New Delhi: Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant has trasferred at least two matters away from a bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah over its decision to convert individual disputes into nationwide public interest litigations (PILs), Hindustan Times has reported.The decision, taken in consultation with senior Supreme Court judges, comes four weeks after CJI Kant told judges at a full court meeting to restrict themselves to the subjects allocated to them under the court’s roster.As per the report, the CJI consulted Justices Vikram Nath, B.V. Nagarathna, M.M. Sundresh and P.S. Narasimha before deciding to reassign the two cases.“The CJI was categorical in the full court meeting that the judges ought to work as per the roster to keep case allocation orderly, maintain judicial discipline and help preserve public confidence that justice is being administered fairly,” a person aware of the development told HT.The cases concern the regulation of private universities across India, and the issue of unauthorised construction and commercial use of residential properties. While both matters originated as individual concerns, they were subsequently expanded by Justice Amanullah’s bench to examine broader, systemic problems.The first of the two cases – Ayesha Jain vs Amity University, Noida – emerged from a student complaint against the university, with the petitioner alleging harassment and the loss of an academic year due to a change in her legally recognised name. During the court proceedings, the bench expanded the scope of the case to encompass administrative, financial and regulation issues in private universities; issuing directions to the Union and state governments.The case has now been assigned to a three-judge bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath and the hearing is listed for Thursday, November 19.The second case – Loganathan vs State of Tamil Nadu – relates to an individual dispute from Chennai, involving the construction of a one-and-a-half-storey building without an authorised plan. The case’s proceedings were initiated before the Supreme Court on March 25, after which it was widened to cover similar violations across the nation. The bench had also demanded responses from various states and municipal authorities in Delhi and the national capital region (NCR).A bench headed by Justice B.V. Nagarathna is expected to hear the case on November 23.The CJI’s interventionAccording to HT, CJI Kant, in his meeting a month before, stressed the need for “orderly” case allocation, along with maintaining the public’s faith in the judicial system.Per this reasoning, Justice Amanullah, whose roster does not include PILs, was expected to refer the issue to the CJI through the Supreme Court registry in case the matter warranted examination as a public interest concern, the report said.“As per roster, Justice Amanullah does not have PILs as a matter he could examine and therefore, if his bench felt the matter required adjudication as a PIL, it ought to have been referred to the CJI through the court registry for appropriate orders,” another source informed the HT.Justice Amanullah could not be reached for his response to the reassignment.SC’s stance on roster allocation till nowIn its 2017 constitution bench judgment in the Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms, a five-judge bench reaffirmed that the CJI alone is responsible for the roster and has the exclusive authority to constitute benches and allocate cases. The judgment stated that individual benches, whether comprising two or three judges, cannot assign cases to themselves and can only exercise jurisdiction only over matters formally allocated to them by the CJI.Much earlier, in 1997, State of Rajasthan vs Prakash Chand, the apex court had held that the CJI has the prime prerogative to constitute benches and distribute judicial business, and that judges were expected to discharge only the duties allocated to them.In Jasbir Singh vs State of Punjab (2006), the court had ruled that a judge who believes that a particular case should be heard by a specific bench must approach the CJI for further action. The judge cannot, by themselves, assume jurisdiction on the matter, disregarding the prescribed roster in the process.In Kishore Samrite vs State of Uttar Pradesh (2012), the Supreme Court had highlighted the need for courts to scrutinise claims of public interest thoroughly, cautioning them against misusing PIL proceedings.The above-mentioned rulings reinforced the institutional framework that the CJI relied on to transfer the two cases.Debate over CJI’s control over roster allocationCJI Kant’s power as master of the roster has also previously come under fire. In a recent article by The Wire, senior advocate Dushyant Dave questioned the CJI’s handling of a contempt matter involving the deputation of Indian Police Service (IPS) officers to the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs).Dave said the CJI had interfered with a judicial order passed by the bench of Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Chandurkar on September 29, and constituted a special bench of Justices Manoj Mishra and Ujjal Bhuyan to hear the petition. Justices Bhuyan and Chandurkar had also expressed surprise at the deletion of the case from the Daily Cause List and sought an explanation from the Supreme Court registry.Relying on the court’s observations in Shanti Bhushan vs Supreme Court of India – which recognised that a bench, once assigned a matter, exercises its judicial functions independently and without interference from other judges, including the CJI – Dave argued that the CJI’s authority did not extend to interfering with an already assigned matter.