The role of independent directors has come under sharp focus in the escalating leadership and listing controversy at Tata Sons. Harish Manwani and Anita Marangoly George, the two independent directors on the board of the unlisted holding company of Tata group of companies, have found themselves at the centre of a dispute that could eventually be tested in courts, potentially all the way to the Supreme Court. Their decisions have consequences that extend beyond the tenure of one chairman and Tata Sons. They raise fundamental questions about the independence of the board, the rights of shareholders and the standards of corporate governance expected of one of India’s most respected business groups and the rest of India Inc.Both directors have good professional backgrounds so far. Manwani spent nearly four decades with Unilever, eventually becoming its global chief operating officer, and subsequently built an extensive career in corporate boardrooms. Anita George has also had a long career in international finance and infrastructure. She was a senior director at the World Bank Group and subsequently joined Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec (CDPQ), the Canadian institutional investor, as managing director for South Asia in 2016.George also has a previous association with the TVS Group. She joined the board of TVS Logistics Services Limited, now known as TVS Supply Chain Solutions Limited, as a director on January 11, 2017. Her directorship came in the context of CDPQ’s investment of more than Rs 1,000 crore in TVS Logistics in 2016, when the Canadian pension fund acquired a substantial minority stake in the company. She quit the TVS board in September 2021 and subsequently joined the Tata Sons board in 2022 as an “independent director”.With Noel Tata, Chairman of Tata Trusts, the majority shareholder of Tata Sons, not agreeing to an extended tenure for N Chandrasekaran, the present chairman of Tata Sons, the role of independent directors has come under scrutiny at a critical moment in Tata group’s history.At the September 17 board meeting this year, both supported the reappointment of N. Chandrasekaran for another five-year term as executive chairman. The decision was contentious because Chandrasekaran had informed the board on August 12 that he would not seek another term when his existing tenure ended on February 20, 2027. Tata Trusts had accepted his decision and called for the process of selecting a successor to begin.Yet, barely a month later, the board revisited the matter and approved his continuation. The Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC), chaired by Manwani and with Venu Srinivasan and Anita George as a member, had met on September 3rd and unanimously recommended that Chandrasekaran reconsider his decision and seek another term. The board subsequently approved the reappointment by a majority vote but Noel Tata vetoed a third term for Chandrasekaran – leading to an intense corporate battle. The fact that Noel was under the impression that the board had not reached a decision on listing and Chandrasekaran’s reappointment and would come to know about the board decision only later with a press statement was a big surprise and shows the lack of transparency at the meeting.What is legally interesting is that Manwani used his casting vote when Noel and Venu Srinivasan – both representing the trusts – voted differently with Srinivasan voting in favour of Chandra’s third term and Noel Tata voting against. The trusts have veto powers over all Tata Sons decisions as per Tata Sons articles of association. But with two directors on Tata Sons board voting differently, there was a stalemate, and Manwani voted for the resolution instead of waiting for a legal clarity as sought by Noel.Retirement normsThe decision raised questions about the Tata Group’s established retirement norms for executive leadership. The group has traditionally followed a retirement age of 65 for executive directors. Chandrasekaran, who will turn 65 in June 2028, would cross that threshold during the proposed extension. The issue, therefore, is not simply whether the board has the authority to reappoint its chairman, but also if an exception to an established policy is justified and whether the board has adequately considered its implications.The comparison with Ratan Tata is particularly relevant. When he turned 65 on December 28, 2002, he gave up all his executive positions across the Tata Group and moved to a non-executive role as chairman of Tata Sons. So, why should a different standard be considered for Chandrasekaran, and what justification have the independent directors offered for supporting such an exception?There is another important question concerning succession planning. Once Chandrasekaran communicated his decision on August 12, why did the NRC not initiate a structured process to identify a successor? Instead, its September 3 meeting was devoted to persuading the incumbent chairman to reconsider his decision. Was this the most appropriate course of action for a committee entrusted with overseeing leadership succession? Manwani, as NRC chairman, should explain why the board did not proceed with a parallel succession exercise, particularly when the existing chairman’s tenure was due to end in February 2027.Section 178 of the Companies Act, 2013, sets out the responsibilities of the NRC in companies to which the provision applies. These include identifying persons qualified to become directors and recommending their appointment, as well as recommending criteria for determining qualifications, positive attributes and independence. Section 166 requires directors to act in good faith, exercise due and reasonable care, skill and diligence, and exercise independent judgement. Schedule IV of the Act also emphasises that independent directors must bring objective judgement to board deliberations and safeguard the interests of the company and its stakeholders.These provisions underline an important distinction: an independent director is not expected to be independent merely in designation. Independence must be demonstrated through the quality of decisions, the willingness to question management and the ability to exercise objective judgement when competing interests are at stake.SecrecyThe question of boardroom transparency has added another dimension to the controversy. Tata Trusts sought access to the audio-video recording of the September 17 meeting, but Tata Sons declined the request. In its November 9 response, the company reportedly argued that neither the law nor its Articles of Association required it to retain or share recordings of in-person board meetings. Here, the larger issue is one of governance and transparency. When the validity of a crucial board resolution is being challenged, access to an accurate account of the deliberations would help establish what was discussed, what objections were raised and how the decision was reached. The fact that Tata Trusts owns approximately 66 percent of Tata Sons makes the demand particularly significant.A board cannot invoke confidentiality as a blanket answer to every question about its decision-making. There must be a distinction between protecting sensitive commercial information and ensuring that directors have access to the information necessary to discharge their responsibilities. At the very least, the board should be able to demonstrate that its minutes accurately reflect the proceedings and that dissenting views have been properly recorded.The September 17 resolution itself is under challenge. Tata Trusts maintains that the Articles of Association require the affirmative votes of its nominee directors for the appointment or reappointment of the Tata Sons chairman. Since Noel Tata voted against Chandrasekaran’s reappointment, the Trusts contend that the resolution is legally invalid. Tata Sons has defended the board’s decision, arguing that the relevant selection committee provisions do not apply to the reappointment of an incumbent chairman. This is a substantive legal dispute that will require careful examination of the Articles of Association.The next major test for the independent directors will come at the November 26 board meeting, when Tata Trusts’ proposed restructuring of Tata Sons is expected to be considered. The Trusts have proposed merging Tata Electronics and Tata Consulting Engineers with Tata Sons. Their argument is that the resulting company would have substantial operating activities and revenues, potentially changing its regulatory classification and removing the basis for its treatment as an upper-layer non-banking financial company.The proposal has significant implications. Tata Sons has been classified by the Reserve Bank of India as an upper-layer NBFC and is subject to enhanced regulatory requirements, including the applicable listing framework. During late Ratan Tata tenure, the Tata Sons board worked over time to avoid a listing prepaying all the standalone debt of Tata Sons. The tune of key trustees Srinivasan and Vijay Singh changed once Noel Tata took over as Chair of Tata trusts after Ratan Tata’s death. After sitting on Tata Sons’ application for over two years, the RBI rejected Tata Sons’ application to surrender its certificate of registration in September this year.The independent directors will have to examine the Trusts’ proposal on its commercial, financial, legal and regulatory merits. They must not approach it simply as a contest between the Tata family and Chandra/Venu/Vijay Singh faction. Their responsibility is to the company and its long-term interests, and that requires an objective assessment of every proposal. If they think Chandra deserves another innings then they must explain why.The Tata Sons controversy is no longer just about whether Chandrasekaran should continue as chairman or whether the company should remain privately held. It is increasingly about the institutional checks and balances within the Tata Group and in Corporate India. The credibility of its board, the authority of its Articles of Association and the relationship between the holding company and its controlling shareholder are all at stake.For Manwani and George, the stakes are particularly high. Their professional reputations have been built over decades. They must now demonstrate that their decisions at Tata Sons were guided by independent judgement, due diligence and the interests of the institution, rather than by the preferences of any individual or faction or past affiliations.Whatever the outcome of the November 26 meeting, the larger questions will not disappear. If the reappointment resolution is challenged in court, the circumstances in which it was approved will come under scrutiny. If the restructuring proposal is rejected, the board will have to explain its reasoning. If it is accepted, the directors will have to stand behind the decision and its consequences.Independent directors are appointed to strengthen corporate governance, not to provide legitimacy to decisions that are convenient to a particular faction.In the Tata Sons battle, Manwani and George have moved from the relative anonymity of the boardroom into the public spotlight. Their most important test is no longer their corporate experience or professional credentials. It is whether they can demonstrate that they have lived up to the responsibilities that come with being independent directors at a crucial time of India Inc history.It’s not only theirs, the reputation of the entire India Inc is on the line.Dev Chatterjee is a senior journalist and co-author of The Meltdown and India Inc’s Greatest Turnarounds.