Activists Write to Kerala CM, Women's Commission on Hadiya Case

"It is alarming to have an adult woman today to be ordered into 'protective custody' of her parent’s home under the orders of a Court, denied mobility, communication and the company of her friends and well wishers."

A group of women’s rights activists organisations have written to Kerala chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan and Kerala State Women’s Commission chief M.C. Josephine to express their “outrage and concern” on the isolation of Hadiya, a 24-year-old woman who converted to Islam and married a Muslim man by her own free will, in her parental home. The Kerala high court had annulled the marriage between Hadiya and Shafin Jahan after her father said it was a case of ‘love jihad‘, though she insisted she had not been coerced into marriage. The Supreme Court is now going to probe whether the high court has the authority to annul a marriage when none of the two involved have asked for it.

The letter written by the organisations and activists is reproduced below.


We write to you as individuals and organisations who are part of the women’s movement to express our outrage and concern regarding the dangerous implications of Hadiya’s continued isolation and imprisonment in her parental home. We are aware of the positive step that the State Women’s Commission has taken through filing an SLP in the Supreme Court regarding seeking directions from the bench for a meeting with Hadiya as part of its duty as an institution mandated to ensure that women are not subjected to unfair practices and denial of their civil rights.

We welcome the Supreme Court’s decision to examine the High Court order vis a vis use of Article 226 to declare Hadiya’s marriage as invalid. We also appreciate the honourable courts’ decision to relook at the issue of ‘protection’ for Hadiya outside of her family. These are a recognition of the serious nature of violations that have impacted her liberty and freedom as an individual.

Also read: The Kerala High Court Thinks Love Jihad Is Real, But Women’s Independence Is Not

As women’s rights activists from across the country, we urge you to take steps to ensure that Hadiya is not forcibly confined in the home of her natal family, denied the right to cohabit with her husband, and be subjected to coercion for exercising opting for faith of her choice. It is alarming to have an adult woman today to be ordered into “protective custody” of her parent’s home under the orders of a court, denied mobility, communication and the company of her friends and well wishers. Reports of  domestic violence at the hands of her family, which if true, is a travesty that places upon your Commission the duty of initiating an inquiry.  This situation cannot be ignored or allowed to continue.

As you well know, the issue is not about what her family, religious extremist organisations – whether Hindu or Muslim, or even we in the women’s movement, think of her choice of partner. The fact is that she is an adult and that she has the autonomy and the fundamental right to make choices regarding her work, her religion and her partner.

Also read: Hadiya’s Struggle Against Her Family and the Courts May Soon Resonate With All Indian Women

We appreciate and support the efforts of all activists and women’s organisations in Kerala, and we are conveying our concern and sharing some suggestions emerging from our discussions.

  • The State Women’s Commission of Kerala immediately visit Hadiya to assess the nature of human rights violations that she is facing.
  • The Kerala SWC assess and make public a report on Hadiya’s condition.
  • Hadiya be brought under the protection of the State, perhaps in a shelter in consultation with her.
  • The Kerala SWC and the LDF government must immediately ensure that friends and well wishers be allowed to meet Hadiya and that she is allowed access to a phone and communication beyond the walls of her parental home.
  • We urge you to intensify the efforts that you are already making towards action on her virtual house arrest.

In solidarity,

Nandini Sundar
Tanika Sarkar
Kalyani Menon Sen
Mary John
Uma Chakravarti
Abha Bhaiya
Virginia Saldanah
Urvashi Butalia
Malika Virdhi
Deepa Dhanraj
Disha Mullick
Uma V. Chandru
Purnima Gupta
G. Arunima
Farah Naqvi
Pramada Menon
Chaitali Haldar
Rohini Hensman
Ayesha Kidwai
Lalitha Ramdas
Susie Tharu
Madhu Mehra
Jaya Sharma
Dipta Bhog
Panchali Ray
Madhavi Kukreja
Brinda Bose
Vimala Ramachandran
Johanna Lokhande
LABIA –A Queer Feminist Collective
Bindu Menon
Svati Joshi
Shahira Naim
Janaki Abraham
Suneeta Dhar
Jashodhara Dasgupta
Amrita Nandy
Kavita Punjabi
Ranjani Mazumdar
Sarmistha Dutta Gupta
Nivedita Menon
Rakhi Sehgal
Radhika Desai
Neeraj Malik
Javed Malik
Baaran Ijlaal
Svati Shah
Karuna D.W.
Sangeeta Chatterji
Geetha Nasmisaan
Jan Abhiyan Sansthan, Shimla
Bebaak Collective-Voice of the Fearless
Vandana Mahajan
Teena Gill
Anup Kumar
Mast Ram
Anurita. P. Hazarika
Nilanju Dutta
Ranjita Biswas
West Bengal Forum for  Gender and Sexual Minority Rights (WBGSMR)
Sayantan Dutta
Malini Ghosh