Today, November 16, is Audit Diwas.Imagine a two-day national seminar on cricket umpiring at which the board president opens proceedings, a chief minister takes apart a famous umpiring decision from 15 years ago, the captains complain that verdicts arrive too late to matter, and the final resolution asks for closer collaboration with the umpires. Then imagine that the umpires were not on the dais, were not quoted, and did not later mention the event on their own noticeboard. That, more or less, is what happened in Thiruvananthapuram in the first week of November 2026.The Kerala legislative assembly hosted the All-India Conference of Chairpersons and Members of Public Accounts Committees on November 3 and 4, the first time the State had held the national event. Around 262 delegates from 26 States gathered under the theme ‘Audit, Accountability and Good Governance: The Evolving Role of PAC’. Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla inaugurated the conference and addressed its valedictory session. Rajya Sabha Deputy Chairman Harivansh, Parliament’s PAC Chairman K. C. Venugopal, Chief Minister V. D. Satheesan, Assembly Speaker Thiruvanchoor Radhakrishnan and Kerala PAC Chairperson K. N. Balagopal spoke at the inaugural session, and a conference souvenir was released.The choice of venue, no doubt, had a logic. Kerala’s PAC traces its roots to the Travancore Legislative Assembly of 1933, the State began the convention of giving the PAC chair to the Opposition in 1957, and the committee has presented 1,257 reports in seventy years. If any legislature could claim to take audit seriously, it was this one.Yet the Public Accounts Committee exists for one main purpose: to examine the reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG). Take the CAG’s reports away and the PAC is a committee without a docket. So why did the CAG choose, or was allowed, to be absent, and what that absence says about an institution that Ambedkar called the most important officer under the Constitution.What Was Said in the House That Travancore BuiltSpeaker Om Birla told the committees that every rupee drawn from the exchequer must be accounted for, and that public spending should be judged by the difference it makes to citizens’ lives, not by the size of the outlay. He was troubled that some audit observations stayed unresolved for “10, 15 or even 20 years” and called for a time-bound action plan. He described the examination of CAG findings, Action Taken Reports and follow-up on recommendations as integral to the PAC’s work. He also urged committees to use artificial intelligence and data analytics to sift large expenditure datasets, spot irregular patterns and track pending observations. C. Venugopal, chairing parliament’s PAC from the opposition benches, was sharper. Delay in tabling audit reports, he said, delays accountability and denies citizens their rightful services: “Justice delayed, justice denied.” He then put numbers on the CAG’s choice of subjects. Over six years, defence and railways had received about 33 and 30 reports respectively, while Health and External Affairs had 14 each and Education only seven. He asked the CAG to audit more of the flagship programmes, naming POSHAN Abhiyan, Samagra Shiksha, Swachh Bharat Mission, the Jan Dhan Yojana, the Jal Jeevan Mission, PMAY-Gramin and PM MITRA. Most pointedly, he said that an increase in the resource capacity and independence of the CAG would directly affect the functioning of the PAC. He also proposed that at least one PAC report, with the government’s action taken on it, be discussed in every session of parliament.Chief Minister Satheesan, himself a former chairman of Kerala’s PAC, delivered the conference’s most quotable lines, and they were double-edged. Defending the CAG, he said no legislature is competent to dismiss a CAG report by majority vote, and he called the Kerala Assembly’s January 2021 resolution keeping the CAG’s KIIFB findings out of PAC scrutiny an “unhealthy parliamentary practice”. Attacking the CAG, he described the Rs 1.76-lakh crore 2G figure as “a hypothetical, presumptive projection” rather than an actual loss. He argued that the CAG had valued the 2008 spectrum by later benchmarks, had strayed beyond its mandate by questioning a deliberate policy choice, and had treated the Vizhinjam port as a public sector undertaking when it was a public–private partnership. He called for a national drive to clear PAC files pending for up to 20 years. He also asked for a serious discussion on how PACs should handle findings that, in his words, fall outside the constitutional audit purview because of a misconception in the audit approach.The conference closed with a resolution that reads like a to-do list for the audit chain. It calls for standardised timelines for Action Taken Notes, digital oversight systems such as the Audit Para Monitoring System in every State and UT PAC, regular training for PAC secretariats through specialised institutes, at least three sittings a month and sub-committees to clear pending observations. Its seventh point seeks closer collaboration with the “Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General” to use advanced forensic tools and to identify high-risk areas that need immediate legislative attention.Read the four texts together and one feature stands out. The CAG is the subject of almost every paragraph and the speaker of none. The Speaker relied on his findings, Venugopal questioned his priorities, the chief minister questioned his methods, and the resolution asked for his help. No published account records a single sentence from him or anyone speaking on his behalf.The Plumbing Was Leaking Long Before ThiruvananthapuramNothing said in the Assembly Hall should have surprised the CAG, because the CAG’s own performance reports had already told the story. In CAG — Ensuring Accountability Amidst Controversies, I set out those numbers, and they make uncomfortable reading in the light of the conference.Begin with recommendations. Of the 422 recommendations in reports on the Union Government in 2021-22, audited entities accepted 83, or 19.66%; in 2022-23 they accepted 91 of 509, or 17.87%. State governments did somewhat better: 27.58% in 2021-22 and 47.96% in 2022-23. As for audit observations, the CAG claims that the Union Government accepted 362 of 849 (42%) and the States 434 of 1,698 (25%) in 2021-22; comparable figures were not given for 2022-23.Recoveries tell the same tale. Union audits produced recoveries of Rs 1,113 crore against an accepted Rs 16,777 crore in 2021-22, about 6.6 %, and Rs 1,392 crore against Rs 25,276 crore in 2022-23, about 5.5 %. State audits recovered 21 % and 16.14% in the two years. The CAG’s latest impact report, for 2025-26, puts recoveries at Rs 4,251 crore and, by the press’s reading, recoveries again fell well short of the amounts flagged in several major cases.Then the Action Taken Notes (ATNs), the hinge on which the whole PAC system turns. The CAG reported that ATNs were pending on 10,998 paragraphs relating to Union Government departments in 2022-23, and that no ATN had been received even once on 812 of them. In the States, 10,191 ATNs were pending. Parliament’s PAC itself, between 2015 and 2024, presented reports on only 293 of the 710 subjects it had selected, or 41.26 %, leaving 417 unreported. My conclusion in the book was blunt: the pendency of tens of thousands of ATNs shows that the PAC mechanism has failed to enforce accountability, and reflects the powerlessness of both CAG and PAC.Two caveats from the book matter here. First, the CAG’s performance reports are internal documents with no statutory standing, so their numbers must be taken at face value. Second, the CAG presents no comparison with other supreme audit institutions, so the reader cannot tell whether a 20% acceptance rate is a scandal or a norm. These are exactly the facts that a national conference of PAC chairpersons needed to hear.The book also noted that the CAG’s own biennial forum for senior officers, the Accountants General Conference, is described in the CAG’s annual performance report as a vibrant, participatory forum, but in practice is top-driven and does not encourage free debate. An institution that talks mainly to itself, in a format it controls, will find a two-day public conversation with 262 legislators, many from the Opposition, uncomfortable. That discomfort is not a reason to stay away. It is the reason to turn up.A Website That Did Not NoticeWhen the CAG’s press-release page was consulted on November 10, 2026, its most recent entry was dated June 22, 2026, recording an MoU with the State Comptroller of Israel. Nothing about Thiruvananthapuram appears on it. The photo gallery runs to early July 2026. It has room for a stakeholder consultation of the Central Revenue Audit wing, delegation visits from Oman and South Africa, the signing with Israel, and a tree planted with a visiting dignitary from Sharm El Sheikh. It has nothing on the national conference of the PACs.The contrast is sharper when one looks at what the CAG does choose to convene and publicise. In the first quarter of 2026 alone, its press releases record a national conference on the power sector, a national conference of state secretaries on local-government accountability, a workshop with universities on control and governance, and a conclave on its pan-India audit of ease of doing business for MSMEs. In September 2025, the CAG addressed the state finance secretaries; in November 2025 it launched a colloquium series on public understanding of audit findings. The pattern is clear: the CAG talks readily to the executive, to academics and to foreign counterparts. The legislature, the constitutional recipient of its reports under Article 151, is missing from the guest list.Here is the case for the defence, put at its strongest. A conference hosted by a legislature is the legislature’s event, and it is for the Lok Sabha Secretariat and the host assembly to publicise it. The CAG’s web pages are plainly not updated in real time; the press-release page has been quiet since June, so the omission may be a matter of neglect rather than design. And an institution that reports to Parliament should be wary of issuing statements that seem to comment on Parliament’s proceedings.The answer is that none of this explains the asymmetry. An institution that issues press notes on MoUs with Seychelles and Uzbekistan cannot argue that the national gathering of its principal audience is beneath notice. If the public pages have indeed been dormant for five months, that is a separate failing. INTOSAI’s own statement of what makes a supreme audit institution valuable lists “communicating effectively with stakeholders” as a core principle and puts Parliament first among those stakeholders. A SAI’s public window is part of its accountability, not a press-office afterthought.The Empty Chair and the Unnamed DeputiesThe Comptroller and Auditor General, K. Sanjay Murthy, did not attend. No published account mentions him in Thiruvananthapuram, and none suggests that he sent a message. He may well have sought leave of absence and sent his deputy or additional deputies. Whether he was invited, whether a speaking slot was offered to his nominees and declined, or whether the organisers simply wrote the auditor out of the programme is not on the public record, and this note does not pretend to know.I understand from sources within the department that a Deputy CAG, and possibly two Additional Deputy CAGs, attended. No press release, PIB note or newspaper report that I consulted names them, records an address by them, or mentions any intervention in the plenary sessions. By way of contrast, the PAC chairman of the Nagaland assembly received a press note recording that he took part in the plenary and argued for timely submission of CAG reports to State legislatures. A state committee from Kohima left more of a public trail in Thiruvananthapuram than the supreme audit institution of India.Why might the CAG have kept away? He does attend at least the opening PAC meeting where subjects for examination in the year are selected. The kindest explanations deserve a hearing. The CAG ranks with a judge of the Supreme Court, and an officer of that standing might hesitate to sit in an audience addressed by a Speaker, a deputy chairman and a chief minister, or to be seen taking sides in a hall where the Opposition held the chair of Parliament’s PAC and governed the host State. Silence may also be a reflex of a profession that speaks through signed reports, not through speeches. And senior Deputies who attend without speaking may have been following a programme they did not write.Every one of these explanations is a matter of protocol, and protocol is the weakest reason to leave a constitutional conversation without its central voice. Westminster, from which India borrowed both the PAC and the CAG, settled the question long ago. The UK Comptroller and Auditor General attends all meetings of the Commons PAC and regularly appears as a witness, taking part in exchanges with other witnesses. He is by statute an officer of the House of Commons, and the law requires him to have regard to the PAC’s proposals in deciding what to examine. Indian practice has its own version of this: senior audit officers (and CAG, only occasionally) sit through PAC sittings as the committee’s guide. The national conference was simply that relationship at scale. Being present without being heard is, in such a setting, a kind of absence.The Ghost of 2G Walks Into the Assembly HallThe chief minister’s critique deserves to be taken seriously, and so does the reply that never came.First, the facts. The CAG’s 2010 report on the allocation of 2G spectrum did not present a single number. It offered estimates of presumptive loss on several indicators: Rs 67,364 crore on the basis of an offer made by S Tel; Rs 69,626 crore and Rs 57,666 crore on the basis of equity sales by Unitech and Swan Telecom; and Rs 1,76,645 crore on the basis of prices discovered in the 2010 3G auction. The largest of these became the headline, and the headline became a political weapon. R. P. Singh, the Director General who led the audit, later told the Joint Parliamentary Committee that the final figure was at best a “mathematical guess” and that quantifying loss had not been one of the audit’s objectives. The JPC’s majority report called the estimate “ill-conceived”. When 2G spectrum was auctioned in November 2012, bids came to only Rs 9,407 crore, a gift to the CAG’s critics. In December 2017 a special court acquitted all the accused; the CBI’s appeal was admitted by the Delhi high court only in March 2024, after six years and some 125 listings.The Supreme Court, on February 2, 2012 though, quashed all 122 licences granted in 2008, holding that they had been granted in an arbitrary and unconstitutional manner. The court’s later opinion on the Presidential Reference softened the idea that auction was constitutionally required for every natural resource, but it did not restore the cancelled licences. In 2011, when the PAC was examining the report, its chairman Murli Manohar Joshi pointed out that the CAG had given several figures from several models and had never called any of them final. And the November 2012 auction is weaker evidence than it looks. It was held in a market unsettled by the cancellations, and its high reserve price was widely blamed for the poor response, while the 2010 3G auction it was being compared with had raised Rs 67,719 crore over 35 days of bidding.Vizhinjam is a smaller version of the same quarrel. The CAG’s 2017 report on the Rs 7,525 crore port found that by allowing a 40-year concession instead of the standard 30, the state had let the concessionaire collect about Rs 29,217 crore of additional revenue, and that the state’s 67 % investment was not matched by its share of the benefit. Oommen Chandy, who signed the deal, defended the extension as following the Planning Commission’s model concession agreement. The chief minister’s argument that a PPP should not be judged as if it were a PSU is a legitimate professional point. But it is a point for debate in the PAC, where the CAG’s officers sit, not a settled verdict to be pronounced from a podium the CAG did not share.Two things should be said about the politics without being unfair to the speaker. Both 2G and Vizhinjam bruised Satheesan’s own party, the Congress at the Centre in 2010 and the UDF in Kerala in 2017. Yet the same speech defended the CAG robustly against the LDF’s 2021 attempt to vote down its KIIFB findings. Read charitably, his position is consistent: no legislature may reject a CAG report by majority, but the CAG’s methods are open to challenge in the PAC. That is a perfectly defensible stand. It is precisely why the CAG needed to be in the room to answer it.When prosecutions that follow a CAG report collapse, as they did in 2G and in coal, the public reads the acquittal as a verdict on the audit, and the importance of the audit is rather incorrectly diminished. The chief minister’s barb landed on ground already softened by the special court’s judgment of 2017.Should the CAG have replied? The strongest case for silence is a serious one. The CBI’s appeal is pending in the Delhi high court, and any public defence of the loss figure could be portrayed as commenting on a matter before a court. The CAG speaks through reports laid under Article 151, not through speeches at political events. The 2010 report has already been examined by the PAC (though no report was finalized) and by the JPC. And a CAG who rebuts a sitting Chief Minister in his own Assembly risks being drawn into exactly the partisan arena his independence is meant to keep him out of.Each of these is true, and none of them requires silence. Nobody needed the CAG to defend Rs 1.76 lakh crore. What was needed was a short, professional statement of what a presumptive loss is and is not: an estimate of revenue forgone under stated assumptions, given as a range, not a claim that money was stolen. Such a statement would have added that the report gave several estimates, that the Supreme Court quashed the allocations it criticised, that auditing standards allow the financial effect of a deficiency to be quantified where evidence permits, and that the PAC, not a podium, is the place to test the method. That is not politics; it is explanation. Left unanswered, a chief minister’s description of a CAG report as hypothetical becomes, by default, the last word in the national record of the conference.Whose Conference Was It, Anyway?Should the CAG have organised the event itself, with the Speaker as chief guest? The question is a fair one, and I want to answer it carefully, because my answer is not a simple yes.The PAC is a committee of the House. Under Article 151 the CAG’s reports go to the President or the Governor to be laid before the legislature; the legislature does not report to the CAG. National conferences of committee chairpersons have accordingly been convened by the presiding officers. Parliament’s own PAC organised its centenary celebrations in the Central Hall in December 2021. The national conference of Estimates Committees held in Mumbai in June 2025 was announced by the Lok Sabha Secretariat and hosted by the Maharashtra legislature. A CAG who summoned the chairpersons of the PACs to a conference of his own design would turn the constitutional order upside down, and could fairly be accused of canvassing the very committees that are meant to judge his work. Independence cuts both ways: the auditor must be free of the executive, but he must not be seen to manage the legislature either.So the CAG was right not to try to own the PAC’s conference. Where he went wrong was in not co-owning the conversation. There is a middle path, and the CAG already has the vehicle for it. Audit Diwas falls on 16 November every year, marking the day in 1860 when India’s first Auditor General took office. In 2025 the Vice-President inaugurated it, and the CAG used the day to announce new audit priorities. A CAG–PAC national dialogue, co-hosted with the Lok Sabha Secretariat during Audit Week, with the Speaker as chief guest and the CAG presenting the state of the audit pipeline, would respect the hierarchy and still give the auditor a voice. At the very least, a CAG keynote on the evidence in Section III should have been a fixture of the Thiruvananthapuram programme.The asymmetry noted above is the real indictment. The CAG convenes finance secretaries, State secretaries, power-sector managers, universities and foreign SAIs. In the public record I have been able to find, it has not convened legislators on a national scale. An auditor who builds his calendar around the people he audits, and leaves out the people he reports to, has his audiences in the wrong order.The Test of an Audit is?The test of an audit institution is its output: reports that tell Parliament something it did not know about how Union money is designed, released, monitored and turned into results.On that test the record is thin. The Hindu’s analysis of reports on the Union Government tabled in Parliament found an average of 40 a year between 2014 and 2018, falling to 22 a year between 2019 and 2023, with only 18 in 2023. Over the same period the IA&AD’s staff fell from 48,253 in 2013-14 to 41,675 in 2021-22, and IA&AS officers from 789 to 553. Venugopal’s numbers at Thiruvananthapuram, with defence and railways far ahead of health and education, show where the remaining effort goes.But there were some important reports in this time that made an impact. The performance audit of the Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana, tabled in December 2025, exposed bank-account fields left blank or filled with zeros for most beneficiaries. The 2023 audit of Ayushman Bharat–PMJAY found lakhs of beneficiaries linked to a single dummy mobile number, though press reports that officers associated with such audits were later transferred did nothing to encourage boldness. The CAG has also launched a pan-India horizontal audit of ease of doing business for MSMEs across 32 states and UTs, and announced Ease of Living audits of 101 cities and a national audit of foundational literacy and numeracy.But notice the shape of these exceptions. Most of the new pan-India work is organised around “ease” themes and state-level delivery. The big centrally sponsored schemes, on which the Union spends tens of thousands of crores a year, are still examined mostly through State reports. Those reports look at what a State did with the money: utilisation certificates, delays, ineligible beneficiaries, idle assets. They stop at the state boundary. What escapes is everything that happens in Delhi: whether the scheme was well conceived, whether its design assumptions held, how the nodal Ministry decided releases, whether its central dashboards measured outcomes or only outlays, and why the same weaknesses recur in State after State. A scheme designed in Delhi, financed from Delhi and monitored from Delhi cannot be judged in Thiruvananthapuram or Kohima alone. Holistic performance audit asks about economy, efficiency and effectiveness where the decisions are taken.That is why Venugopal’s list matters. POSHAN, Samagra Shiksha, Swachh Bharat, Jan Dhan, Jal Jeevan, PMAY-Gramin: this is, in effect, a Union-level performance-audit programme requested by the chairman of Parliament’s PAC. An AI model trained on twenty thousand inspection reports will find anomalies faster. It will not, by itself, decide to question a Union Ministry. That decision is still made by people, and it is the decision the record shows being made too rarely.Was the CAG right to be absent? Independence, the argument runs, includes the freedom not to attend. The CAG speaks through reports, and the PAC is free to call his officers whenever it likes. There is no evidence that he was invited to speak, and if the organisers built a programme without a CAG slot, the Deputies who attended could only listen. The 2G matter is before the Delhi High Court, and silence there is prudence, not cowardice. Technology investments take years to show results, and Union reports now in the pipeline may yet show them. And a CAG who used a legislators’ conference to defend himself against a Chief Minister would invite exactly the charge of politics that dogged one of his predecessors.Each point has merit, and together they explain a good deal. What they do not do is answer the central question: why the institution whose work was the subject of the conference left no voice, no record and no response. Independence protects the CAG from being told what to audit. It does not oblige him to be silent when his principal audience asks what he is auditing, why so slowly, by what methods and with what tools. Silence on those questions is not neutrality. It is the absence of the one participant who could have turned complaints into an agenda.The Way ForwardThe first lesson concerns presence. The CAG should establish, by convention, a standing CAG–PAC national dialogue held during Audit Week each November and co-hosted with the Lok Sabha Secretariat, with the Speaker as chief guest and the CAG presenting a frank account of the audit pipeline: reports pending tabling, ATNs outstanding, recommendations accepted and recoveries made, compared where possible with peer SAIs. At every all-India PAC conference the CAG, or a named Deputy CAG, should speak, and the CAG should put the text and the officers’ names on its own website. Silent attendance should not be the default.The second lesson concerns method. The 2G debate will not die until the method behind presumptive loss is understood outside the audit department. If the CAG has internal guidance on quantifying presumptive or notional loss, it should publish it in plain language: the circumstances in which quantification is attempted, how benchmarks are chosen, why figures are given as ranges, and how sensitive they are to assumptions. Each PAC could then be offered a briefing on method before it examines a report with a large loss figure, so that arguments about methodology take place in committee, with evidence, and not from a podium.The third concerns time. Article 151 requires reports to be laid before the legislature but sets no time limit. Venugopal’s “justice delayed” complaint will persist until there is one. The CAG should support an outer limit, by statute or by the rules of each House, for laying reports after they reach the President or Governor. In the meantime it should build on its existing “Status of Tabling of Audit Reports” page by publishing, for every report, the date of submission, the date of tabling and the days elapsed. Public delay is harder to sustain than private delay.The fourth concerns data. The conference resolved to extend digital para-monitoring to every State and UT PAC. The CAG already holds paragraph-level data through its CAG-Connect platform, and Venugopal has spoken of the heavy backlog in Parliament’s own Audit Para Monitoring System. A standard data feed from the CAG’s systems to each legislature’s dashboard, showing every paragraph with its ATN status, would answer the resolution’s request for collaboration in the most practical way possible.The fifth, and the most important, concerns what is audited. The CAG should commit to, and publish, a rolling multi-year programme of all-India performance audits of the largest centrally sponsored schemes, with the nodal Union Ministry at the centre of each audit and State-level work feeding into a single national report. Scheme design, fund release, central monitoring and outcomes should all be in scope. The programme should go well beyond the brief “focus areas” the CAG now lists. The CAG should invite the PAC’s suggestions on the programme, much as the UK C&AG must have regard to the PAC’s proposals, while keeping the final choice entirely his own, as the Mexico Declaration’s principle of full discretion in the discharge of SAI functions requires.The sixth concerns the memoranda. Every MoU signed in the name of AI and analytics should carry a published ledger of outcomes. The CAG’s annual report should identify which audit reports used the new tools and what they found that could not have been found before. Without that link the MoUs will remain what they look like from the outside: photographs of signing ceremonies.The seventh concerns capacity. Venugopal said in Thiruvananthapuram that the CAG’s resources and independence directly shape the PAC’s effectiveness. That was an open offer of political support from the Opposition chairman of Parliament’s PAC. The CAG should take it up, with a public case for reversing the decline in staff and for a Union-audit cadre equal to the Union’s spending.Audit Diwas falls today, on November 16, 2026, 12 days after the delegates left Thiruvananthapuram. It is the obvious moment for the CAG to reply, not to the chief minister, but to the conference. P. Sesh Kumar was Director General of Audit at the CAG.