New Delhi: A controversy continues at Kolkata’s Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute (SRFTI) over alleged attacks on students and the administration’s response. The institute’s alumni have now formed a three-member fact-finding committee to conduct an independent inquiry into these incidents. The committee includes actress Ratna Pathak Shah, writer Anita Agnihotri, and former bureaucrat Jawhar Sircar.Speaking to The Wire Hindi, committee member and former Union Information and Broadcasting Secretary, Jawhar Sircar, questioned the functioning of the Special Investigation Team (SIT) constituted by the West Bengal government. He pointed out that more than six weeks have passed since the SIT was formed, yet it has not recorded a statement from any student.“It has been over a month and a half since the SIT was formed, yet they have not met with the students even once,” Sircar said. “The team did visit the campus once and met with the vice-chancellor, the dean, and other officials, but it did not speak to any students. The students were simply assured that they need not worry and that everything would be fine. But this is not the same as conducting an investigation and listening to people.”In this regard, Poorvi, additional general secretary of the SRFTI Students’ Union, told The Wire Hindi that the SIT held a meeting with three student union representatives on October 30. However, the students’ statements were not recorded, nor were they asked for any information regarding the events of September 27.According to Poorvi, the SIT merely provided information about its own investigation during the meeting and urged the students to resume classes. She noted that no details concerning the incidents were sought nor was the students’ perspective heard.Union general secretary Nachiket said that the SIT members spent a considerable amount of time on campus with the institute’s administration. Afterward, Nachiket, Poorvi and Union president Blossom were called in. However, he added that the SIT did not ask them for any details about the incidents. Also read: Hindutva Attack, Six Students Expelled, Campus Shut: What’s Happening at Kolkata’s SRFTI?Nachiket believes that the investigation is heavily influenced by the institute’s V-C.Jawhar Sircar pointed out that the scope of the SIT’s investigation is confined to the September 27 incident, even though violence also occurred just outside the institute on October 4. He further added that the investigation should also examine the police’s role and subsequent actions taken by the institute’s administration against the students.He explained that, for this reason, the alumni committee has decided to establish an independent fact-finding panel. The objective of this panel is to understand the events of September 27 and October 4, as well as the circumstances that followed; record statements from those affected; and compile an independent account of what transpired.V-C accused of taking action against studentsSircar also raised questions regarding the role of the institute’s Vice-Chancellor, Santosh Ajmera, following the incident on October 4.He alleged that it was clearly politically motivated, involving members of the Hindu Jagran Manch. This particular incident is not being investigated. Instead of investigating the violence and ensuring students’ safety, the administration initiated action against them.“Instead of investigating the incident of October 4, the V-C began expelling students. Some were issued show-cause notices, while others were threatened. Contractual faculty members were also dismissed. All of this began after October 4,” Sircar noted.He described the action as an attempt to create an “atmosphere of terror.” According to them, the students had warned the administration on October 2 that they might be attacked on October 4. Despite this warning, the incident took place.Notably, on October 15, the institute issued an order expelling six students. Five were expelled for two semesters, while one student, Shubham Waydande, was expelled for three semesters. An FIR was also registered against Shubham over the alleged attack on the V-C.Calcutta high court lawyer Jhuma Sen, who is representing the students, had earlier told The Wire Hindi that they were not even given a chance to present their case before being expelled. She said the action was legally wrong.Meanwhile, SRFTI administration said in its response that action against the six students was taken after they allegedly misbehaved with, threatened and assaulted the V-C on October 15. According to the administration, the action was taken on the recommendation of the Dean Council.Three-member committee to record statements of students and teachersSRFTI alumni have formed a three-member committee to conduct an independent inquiry into the entire matter. The committee includes actor Ratna Pathak Shah, writer Anita Agnihotri and former bureaucrat Jawhar Sircar.Ratna Pathak Shah’s husband and actor Naseeruddin Shah had earlier alleged that SRFTI students were being targeted following the BJP’s victory in the West Bengal assembly elections, calling it an act of revenge against them.This committee will record statements of students, teachers, staff, alumni and anyone else with firsthand knowledge of the events or affected by them. The committee said it will independently document the incidents and make its findings public.The committee scheduled a hearing for 10 am on November 13. The notice issued for the hearing said it would not be a regular public hearing. Statements would be recorded confidentially and the hearing would be closed to the press and media. People with direct knowledge were urged to contact the committee directly.Sircar told The Wire Hindi that the committee is expected to receive statements and evidence from a large number of people. As a result, the investigation may take about a month to complete.He said, “We will publish our investigation report, but it will take time. There are hundreds of statements, and people will also need to provide evidence to support their claims. We will review that evidence and decide whether it is admissible.”Institute calls the committee unauthorisedMeanwhile, the SRFTI administration has expressed objection to the decision to form an independent investigation committee.In a letter sent to the alumni committee on November 12, the institute’s registrar, Deepak Kumar, said that the West Bengal government’s SIT was already investigating the matter. The institute has also set up its own fact-checking committee. Therefore, an unauthorized private organization had no legal basis to conduct a parallel investigation. The registrar alleged that such an inquiry could be intended to invent conflicting accounts, distort facts and undermine the ongoing investigation. He said that the institute would fully cooperate with the SIT and that everyone involved should respect the legal process.In response, the alumni committee sent a letter to the registrar on November 13. The committee said that it did not need government approval or statutory authority, as it was an independent body formed through a citizens’ initiative.Also read: ‘Threat From Within’: SRFTI Students Speak of Intimidation by Admin Amid Episodes of ViolenceThe letter stated, “This committee has no legal authority to summon anyone, compel the production of records or hold anyone guilty. It will hear from those who choose to appear before it and publish the findings of its investigation.”Citing Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(b) of the Constitution, the committee said that citizens have the right to freedom of expression and to assemble peacefully. The country has a long-standing tradition of forming independent citizens’ inquiry committees led by retired judges and other public figures.‘The scope of SIT and our investigation is different’In its response, the alumni committee also clarified that its inquiry is not running parallel to the SIT’s investigation. According to the committee, under the West Bengal government’s September 30, 2026, order, the SIT is investigating criminal cases related to the September 27 incident.On the contrary, the independent committee’s investigation covers a wider scope. It includes the events of October 4, the roles played by the institute and the police at the time, and the administrative action taken against students on October 15 and afterward.The letter said, “We will not obstruct the SIT’s work. Once our report is published, we will also share it with the SIT.”The committee also questioned how a fact-finding panel set up by the institution could serve as an independent inquiry when the role of the administration itself is under scrutiny. It asked the registrar to provide the order establishing the panel, details of its members and the specific matters it has been asked to investigate.The committee also assured the institute that it was willing to hear the administration’s side. The letter stated that the institute has been given a chance to present its position. If it did not take part, the report would note that it had been invited to share its views but chose not to participate.The committee also expressed concern that students, teachers or other staff members who testify before it should not face harassment or retaliation of any kind. It expressed hope that the institute would not prevent anyone from presenting their views to the committee.The West Bengal government had constituted the SIT on September 30 to investigate the incident that took place three days before. The team is led by Kunal Aggarwal, Additional Commissioner of Police (Crime) of Kolkata Police. The SIT was entrusted with the investigation of three FIRs lodged at Panchsayar police station and was directed to submit its first report to the state government by October 1.According to an Akashvani News report published on October 2, the SIT had submitted its first six-page report to the state’s Department of Home and Hill Affairs. The report said that the SIT had interrogated 23 people so far and identified 250 others.For more clarity on the case, an email was sent to SIT chief Kunal Aggarwal seeking details on the current status of the investigation, the statements of students and witnesses recorded so far and whether the October 4 incident has been included in the scope of the probe. The report will be updated once a response is received.Role of Union governmentIn the conversation, Jawhar Sircar also raised the issue of responsibility held by the Union government and the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, under whose administrative jurisdiction SRFTI falls. Notably, Sircar has previously served as secretary in this ministry.When asked whether the ministry should have intervened, he said, “Yes, the ministry should have done something.”However, he went on to raise concerns about political interference and alleged attacks at other educational institutions across West Bengal. He said, “You have to understand that in West Bengal, the chief minister himself is attacking every prestigious institution. He led thousands of naga sadhus in a procession outside Jadavpur University and threatened the faculty and students from the main gate saying, ‘We will teach you a lesson’. No chief minister has done anything like this before – not even Yogi Adityanath. Imagine going to the gate of Lucknow University and yelling that all its students will be taught a lesson. This was a public statement by the chief minister.”Sircar further said, “After that, he (the chief minister) also threatened students at Kolkata’s Presidency University, Bengal’s second-most prestigious institution. The controversy began when someone tore down an ABVP poster.”Meanwhile, taking action in the matter, Presidency University expelled two students accused of allegedly damaging a poster of Vivekananda. One of them had completed her postgraduate studies only a few months ago. The university has also barred both students from applying for admission to any of its courses in the future.”Sircar linked these incidents to developments at SRFTI and said, “A similar pattern is visible at Jadavpur, Presidency and SRFTI. This is a case of right-wing terror.”Committee report expected in a monthSircar said the committee would not draw conclusions based solely on allegations. Those who have alleged assault, battery or threats need to provide videos and other evidence to support their claims.The committee, he noted, would hear people out and examine it based on the available evidence. Only after that would it decide which facts could be included in the report.Meanwhile, the SRFTI administration has suspended academic activities on campus until December 11, extending the initially set date until November 13.Disputes between students and administration have disrupted classes at the institute with students demanding improved safety, the withdrawal of expulsion orders and accountability from the V-C.In such a situation, the independent committee’s inquiry should not be limited to the events of September 27 and October 4. It must also examine the steps taken by the institute’s administration afterwards, how it responded to students’ complaints, and what efforts were made to restore a normal academic atmosphere on campus.The committee said it would make the findings of its investigation public. According to Sircar, preparing the report could take about a month.This article first appeared in The Wire Hindi. It has been translated by Naushin Rehman.