Listen to this article:
New Delhi: As many as 21 Indian diasporic organisations from across the globe have condemned the recent raids and seizures carried out by the Delhi police against The Wire, its editors and staffers following the complaint lodged by Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Amit Malviya in connection with the now-retracted news stories on Meta.
The statement issued by the signatories – India Civil Watch International; Aotearoa Alliance of Progressive Indians, New Zealand; Boston South Asian Coalition, USA; Hindus for Human Rights, UK; Dalit Solidarity Forum, USA; among others – said the “witch hunt” to which The Wire is being subjected to is “grossly disproportionate and politically motivated”.
Malviya’s complaint is connected to a series of reports carried by The Wire that raised serious questions about the political control of the social media company Meta by individuals purportedly connected to the BJP. Once it became known that some of the sources in the reports relied upon by The Wire were not authenticated, it duly carried an official retraction of the stories on October 23. It also apologised to readers and launched an independent review.
“That the case was filed and the raids carried out after and despite their official retraction of the story based on their acknowledgement of discrepancies suggests that the FIR and the subsequent raids were nothing but an attempt to publicly and dramatically demonstrate the state’s power to intimidate and silence journalists who dare to question it,” said the statement.
The signatories saw the raids on The Wire as part of an ongoing deterioration of journalistic and press freedoms in India. In recent years, police have raided and seized devices of almost every organisation that seeks to remain independent in its research, journalism, or advocacy: Newsclick; NDTV; Amnesty International; Centre for Policy Research; Vanvasi Chetna Ashram; Citizens for Justice and Peace; and of course those accused of ‘anti-national’ activities such as the Bhima Koregaon 16 or those protesting the CAA / NRC, the statement said.
Reproduced below are the full statement and the list of signatories.
We Stand with The Wire
We are writing as diasporic Indian organizations and allies to express our solidarity with The Wire. We strongly condemn the witch hunt to which they are being subjected by the state. This is a grossly disproportionate and politically motivated response to the filing of cases of cheating, forgery, fraud, defamation, and criminal conspiracy against them by Amit Malviya, who heads the ruling BJP’s National Information and Technology Department and leads their social media cell.
Malviya’s complaint is connected to a series of reports carried by The Wire that raised serious questions about the political control of the social media company Meta by individuals purportedly connected to the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Once it became known that some of the sources in that report relied upon by The Wire were not authenticated, it followed professional standards and duly carried an official retraction of the story on October 23, 2022. It also apologized to its readers and launched an independent review. That the case was filed and the raids carried out after and despite their official retraction of the story based on their acknowledgement of discrepancies suggests that the FIR and the subsequent raids were nothing but an attempt to publicly and dramatically demonstrate the state’s power to intimidate and silence journalists who dare to question it.
The details of the story and who is ultimately culpable are not relevant here. Nor is the question of the publication’s editorial standards. For, neither of these are grounds for what has since happened – multiple police raids by the Delhi Crime Branch, the seizure of electronic devices from the homes of The Wire’s founding editors, Siddharth Varadarajan, M.K. Venu, and Sidharth Bhatia, deputy editor Jahnavi Sen, and business head Mithun Kidambi in Delhi and Mumbai, and a search of The Wire’s office in Delhi where police officers physically pushed out lawyer Shadan Farasat while seizing the devices.
Egregiously, the phones and laptops of the four Wire editors, the accountant, and the business officer were seized without being sealed and without provision of the hash value by the authorities for the seized devices at the time of the seizures. The hash value is the single most important forensic evidence that captures the total state of the electronic devices at the time of seizure. It allows for forensic experts to determine whether any tampering of the device took place after seizure. In short, the hash value ensures the integrity of the stored data. Given the emerging evidence around electronic surveillance and the reports of planted and ‘fabricated’ evidence used to implicate political prisoners such as the Bhima Koregaon 16, we are highly concerned about any claims by authorities based on the data on the above devices. Given that seized devices contain sensitive information, including financial information, there is the possibility of further vilification of the outlet. The Wire has since noted its demand for the hash value to be shared immediately.
The raids on The Wire are part of an ongoing deterioration of journalistic and press freedoms in India. In recent years, police have raided and seized devices of almost every organization that seeks to remain independent in its research, journalism, or advocacy: Newsclick; NDTV; Amnesty International; Centre for Policy Research; Vanvasi Chetna Ashram; Citizens for Justice and Peace; and of course those accused of ‘anti-national’ activities such as the Bhima Koregaon 16 or those protesting the CAA / NRC. In all these cases, either the Enforcement Directorate has been involved, invoking allegations of money laundering or abuse of the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA), or the case has been pursued under anti-terrorist legislation such as the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA). Since neither would apply to The Wire as it does not accept foreign donations, a case of criminal defamation, forgery, and cheating has been made the excuse, even though such a charge does not provide any justification for a raid on premises or for the seizure of devices.
In this context, it is useful to remind ourselves of The Wire’s achievements and what it stands for:
- The Wire’s story parallels that of the BJP government. Established a year after Narendra Modi’s election, the outlet has consistently shone a spotlight on the government, calling it out for its mounting scams, swindles, cult of personality, authoritarian destruction of democracy, and genocidal politics. For this it has earned the implacable hatred of the powers that be, who have filed several police cases against it prior to this one, and subject it to surveillance, most recently with the Pegasus software.
- In just seven years, The Wire has built itself into a leading source of reliable news, doing so on a shoestring budget constituted heavily by ‘mom and pop’ donations, all openly recorded. As the Washington Post describes it, it is a “tiny but pugnacious outfit” that is among the handful that has consistently spoken truth to power.
- The Wire has broken a range of important stories with patient sleuthing and careful reportage. As importantly, it has amplified the work of social movements, carrying articles, interviews, and statements by social movements, activists, and researchers on displacement, labour, agrarian crisis, poverty, environmental crisis, political prisoners, and much else. It has carried stories from Kashmir, in particular placing on record attacks on journalists there. It has also attempted to provide space to current events, movements, and progressive analyses from across the world, with a special focus on South Asia.
- The Wire took as a founding principle the central role of an independent media in democracy. It has sought to democratize the media by taking control away from the corporate houses and putting it in the hands of the readers, recognizing the need to go beyond the English-reading public and publishing from very early on in Hindi, and then Urdu and Marathi, and also opening up the site to a variety of voices including, importantly, those of youth in its LiveWire section. Along with other digital media organizations, it co-founded Digipub to carry out vigilance and advocacy around state control of the digital sphere.
The Wire has gone on record to honestly acknowledge its mistake and has committed to a full inquiry. This is more than many well-established outlets have done when they have their facts wrong and speaks further to The Wire’s strong sense of accountability to its readership.
As we watch democracy in India under attack from every direction, we are acutely aware of the costs of losing one of our few remaining independent media voices.
We demand that the Delhi police stop their persecution of The Wire, drop all charges against them, and return their seized devices forthwith.
Aotearoa Alliance of Progressive Indians, New Zealand
Boston South Asian Coalition, USA
Center for Culture-Centered Approach to Research and Evaluation (CARE), New Zealand
Centre d’etudes sur l’asie du sud (CERAS), Montreal
Chicago Coalition for Human Rights in India, USA
Coalition Against Fascism in India, USA
Dalit Solidarity Forum, USA
Hindus for Human Rights, UK
Hindus for Human Rights, USA
India Civil Watch International
India Labour Solidarity, UK
InSAF India (International Solidarity for Academic Freedom in India)
Punjabi Literary and Cultural Association, Winnipeg
Scottish Indians for Justice, Scotland
Shaheed Bhagat Singh Charitable Trust, New Zealand
South Asia Solidarity Group, UK
South Asian Diaspora Action Collective (SADAC), Montreal
South Asian Dalit Adivasi Network (SADAN), Canada
South Asian Left Activist Movement (SALAM), USA
South Asian Network for Secularism and Democracy (SANSAD), Vancouver
The Humanism Project, Australia