It’s a marker of the high anticipation – which surrounds the possibility of an India-Pakistan bilateral exchange – that even the routine participation of Pakistan’s minister in a Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) forum in Delhi has prompted a speculative frenzy and hopes of an incremental thaw or a further freeze.This is the first high-level visit since 2023 and following Operation Sindoor. Pakistan’s choice of Musadik Malik, the climate change and environmental coordination minister, for the SCO’s Civilisational Dialogue Forum is not encouraging. A technocrat-turned-politician, he’s known for his bellicose rhetoric on the Indus Waters Treaty dispute. The minister threatened to ‘cut off the hands’ of those trying to control the Indus waters.Illustration: Pariplab Chakraborty.Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in initiating the idea of a Civilisational Dialogue, had sought to complement ‘hard’ power geo-political conversations by focusing on the ‘soft’ power of cultural ties to strengthen people-to-people relations among the ten member states of this Eurasian trans-regional forum.But in recent months, Pakistan’s leaders on World Heritage Day and World Tourism Day have instrumentalised the cultural heritage of the Indus valley civilisation of Mohenjodaro and Harappa to validate claims on the Indus. Meanwhile, India’s culture minister, Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, in inviting Pakistan emphasised the two countries shared a civilisational and cultural past.Also, will the Forum turn sour like the aftertaste of the Goa SCO summit 2023 and witness the India-Pakistan performance of verbal sparring aimed at domestic audiences in the midst of bored internationals? Pakistan foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto had been in Goa to attend the SCO FM summit, but the spat between the foreign ministers distracted from the agenda of regional security. Bhutto at a press conference criticised India’s 2019 revocation of Kashmir’s special status and accused New Delhi of politicising terrorism.Expectedly, Indian foreign minister S. Jaishankar rejected any calls for reversal of the 2019 changes in Jammu and Kashmir, and accused Bhutto of being a ‘promoter, justifier and a spokesperson of a terrorism industry”. He reiterated the formula – talks and terrorism cannot go hand-in-hand.Against the dogmatists, forecasting the inevitability of another toxic exchange between the two neighbours, there is the emerging groundswell of myriad constituencies on both sides of the border incrementally pushing for flexibility in the framing of the Pakistan-India narrative.Why is a flexible narrative important?First, there are the professionals, who argue that the realpolitik logic of a changing era of geo-political shifts towards diverse coalitions and negotiations with adversaries demands a review of the Pakistan-India zero-sum game. India’s preconditioning of diplomacy is particularly negative, given the poor dividends of this sterile policy, as evidenced in the recent terror attacks in Kulgam and Kishtwar.With reason it is not only the optimists who see merit in the former chief minister of J&K’s recent comment urging resumption of dialogue with Islamabad. “Ab aap intezaar karenge, jab tak aap sabki goliyan band ho jayengi, tab tak raat ho jayegi” [If you keep waiting for everyone to stop firing, it will be too late].Then, there is the impact of the stifling fallout of the Pakistan-India conflict which holds hostage the potential for South Asia regional cooperation (SAARC), and even undermines India’s ‘Neighbourhood First’ policy as evident in the deterioration in our domestically driven bilateral relationships. Further, it produces the South Asia region’s further pivot towards China, positioning India as the region’s outlier, and complicates further the country’s priority relationship with its northern neighbour China.Also, the India-Pakistan impasse stymies trans-regional transit of energy pipelines – the Iran-Pakistan-India pipeline and the Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India pipeline – and compromises India’s huge investment in the development of the Chabahar port in Iran.Second, are the overlapping constituencies of environmentalists, climate change and water resource experts and struggle groups. The Himalayas are our common northern roof and the glacial flood disasters in Nepal/Tibet and Bhutan are a warning of shared risk, and a responsibility and opportunity for India to take the lead and bring together the Himalayan nations to study and monitor the situation, build early warning mechanisms, and collaborate on joint rescue and rehabilitation efforts.Beyond the rationale that climate change recognises no boundaries, there is the specific challenge of the region’s transboundary rivers. India’s unilateral suspension of the landmark Indus Waters Treaty of 1960 is imbricated in the escalating Pakistan-India hostility post the Pahalgam terror attack in 2025. But its fallout reaches the troubled India-Nepal transborder Mahakali Treaty, the unresolved India-Bangladesh Teesta River treaty and the still bilaterally or trilaterally unaddressed Medog hydropower project on the Yarlung Tsangpo River in China (downstream Brahmaputra in India and Jamuna in Bangladesh).India’s controversial counter to build the Siang Upper Multipurpose Project below is opposed by independent experts and indigenous struggle groups in Arunachal Pradesh. The intelligent option of a China-India water management discussion is weakened by unilateral action on a transboundary Indus Waters Treaty.Third, is the business and revenue constituency. Direct trade between India and Pakistan may be suspended since the Pahalgam terror attack, but the latest figures record a surge in Indian goods to Pakistan and indicate continuing demand.Data compiled by the State Bank of Pakistan records import of Indian goods worth Rs 5,876 crore ($61.74 mn) in the first quarter of the 2026-27 fiscal year (which in Pakistan runs from July to June), up 69% from Rs 3,478 crore ($36.55 million) in the same period last year. Pharmaceutical products dominate Pakistan’s key imports from India. India imported no goods from Pakistan.Evidently, Indian goods are reaching Pakistan via third countries UAE and Singapore, entailing a loss of customs revenue to the Indian exchequer. The Global Trade Research Initiative has estimated that Indian goods worth $10 billion reach Pakistan annually via such routes.According to Noor Md Kasuri, chair of the Pak India Business Council, Pakistan suffered an estimated $40 billion in economic losses following the suspension of trade with India. Trade ties between India and Pakistan have been in free fall since 2019, when India revoked Pakistan’s most-favoured nation status following the Pulwama attack in 2019. The trade freeze has affected businesses and increased sourcing costs, especially of cotton, sugar, fertiliser, cement and petroleum products.A 2025 Gallup Pakistan-Gilani survey estimated that 44% of Pakistanis favour boosting trade with India, while 28% were against it.Fourth, is the dense network of exchanges – accidental, incidental and intentional, not least being in the field of sport. India bans bilateral sports ties with Pakistan but clears multi-nation events as it pushes to host major global competitions. But the appetite for an India-Pakistan play is intense especially in cricket.India’s recent U-19 win over Pakistan in Oman made it to the front page. In Pakistan a defeat is a defeat but there is no hyper-nationalist TV bashing. As visitors to Pakistan (including this author in 2022) have found, many Pakistanis are as likely to extol Virat Kohli’s batting skills and applaud a well-played India win, as they are to rue their own team’s defeat.Indian players under BCCI directive after the Pahalgam terror attack are yet to let go, transferring onto the playing field a show of hyper-nationalism as manifest in the aggressive refusal of the traditional handshake since the Asia Cup Dubai 2025 to the U-19 Asia cup in Oman in November 2026. The policy and the resulting snubs triggered sharp reactions from cricket veterans and commentators.Also, there are the myriad exchanges involving familial, cultural, scientific, educational, environmental, medical and youth interactions, and especially those of struggle groups of fisherfolk, prisoners, climate activists and farmers.Recently, quietly and unobtrusively, the Mumbai sub-regional council of the Indian Association of Physics Teachers hosted an online lecture delivered by eminent Pakistani physicist Pervez Hoodbhoy to mark the birth centenary of Nobel laureate Abdus Salam. Describing him as an ambassador of goodwill between the two countries in the lecture on “The Truth About Abdus Salam: Science, Faith and the Atom Bomb”, Hoodbhoy wryly remarked on Pakistan’s neglect of the iconic Abdus Salam, because he was an Ahmadiya.Finally, there is the multi-faceted people-to-people peace constituency on both sides of the border which holds aloft the realisable vision of normalisation of relations between India and Pakistan. Its flag bearer is the three decades old Pakistan India Peoples Forum for Peace and Democracy (PIPFPD). The enthusiastic energy generated during the inter-generational PIPFPD’s April 2026 National Convention on Isaq Siyasat Awam (this politics is public) was a testament to the depth, resilience and determination of the people’s commitment to reject the logic of war, the politics of hatred and silencing.The irony is that both our governments iterate their commitment to fostering people-to-people contacts at such forums as the SCO Civilisational Dialogue but raise even higher hostile visa regimes to keep the two peoples divided.Rita Manchanda is co-chair of PIPFPD, a scholar and activist.This piece was first published on The India Cable – a premium newsletter from The Wire – and has been updated and republished here. To subscribe to The India Cable, click here.