New Delhi: The Reserve Bank of India’s latest communication to Tata Sons has sparked a debate over the banking regulator’s powers to enforce listing requirements on Upper Layer non-banking financial companies (NBFCs). Legal experts are questioning whether its position amounts to regulatory overreach, reports the Hindu Business Line.In a letter responding to Tata Sons’ October 6 query on regulatory compliance, the RBI asked the company to adhere to all applicable regulations governing Upper Layer NBFCs, “including the requirement of listing”. However, the regulator inferred from Tata Sons’ internal board discussions that the query concerned listing. This was not a question specifically asked by the company.ANB Legal partner Nazneen Ichhaporia told the publication that RBI’s decisions must rely on regulations and not just private board proceedings of an unlisted concern. Senior lawyer H.P. Ranina argued that while the RBI can issue directions to NBFCs under the RBI Act, it has no explicit authority to compel a company to list its shares.Others, however, believe the RBI is within its remit. InGovern’s Shriram Subramanian said Tata Sons, having been classified as an Upper Layer NBFC, must comply with the associated listing requirements. Corporate advisor Srinath Sridharan added that the company had not proposed a formal alternative to address the regulatory requirement.Also read: In Tata Sons Battle, Independent Directors Must Answer for Their DecisionsWhile Tata Trusts chairman Noel Tata has favoured retaining its private status, other family members have supported a potential listing.Nitin Potdar, a senior corporate lawyer, had earlier argued in a piece for The Wire that the RBI has no legitimate legal or regulatory basis to force Tata Sons to list its shares on the stock market. In doing so, it was allegedly exceeding its authority and interfering with the company’s ownership structure.Also writing for The Wire, former director and professor at Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad, Samir Kumar Barua, argued that Tata Sons should be allowed to restructure its business to fall outside the RBI’s NBFC classification, rather than being forced to list.He also wrote that the RBI should accommodate the Tata Trusts’ philanthropic ownership model, provided the restructuring is genuine, transparent and legally compliant.The conflict between the Tata Group and Tata Trusts is primarily over the listing Tata Sons, and spilled into the public domain earlier this year. In October, Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh, two senior trustees of Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT), the biggest shareholder in Tata Sons, said they were not consulted before a Tata Sons merger proposal was discussed.Tata Trusts’ plan for strategic reorganisation of Tata Sons is reportedly geared to avoid losing the latter’s private status, so that it neither becomes a Non-Banking Financial Company nor a Core Investment Company, thereby avoiding having to list as per RBI norms.