New Delhi: After a gap of over two years, leaders of the four Quad countries finally met on Tuesday (November 17), but the summit saw noticeably less emphasis on criticising China’s maritime actions in the Indo-Pacific, even as it flagged concerns over “economic coercion”.India was supposed to host the leaders’ summit in 2025, but the annual pow-wow had fallen by the wayside under the second Donald Trump administration until now. Although the foreign ministers continued to meet, the leaders had not convened since 2024, breaking a run of annual summits that began in 2021.Their meeting in Manila was also the first time the four leaders had gathered in a non-Quad member country. There was no mention of any future leaders’ meeting for next year by any leader or in a diplomatic document.Trump arrived in Manila on the final day of the ASEAN summit and went straight into a Quad leaders’ meeting at the Solaire Resort. Lasting approximately 90 minutes, the meeting between the leaders of India, Australia, the United States and Japan began with a joint photo session and opening remarks to the media.However, the Quad meeting was taking place amid considerable anticipation over the first-ever trilateral summit between Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping, scheduled for Wednesday in China. The upcoming meeting also dominated the questions during the photo session, with Trump fielding queries largely about China, the Nvidia controversy and the trilateral summit, while the other three leaders stood silently beside him.A quieter line on China’s maritime actionsTwo years ago, the Wilmington Declaration as per the norm didn’t name China, but it was rather more explicit than usual in criticising actions taken by Beijing in the disputed waters of the Indo-Pacific.In 2024, the declaration said the Quad leaders were “seriously concerned about the situation in the East and South China Seas”. It specifically criticised the “militarisation of disputed features” and “coercive and intimidating manoeuvres” in the South China Sea, and condemned the “dangerous use of coast guard and maritime militia vessels”. The declaration also endorsed the 2016 Arbitral Award on the South China Sea, describing it as a “significant milestone” and the basis for peacefully resolving disputes between the parties.The November 17 joint press release dropped all these specific references. The absence of the 2016 Arbitral Award was especially notable given that the summit was being held in the Philippines, where tensions with Beijing over the South China Sea have remained high despite recent diplomatic efforts to lower the rhetoric.Instead, it retained the broader formulation that the four countries “strongly oppose any destabilising or unilateral actions that seek to change the status quo, including by force or coercion”. Unlike in 2024, however, this was not followed by any implicit reference to specific maritime disputes or the conduct of any country’s vessels in the region.China nevertheless remained an implicit presence in the 2026 joint press release, and despite the reduced emphasis on the country’s maritime actions in its public messaging, the Quad continued to keep maritime security on its agenda. File photo: AP/Jae C. Hong.China nevertheless remained an implicit presence in the 2026 joint press release. The leaders expressed “grave concerns about economic coercion, including through arbitrary export restrictions”, while also referring to the need to secure critical supply chains and protect freedom of navigation and overflight.The reference to export restrictions comes amid growing concerns over China’s use of controls on critical minerals, particularly rare earths, of which it is the world’s dominant processor. China has also imposed restrictions on specific foreign companies, including those based in the US, Japan and Europe.Despite the reduced emphasis on China’s maritime actions in the public messaging, the Quad continued to keep maritime security on its agenda.The Manila press release announced the Indo-Pacific Maritime Surveillance Collaboration, which it described as “a new initiative to enhance information sharing and maritime domain awareness”. The leaders also said that “our respective P-8 and P-3C patrol aircraft are scheduled to fly in a maritime exercise for the first time in a Quad context” in 2027. The statement added that the four countries would work together to keep maritime transit routes across the Indo-Pacific open, safe and resilient.Beyond these announcements, however, the 2026 document did not contain the extensive discussion of geopolitical conflicts and regional security concerns found in the 2024 Wilmington Declaration.Even on counterterrorism, the 2026 release retained a brief condemnation of terrorism and violent extremism, “including cross-border terrorism”, and a commitment to strengthening existing cooperation. The 2024 declaration had gone further, specifically reiterating condemnation of the 26/11 Mumbai and Pathankot attacks and referring to efforts to pursue designations through the UN Security Council’s 1267 Sanctions Committee.The Biden-era language of democracy fadesThe political language that had characterised the Quad under US President Joe Biden was also absent from the 2026 joint press release. It made no mention of “shared values”, the rule of law or the four countries’ identity as democracies as a defining basis of their partnership.In 2024, Biden had opened the leaders’ meeting by describing the four countries as “democracies who know how to get things done”. He had recalled that he reached out to the other three countries in the first days of his presidency to elevate the Quad, and said that they were “more strategically aligned than ever before”.Trump, by contrast, made no comparable reference to democracy or a shared democratic identity in his opening remarks in Manila. His comments centred on the personal relationships between the leaders, regional security, economic security and what he called “peace through strength”.He did refer to countries that “share our values and our common interests”, but specifically in the context of ensuring that they would shape the future of artificial intelligence.Even Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s opening remarks reflected the change in tone.At the 2024 summit in Wilmington, the Indian prime minister had said that it was important for the Quad to move forward on the basis of “shared democratic values”. He had added that the four countries were “not against anybody” and supported “a rules-based international order, respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, and peaceful resolution of all disputes”.In Manila, Modi described the Quad instead as “a constructive and trusted partnership”. While he referred to maritime security, trusted supply chains, new technologies and disaster response, he did not invoke democracy or the rules-based international order. His remarks focused on the partnership’s ability to provide “trusted solutions for the entire Indo-Pacific” and on setting “concrete goals” for its next phase.Private capital, critical minerals and strategic supply chainsThe grouping’s economic priorities had also evolved. In 2024, the leaders had placed considerable weight on practical cooperation intended to support development across the region, with initiatives like Quad Fellowship to students from Southeast Asia.Now, the economic programme was framed instead around strategic supply chains, critical minerals, technology and economic resilience. Several elements of the 2024 health and humanitarian cooperation were also missing. The extensive agenda that had included the Cancer Moonshot, health security, climate action, clean energy and education scholarships did not feature in the 2026 press release.Trump demonstrated this emphasis squarely in his opening remarks, referring to new deals on critical minerals and rare earths intended to ensure that none of the four countries was “vulnerable to coercion by any single foreign supplier”.He also announced the first Quad Business Leaders Forum, scheduled for 2027, to bring private-sector participation into the grouping’s economic cooperation. Modi announced in the Quad meeting that India was very interested in hosting this summit in the first quarter of 2027.AI technology cooperation, with an eye on ChinaArtificial intelligence, meanwhile, had moved much closer to the centre of the Quad’s world. Using his self-coined term, Trump described ‘Super Intelligence’ as “the greatest opportunity for economic growth since the Industrial Revolution”, and reiterated that the four countries would expand access to trusted technology ecosystems across the Indo-Pacific, with more than $85 million in funding.The joint press release referred to the Quad AI Accelerator, which is intended to coordinate funding, access and technical assistance for trusted AI systems in the region. Trump’s remarks made clear that this was not simply development assistance for Indo-Pacific countries, but also part of the strategic competition with China over AI leadership.The Quad leaders also acknowledged the “rapid increase in the number and scale of cyber incidents in the region” and announced enhanced ‘Quad Cybersecurity Cooperation’, with the aim of working towards “an open and secure cyberspace”.Foreign secretary Vikram Misri, in a video statement released by the Ministry of External Affairs after the summit, said the four countries had placed particular importance on cyber cooperation. “This is also intended to be enhanced in order to address the scale at which cyber incidents are now taking place,” he said. “This is an effort towards building a safe, secure and trusted cyberspace.”The announcement comes amid a spate of cyber incidents in Asia, the US and Europe. In February, Singapore disclosed that all four of its major telecommunications operators had been targeted in a cyber espionage campaign, with hackers gaining unauthorised access to parts of their networks. Meanwhile, cyberattacks targeted water utilities in multiple US states, while European retailers have faced attacks on supermarket refrigeration systems, disrupting operations and forcing some to discard food.