New Delhi: After a US judge requested Indian courts to enable the service of summonses to national security adviser Ajit Doval and former Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) secretary Samant Goel in connection with a civil lawsuit filed by Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, India reiterated its stance that the suit is without basis.“I had stated from this very platform that we reject such baseless lawsuits. That continues to be our position on the matter,” said Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal on Friday (November 20).Earlier this month, on November 9, Judge Katherine Failla of the US federal court for the Southern District of New York had granted Pannun’s request to have the summonses to Doval and Goel transmitted by the American judiciary to those Delhi courts that have jurisdiction over the addresses at which the duo is believed to live.Pannun, an American and Canadian citizen who is general counsel for the pro-Khalistan Sikhs for Justice organisation, had filed the civil lawsuit in 2024 naming the Indian government, Doval, Goel, former RAW officer ‘Vikram’ Yadav, Nikhil Gupta as well as 50 unnamed individuals and accusing them of conspiring to kill him in retaliation against his advocacy for a separate Sikh country.US prosecutors have alleged that Yadav – whose actual name they later revealed to be Vikash – orchestrated a plot to murder Pannun at his home in New York that was ultimately foiled by American law enforcement officers. Their criminal case, which entered the public spotlight in 2023, is separate from Pannun’s civil lawsuit.Judge Victor Marrero of the same federal court on Friday sentenced Indian national Gupta to 19 years and seven months in prison for murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering in the matter. Yadav’s whereabouts are unknown.In her November 9 order, Judge Failla had agreed with Pannun’s argument that Article 19 of the Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents would allow for summonses in his civil suit to be served through the Indian judiciary.Article 19 allows countries party to the Convention – including India and the US – to retain domestic laws allowing transmission of foreign judicial documents for service within their territories by methods that are not otherwise mentioned in the Convention.Judge Failla agreed that in India’s case the law concerned is section 29(c) of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The provision says that civil courts outside of India that the Union government has notified to be applicable under the Code may send summonses to Indian courts and that these summonses can in turn be served as if they were issued by the Indian courts concerned. In 2009, the government notified all civil courts in fellow countries party to the Hague Convention as covered by section 29(c).On November 13, Judge Failla accepted Pannun’s packet of submissions, including the summonses to Doval and Pannun, and directed the court’s clerk to deliver them to the Patiala House, Tis Hazari and Dwarka courts in Delhi, which have jurisdiction over the two officials’ addresses.She requested the three courts to accept the summonses and other documents and cause them to be served to Doval and Goel in accordance with the relevant procedures. The judge also asked the courts to provide a written record of the proceedings undertaken.Pannun’s attempt to serve his summonses via the court-to-court route came after his lawyers failed to do so directly to Doval in person during his 2023 US visit.They had also attempted to serve Doval, Goel and Yadav the summonses through the Union law and justice ministry, which is India’s central authority under Article 5 of the Hague Convention. This article provides that a central authority shall itself serve or arrange to serve summonses. Pannun claimed that the ministry returned his documents on the stated grounds that they did not fall within the relevant categories.Weeks before Judge Failla’s orders, the Department of State on October 20 had also informed the court that it transmitted the summons to and complaint against the Union government.MEA spokesperson Jaiswal said on November 10 that India rejects the “fabricated and malicious attacks on our high officials” as well as Pannun’s “frivolous” lawsuit. “Request[s] for serving of judicial documents in India can only be routed through India’s designated Central Authority, that is the Ministry of Law and Justice,” he added.