Janata Dal leader Tejashvi Yadav was shown addressing a public meeting where he said: “This is not an election to elect an individual, party or alliance – but it is an election to save the country, the constitution and reservation.”

He was also seen taking a dig at Janata Dal (United) leader and chief minister Nitish Kumar, terming him a “paltu chacha” (turncoat uncle) for deserting the RJD and moving towards the BJP. “Paltu chacha now finds their DNA okay,” he quipped.

He added, “Nitish chacha ketay thay mitti main mil jaoonga par bhajpa main nahin jaoonga, bhajpa main to chale gaye, mitti main milanay ki baari aapki hai.” (Nitish used to say he will turn into dust but not go with BJP. He has gone with the BJP, it is your turn to turn him to dust.)

Zee TV

In his primetime show, channel editor Sudhir Chaudhary spoke about Modi’s controversial speech in which he urged first time voters to vote for Pulwama and Balakot. The Election Commission later took note of this alleged model code violation.

Also Read: #PollVault: EC Wakes Up as Modi Asks for Votes in the Names of Slain Soldiers

The channel showed how Modi pointed out that the first salary and first vote are very important for every individual. It had him saying that just the way you place your first earnings in the hands of your mother, sister or the deity you worship, so should you cast you first vote for those who laid down their lives in Pulwama or those who carried out the Balakot airstrike thereafter.

It did not, however, mention that the EC had barred all parties and candidates from referring to the armed forces in their campaign.

Aaj Tak

The channel showed Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi being heckled again by BJP supporters during a road show in Bijnore with chants of “Modi, Modi”. But she was not perturbed and threw flowers at them in a typical Gandhi-giri style.

However, there was soon a clash between the BJP and Congress supporters and police had to intervene to separate the two. Earlier too, in several of her roadshows and rallies in Uttar Pradesh, Priyanka met similar sloganeering by BJP with a smile or a few gentle words.

Join The Discussion