On September 2, I went to the District Collector’s office in Ranchi and found the corridor crowded. Hearings under the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the electoral rolls were underway, and more than 150 people had come. It was a weekday. The corridor was full, and the staff appeared struggling to manage the line. The SIR is the Election Commission’s house-to-house redoing of the rolls. In Jharkhand, booth level officers (BLOs) went door to door with enumeration forms between June 30 and July 29, and the draft roll was published on August 5. Each voter is supposed to be linked to the 2003 roll, which is the product of an earlier intensive revision, through their own entry or a parent’s.Those who cannot be linked, or whose records look inconsistent, get a notice and must appear before the electoral registration officer (ERO), or an assistant (AERO), with documents. Their names are on the draft roll. The number who have to appear this way is large. The state had 2.64 crore electors before the exercise began, and the draft roll has 2.21 crore, after 43.61 lakh names were removed as dead, shifted, untraceable or registered more than once. The Chief Electoral Officer’s office said 63,24,116 voters on it would be served notices, close to three in ten of the names on the draft roll. Of these, 14,03,205 are “unmapped”, with no link to the 2003 roll. Another 3,65,684 are “demographic similar entries”, records in which the name, relative’s name, age and address match, or nearly match, those of another voter, and which are flagged as possible duplicates. The biggest group, 45,55,227 or about 72% of the notices, was flagged for “logical discrepancies”, an administrative label for records that look inconsistent with each other, such as an unlikely age gap between a parent and a child, or a father’s name that differs from one roll to the next.It is easy to count only the voters who end up deleted, and whether any of them were deleted unfairly matters a great deal. But they are the end of a process, and the process touches far more people. Even if the number wrongly deleted turns out to be small, the number put through it is not. Sixty-three lakh voters have been told to prove their electoral status, and proving it costs time and money. I tried to see what that looks like. I spoke to two BLOs, one at a booth picked at random in urban Ranchi and one at a rural booth in Bagodar, so as to hear from both a city and the countryside.I also went through the lists of unmapped voters that the Chief Electoral Officer’s office has published for two booths in Hatia, an urban constituency in Ranchi. I picked Hatia as it has the largest number of notices of any constituency in the state, 1,52,362, according to the Chief Electoral Officer’s figures, so it is not a typical seat. The rest comes from my visit to the collectorate. Most of the people I spoke to in the corridor had come with only a Voter ID card and Aadhaar. A woman waiting there told me that officials were asking for a jati praman patra (caste certificate) or an awasiya praman patra (residence certificate). So a Voter ID and Aadhaar were not enough on their own. The Ranchi BLO, whom I reached by phone on the number listed on the Election Commission’s Jharkhand website, gave me a longer list of what a flagged voter is told to bring: LIC and bank documents, post office records for those born before 1987, a birth or residence certificate, a caste certificate, a passport, a matriculation certificate.Aadhaar alone is not accepted, he said, and a voter with no accepted document will be deleted. Someone who misses a hearing gets a second notice and another date to attend. Outside the office, touts and stalls were persuading people to have affidavits drawn up, at Rs 300 to Rs 500 each. As far as I could tell, most of these were not needed. An affidavit is required in some cases: when a family member appears on a voter’s behalf, as the Ranchi BLO told me.Also read: What is the SIR Costing?Most of the people paying at the stalls did not seem to be in the position. Rs 300 to Rs 500 is real money for a family that lives on daily wages. Jharkhand’s minimum wage for unskilled work in its larger cities is about Rs 520 a day, so an affidavit can cost most of a day’s pay. My own errand was an affidavit for a name error, stating that two versions of my name belong to one person, me, but not related with the SIR anyhow. I first took it to one sub-divisional officer (SDO), who was acting as executive magistrate. The SDO turned it down, because my permanent address was in Giridih and not Ranchi. Another SDO, however, accepted and signed it the same day. That is one experience, not a survey, but it shows how much can depend on which officer you reach.Asked which groups are easiest to lose from the list, the Bagodar BLO, an Anganwadi worker, put migrant workers first. They are away when the BLO visits, she said, or absent from the household when the forms are filled. I did not meet migrant workers in this work, so that is her account and my inference rather than something I saw. Still, the inference is not hard to make. A worker in another state who gets a notice must either come home for a hearing, losing days of work and the fare, or send a family member, who needs an affidavit and a written application.WomenWomen are caught in a different way. In the two Hatia booths I looked at, 172 voters are unmapped, 56 in one and 116 in the other, and about two in five of them are women recorded only through a husband’s name. The lists give only the unmapped voters, not each booth’s total electorate, so I cannot say what share of the roll that is. For the constituency as a whole, the Chief Electoral Officer’s figures show 59,411 of 5,49,975 electors as unmapped, about 11%. This fits what has been reported from other states. In Bihar, people told Scroll that women who had come to their villages after marriage could not get documents from their parents’ homes, and that the 2003 list was hard to access. In Karnataka, activists said married women would have to produce their own 2002 entry, or a parent’s, grandparent’s or sibling’s, and show they were the same person despite a change of name. It would be no surprise if Jharkhand’s story were the same.Also read: Did 27 Lakhs Lose the Right to Vote Because the EC Software Switched Bengal Voters Already Decided by EROs Over to Judges Overnight?A woman’s 2003 entry may sit under her father’s name in her parents’ booth, and a matching exercise confined to her present booth never goes looking there. The Bagodar BLO described the same trap from the other end. Women who cannot read or write, are widowed or are out of touch with their parents are easily eliminated, she said, because they cannot produce a parent’s entry in the roll. A widow whose husband was never enrolled can drop off the list entirely. Another woman, the BLO told me, lost her husband before and no documents were collected from her, and she can no longer be traced at the address on record.Naming conventions add to it. The BLO listed “Devi” and “Kumari” being added or dropped around marriage among the common mismatches, and called confusion between husband (pati) and father (pita) in the relationship field the main reason behind the logical discrepancy flags. The elderly have a more insurmountable problem. Many of them have received notices, and many cannot keep travelling to the office, because of their health and the cost of the trips. At the collectorate, I met a man in his seventies who was not fluent in Hindi and spoke Sadri, the local language. He had come with only his Aadhaar card, which officials in the same building were treating as insufficient on its own. Getting to the collectorate in Ranchi costs him Rs 100, he said, which matters a lot to him. The unmapped lists for the two Hatia booths include people in their seventies and eighties, and over half the people on them are 41 or older, old enough to have been on the 2003 roll. These are not first-time voters. Many of them have probably been voting for years, and are now being asked to prove again that they belong on the roll.Others fall through in less obvious ways. The Ranchi BLO said urban areas with rental residents and roadside-stall dwellers are the most prone to trouble, and that many electors cannot be found at the address on record. He also said name errors are common because the 2003 roll itself has many, which leaves the voter to correct the Commission’s old mistakes. A voter whose permanent address is in another district can have an affidavit turned away, as I found. And families come as families: in one Hatia booth a father, his wife and their three children are all on the unmapped list, which means five sets of papers and, most likely, one long day.The techNone of this is helped by the state of the machinery. The Bagodar BLO said the ECI portal’s server goes down so often that a BLO can enter the details of 60 to 80 voters on a good day and fewer than two on a bad one, and some stay up until two or three in the morning to finish. Training and meetings are at the block headquarters, which can be about 30 km away. Most BLOs, she said, are Anganwadi workers or Jal Sahiyas, the village water and sanitation workers, doing this on top of their jobs, and nobody was tested or recruited for it. The Ranchi BLO, a teacher, said BLOs have not been trained for this process yet, and that the AERO, the ERO and the ECI do not coordinate with one another. Between them they ask for a working phone or tablet, money for recharge and fuel, and a wage that matches the work. In West Bengal, The Reporters’ Collective reported in January that software deployed without written instructions had flagged 1.31 crore voters there, 17% of the roll, for logical discrepancies. A senior Election Commission official told it that the digitisation of the old rolls had not been tested for quality, and that this probably led to voters being wrongly flagged. Later that month the Supreme Court ordered that voters flagged for logical discrepancies in West Bengal could file documents and objections at panchayat and block offices, through an authorised representative if need be, and gave them 10 more days.These are two booths in one urban constituency, two BLOs and one visit to one office, and I make no claim beyond them. The Bagodar BLO described one woman, Pramil Devi, to me. Her name is not in the 2003 roll and no record of her grandparents could be found. Her husband passed away a few years ago. She has no residence certificate either, and the BLO could not reach her parents. The people in the Ranchi crowd could at least get to a counter, even if they were sent away for another certificate or an affidavit. She may never get to one. If her name goes, she will be counted among the deleted. The people who paid for the queue, in time, fares and affidavit fees, will not be counted anywhere. The final roll has been pushed back again and is now due on November 30, and I do not know whether her name will be on it.Ronit Kumar Singh is an undergraduate student and recipient of the UCL Global Undergraduate Scholarship 2025 at University College London. He is a research intern with Jean Dreze.