In an interview where he refutes the objections raised by the Indian government about the WHO’s estimate that the total excess deaths during the pandemic in India (which are usually assumed to be COVID-19 deaths) are four million and not 522,000, the Indian government’s official figure, Dr Murad Banaji says India’s refusal to accept a much higher death toll than the official estimate raises “issues of scientific integrity”.Banaji says this refusal will raise questions about scientific work done in India as well as questions about the government’s response to that science. This is not good for India’s image.Banaji, a London-based mathematician who has been tracking India’s COVID-19 epidemic and, in particular, COVID-19 mortality, says the WHO estimate of four million excess deaths is not just broadly correct, but is also corroborated by six separate studies which estimate India’s COVID-19 death mortality in a range between three and five million. The WHO figure is bang in the middle of that range.“It would be right for the WHO to be extremely cautious at taking India’s Covid death figures at face value,” Banaji said.In an interview to The Wire, Banaji challenges the four key objections raised by the health ministry when, in a formal statement, it responded to the WHO’s four million deaths estimate.Speaking about the claim made by the health ministry that the test positivity for COVID-19 was never uniform throughout the country at any point in time and this has not been considered for modelling purposes, Banaji said this is “very confused and confusing”. He pointed out that test positivity is not related to mortality. He also pointed out that India has serosurvey results which show that in June 2021, before mass-scale vaccination had made a big mark, positivity was at 68% levels. That suggests a far larger number of cases than officially acknowledged and, therefore, a far larger number of deaths.