As the world settles down after the US mid-terms elections, one of the key lessons is how badly both traditional media misread the outcomes. Across the news sites covering the spectrum, from the New York Times to Fox News, large sets of politicians were labelled as “too extreme” for supporting things like trans rights or Medicare for All. Almost all of them won their elections handily showing that the voters held very different views than the media. An illustrative example is CBS. The news site was reportedly pressured by their new boss, Bari Weiss, to find connections between Abdul E Sayed and the Muslim Brotherhood. El Sayed won his election. CBS, though, has haemorrhaged viewers. Its flagship product, 60 Minutes, “recently saw the smallest audience of the season and the smallest for a fourth episode in at least a quarter century. The season premiere in September managed 7.94 million, a 21% drop from 2025 and the weakest opening this century.”Combined with the news coverage was the news commentary on X, the most important social media site for journalists and politicians since its inception. Here again, the assessment was wide of the mark. Both The Atlantic – the most mainstream of publications – and 404 Media, a niche tech publication founded in 2023, now have articles on how X discourse was not just wrong, but totally misled the US Republican Party and its supporters. If everybody had been wrong, this could have been written off as a fluke. Instead, the commentary on the social media app Bluesky – niche, heavily US dominated, as well as skewing to the academic community – was predominantly correct on key issues, whether it was trans rights, anger at immigration raids, and US support for Israel and how these affected the elections. Mainstream media’s ground presence has dwindledThe Mississippi Free Press, a small non-profit newsroom founded in 2020, had been suggesting a Democratic turn in the American South long before anybody realised it. In the end, Scott Colom became the first African-American to win a Senate race in Mississippi after more than 140 years. Bolts magazine, a digital non-profit magazine founded in 2022, has been doing such a good job that the New York Times took the details of a story it had done on an anti-immigration sheriff, and did not even credit it.The single biggest explanation of this gap seems to be a lack of on-the-ground reporting by big papers, TV networks, and commentators on social media. This is not a new problem. In his 2008 book on the problems in journalism, Flat Earth News, Nick Davies coined the term “churnalism”, meaning that journalists were rushing out copy without investigating the situation on the ground, or talking to people affected. For his research he commissioned an assessment of the articles published in four UK newspapers – Times, Telegraph, Guardian, Independent – over two weeks, and found that of the news in 2,000 articles, “only 12 per cent of it was probably based on material generated by Fleet Street reporters.” Most of the rest – a whopping 88% – was largely a mix of input from PR agencies and news wire agencies. This churning out news stories with little on-the-ground check was a result of media consolidation, the elimination of smaller bureaus, and the relentless pressure to produce news stories at a frantic pace to catch the attention of the audience. By definition, then, larger newspapers simply produce too much with too little ground reporting for a close look of what is happening on the ground. And while small organisations, such as the ones mentioned above, can do so, they will not be able to do more than report on a few specific topics and geographies. As good as the quality of the discussion is on the social media website Bluesky, it misses out huge swathes of land – whether the political crises in India, or the crushing of the last vestiges of independent journalism in Egypt. In effect, the main role of the media, as the Fourth Estate of democracy – the ability to inform people of what is actually happening, how power is exercised in life, is severely curtailed. Moreover, the large companies that own news networks can be influenced by the government. The simplest method – as pioneered in India – is to control who receives access to the administration, and is thus able to “remain relevant”. Then there are more obvious quid pro quos. The Ellisons, who own CBS, received favourable treatment by the Trump administration for the merger of their large media empire. It is no surprise that CBS hired somebody like Bari Weiss, seen to be very favourably inclined to the Trump administration. For Indians, this dynamic will sound very familiar. Just like the Ambanis dominate the Indian media space from entertainment (JioHotstar) to TV (Network18), the Ellisons now dominate Hollywood’s biggest studios (Paramount and Warner Bros Discovery) as well as TV news in the form of CNN, CBS, and 28 TV stations owned by CBS. Just like the “largest democracy”, the world’s oldest modern democracy is now a Godi empire.A government unawareSocial media giants, which have displaced newspapers and TV networks as the source of news for many people, can also play a major role. Elon Musk owns X, and he donated nearly $500 million to help Republican campaigns, making him the largest single donor in US election history (and the largest failure). X has been suffused with the ‘culture war’ talking points – xenophobia and anti-trans rhetoric – that were central to Republican campaigns. As Sarah Jeong reported in the Verge, the forced sale of Tik Tok (to the Ellisons) in the US was driven by a desire to limit what the public saw of Palestinian suffering in a war that the US was backing. Facebook (now Meta), too, played a doubtful role in Brazil’s elections. In sum, the media industry looks incredibly pliable to authoritarian leaders and their corporate supporters. They can control the message – or drown out the messages of their opponents – while retaining the façade of a “free media”. But the role of the media is not merely to be a mouthpiece of power. Credible, on-the-ground reporting, also supplies the government necessary information about what is working and what is not. Despite the very favourable media environment – in fact, maybe because of the Godi media they now have – the Republicans catastrophically misjudged the resentment against their policies, and are now facing a complete rout. A media controlled by the masters might – in the short run – seem like a good deal for the government, but it comes with the price tag of a government unaware of what is really happening in the country. In this, once again, India showed how almost total capture of the media and social media space is not necessarily a net good for a government. During the 2024 general elections, when the results started coming out of Uttar Pradesh, the government was visibly flailing with Prime Minister Narendra Modi making absurd statements about being “non-biological” as his party reeled from the unexpected result. There is a straight line from that moment to the current protests, where the government has tried to manage the narrative with no success. The government controls, by hook or crook, almost the whole of the media narrative, but in achieving this dominance it has insulated itself from the frustrations in the country. The results of the US mid-term elections are being seen by many as a chance of a democratic reset in a country slipping into authoritarianism. In other countries – Hungary, Poland, Serbia, and Israel where the fall of long-term parties that had an incestuous relationship with the media – elections have led to a change of guard. But, as India shows, mere elections can only be a first step in this change. The frustrations of the public have not gone away; the monopolistic media empires remain unchecked. In India, the US, and other democracies dealing with authoritarian leaders, electoral defeat (despite obviously rigged systems) and public protests will only go so far in restoring democracy if the structure of the media remains so fundamentally at cross purposes to its role: informing the citizens about what is happening, and informing the government, too.Omair Ahmad has worked as a political analyst and journalist in India, the US and the UK.