Bengaluru: With tense pushbacks regularly punctuating the closing session of the 31st Conference of Parties (COP31) on the evening of November 22 (Sunday) at Antalya, Turkey, several countries and negotiating blocs refused to accept the final cover decision (the main agreement and outcome) put forward by the Presidency on the last day of this year’s UN climate summit. As a result, the Presidency comprising Turkey and Australia could not adopt the main cover decision, called the Antalya Pact, despite 14 days of negotiations and discussions.India was among the few countries and blocs (on behalf of Like-Minded Developing Countries) that agreed to accept the cover decision, in the interest of multilateralism despite the final cover text containing elements it did not agree with. Others like the European Union rejected the text outright.It was among the blocs and several member countries that expressed “profound disappointment” that the UN climate summit, which began in Antalya on November 9, did not achieve consensus. Among the concerns that these countries raised for rejecting the final decision text proposed by the Presidency was the lack of mention of fossil fuels, no timelines or baselines for climate finance, and the recommendation of carbon capture and storage technologies that some argued gives less incentive to move away from fossil fuels.Climate activists and experts have also criticised the lack of consensus at a time when the world is hurtling towards irreversible threshold breaches due to global warming.No consensusNovember 22 marked Day 14 of COP31 on climate change, which is conducted annually by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). The Conference aims to get member countries to take active steps to achieve targets specified in the Paris Agreement of 2015, primarily to ensure that the increase in the global average temperature is kept well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, and pursue efforts to limit the temperature increase to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.This year’s climate summit began on November 9 and was to end on November 20. However, with no consensus on critical negotiating points, the Presidency – Turkey and Australia – extended it by two days.The closing plenary on the evening of November 22, delayed by several hours, was marked by dissent and tense disagreements primarily revolving around the main text or the ‘cover decision’ – called the Antalya Pact – that was to have been among the prime outcomes of the summit. Several countries and negotiating blocs refused to agree to the cover decision.“The European Union and its member states object to the Antalya Pact formally,” said Irish climate minister Darragh O’Brien on behalf of the EU at the closing plenary.“Because it fails to meet the moment. The moment that our world faces, the crisis that our world faces. We express profound disappointment with the final draft COP31 cover decision or Antalya Pact. At a time when the world urgently needs action to avert disastrous levels of global warming, the draft cover decision falls well short. We will not endorse a decision that does not respond to the science, that disregards the implementation gap, and that actually risks deepening the chasm between the global commitments and the action required to correct the overshoot and bring 1.5 Degrees back within reach.”Darragh O’Brien, minister of climate, energy and the environment of Ireland, left, and Wopke Hoekstra, EU climate commissioner, speak outside a plenary session at COP31 UN Climate Summit. Photo: AP/Khalil Hamra.No mention of fossil fuels, and other issues“We will not endorse a cover decision or Antalya Pact that does not even mention fossil fuels, which is the key driver of climate change … we will not accept a COP that greenwashes fossil fuels,” he added.Ghana on behalf of the African group of negotiators said that the Pact falls short on adaptation finance.“The decision reaffirms the goal to at least triple adaptation by 2035, but it gives no baseline and no figure,” it said. “The language welcomes and encourages on Loss and Damage [funds] but sets no resource targets.”The Marshall Islands refused to agree to the cover decision too, citing lack of climate finance and that “partners” had turned up with “empty hands”:“We have been let down on all sides … we will not be forced to accept false solutions,” the nation held. “We will not accept an outcome that threatens our future … We cannot survive on empty promises.”The United Kingdom also expressed its “profound disappointment” at the substance of the cover decision. “What is before us is not commensurate with the urgency of overshoot, the scale of the climate crisis or the impacts already being felt by the most vulnerable people and communities around the world,” it held.India’s stand in ‘spirit of multilateralism’India was among the few countries and blocs that agreed to accept the cover decision. Speaking on behalf of Like-Minded Developing Countries, it said that while the final cover text does contain elements it does not agree with, India was still continuing to engage in the “spirit of multilateralism”.“There are still some elements of the text even we are not comfortable with, but we continue to engage even at this late stage of the process … We had expressed our concern about the principles of equity, and CBDR-RC [Common But Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities] not being adequately represented,” said additional secretary of India’s Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, Amandeep Garg, representing India at the plenary.The bloc had also expressed concerns about the dilution of historical responsibilities and obligations of the developed country parties in the text, Garg said. The cover decision does not take into account how the world got to this threshold of crossing 1.5°C of global warming, and whose emissions – both past and continuing – have exhausted the carbon budget.Activists participate in a demonstration holding signs that say “shame” at COP31, on November 20, 2026. Photo: AP/Khalil Hamra.“On top of this our partners have refused to engage on the issue of climate finance across different negotiating rooms. In fact we were told that despite the increasing needs of developing countries due to a problem that we have not caused, we should not expect our developed country partners to even engage on the issue of climate finance since it was dead in the water.”But as India is committed to multilateralism and the principles of consensus, it is willing to move forward and continue to engage “despite our discomfort”, Garg said.“At #COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, India engaged constructively till the very end, working with BASIC and LMDC partners for a balanced outcome rooted in equity, CBDR-RC, climate finance and adaptation. We regret that consensus on the cover decision could not be reached,” said India’s Union environment minister Bhupender Yadav in a post on X on November 22 as COP31 drew to a close.But the absence of a cover decision does not pause climate action, he said. India continues to deliver at home, with over 170 GW of solar capacity, and remains committed to consensus-based multilateralism on the road to COP32. Historical and continuing emissions have consumed a disproportionate share of the global carbon budget, so equity and climate justice must therefore remain at the heart of our collective response, he said.Ghana also later changed its stance from not accepting the cover decision to accepting it towards the end of the plenary.“We are allowing this text to be adopted in the spirit of multilateralism,” it said. “We leave the COP still fighting for delivery.”The overarching consensus was, however, clear. And the Presidency could not adopt the Antalya Pact. Other negotiating texts including those on the Mitigation Work Programme (a UNFCCC process created to urgently scale up global mitigation action and implementation to meet the Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C goal) and the Global Environment Facility (a multilateral environmental fund established in 1991 that provides grants and blended finance for environmental projects in developing countries) did not find consensus either and were subsequently not adopted.UN officials express disappointment“I am deeply disappointed that COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome,” said UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, in a statement on November 22. “I share the very profound frustration of all those who expected governments to rise to the moment the climate crisis demands.”However, this setback does not change the facts, he said. There may be no consensus in the negotiating room but there is no ambiguity in the science, he said.“Temperatures keep shattering records. Climate extremes keep intensifying. Emissions remain far too high. And every delay makes our task harder and more costly. The world is now poised to exceed the globally agreed limit of a 1.5 degree temperature rise. The window to keep that overshoot as short and shallow as possible is rapidly closing. The take-home message from COP31 is clear: the world must do much more to confront the climate crisis – and it must do it now.”Activists participate in a demonstration for climate finance at COP31 on November 10, 2026. Photo: AP/Khalil Hamra.He shares the “deep disappointment” of many with COP31 being unable to agree on issues related to both Presidency’s led decisions, said UN Climate Change executive secretary Simon Stiell at the COP31 closing ceremony in Antalya on November 22.“The world cannot afford a repeat of this moment,” Stiell said. “Our process – including the rulebook and precedents – are designed to bring almost 200 countries together. As we have seen repeatedly over the past decade, that delivers results … Antalya will reinforce our resolve for an ambitious outcome. This process has suffered setbacks before and come back stronger. It must do so again.”Experts, activists concurThe rejection of the Antalya Pact shows that the world will not accept going backwards, commented Harjeet Singh, global convenor of the Fill the Fund campaign and founding director of the Satat Sampada Climate Foundation.“What we need now is a plan, not repackaged national roadmaps, and it must be fair, fast and funded,” he said. “Fair, so rich countries move first. Fast, in line with science. Funded, so developing countries get the support to make the shift.”The Adaptation Fund, which delivers money directly to frontline communities, raised barely $50 million at COP31 against a target of $300 million a year, Singh added:“The text’s [Antalya Pact’s] response was to ‘encourage contributions’, with no amount, no deadline and no country named. With the $120 billion figure deleted and the tripling pathway pushed to 2027, the message to the world’s most vulnerable was clear: you’re on your own. Any new text must put real numbers back on the table.”The COP31 process has betrayed people’s health by failing to deliver a clear plan for transitioning away from fossil fuels or providing the finance countries need to protect lives and prepare their health systems for escalating climate shocks, said Dr Jeni Miller, executive director of the Global Climate and Health Alliance, a consortium of more than 300 health professional and health civil society organisations and networks from around the world addressing climate change.“COP31 and its presidents Australia and Türkiye did not deliver the necessary protection for people’s health and lives – the rightly rejected ‘Antalya Pact’ did not mention health at all even as climate change compounds this year’s super El Nino, causing severe droughts in Fiji and Bolivia, extreme flooding in the western US, and wildfires in Southeast Asia, and putting millions of additional people at risk of hunger or famine,” Miller said in a statement.“Global cooperation and the UNFCCC process are critical for protecting humanity in the face of the profound health crisis that climate change represents. Countries that block progress, by failing to meet their obligations on finance, or by pushing delay to keep exploiting and profiting from fossil fuel use and production at the world’s expense, cannot be allowed to derail the action that is needed. COP must do better.”