In Sonia Maino’s first recorded interview weeks before her wedding, she insistently repeated: “I do not like publicity.” This was no exaggeration – over the next 60-odd years, Sonia Gandhi has been deeply reticent about her personal and public life. Her memoir, thus, has been easily the most awaited book of the year in India and abroad. As she says, this is her personal story – and so it is, written with warmth, candour, grace and humour. Those wishing for explosive political revelations, however, are likely to be disappointed – she is after all an active politician, and perhaps still the most significant leader of her party.Sonia’s life before the Gandhis has been the subject of great, often prurient, speculation. Her childhood and early years, however, are one that many middle-class Indians can easily relate to. A large, happy family: “nonnas and nonnos (grandparents), zios and zias (uncles and aunts), and cuigini (cousins)”, of which Sonia’s parents – a stern, military father, a Singer-sewing machine wielding mother and their three children – form a sub-unit. Having moved, in post-war Italy, from a village to an alien town in search of work, the Mainos adjusted to urban life, an experience many of her readers in India would be familiar with. Growing up in Italy, the young Sonia avidly read de Amicis’ Cuore, which aimed to “create a national character for a newly unified Italy…based on mutual understanding and regard.” Many of these lessons would stand her in good stead in her subsequent political life in India.In fact, her account of her love for Rajiv Gandhi (a bolt of lightning, as she describes it, in French and Italian) makes one wonder if she watched the 1990s superhit Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jaayenge. In many ways, it resembles her own life – a father’s obdurate opposition that melted at the last minute, a mother’s trepidation at what the future would hold, and the eventual (at least at first) happy ending. If Cambridge’s horrible food and grey skies had been unfamiliar, the Delhi she landed in was bewilderingly alien. The rudimentary airport (which would, many makeovers later, be named after her mother-in-law), jackals howling on the Ridge, the “blotchy terrazzo” flooring in dingy government bungalows, the spicy food, and most of all the fixed, unbroken stare of people, so unnerving even now to those unused to it. At Rajiv’s house, she is confronted by a phalanx of formidable women – Indira Gandhi, Amie Crishna and Usha Bhagat – each accustomed to running the house in their own ways. An attack of nerves followed; one of the most moving bits is about her waking up in a cold sweat the night before her wedding, feeling like she was losing her identity and name.For all this, the young, shy Sonia was determined to get married and settle in India. Accordingly, she manfully started to learn Hindi in the weeks before her wedding. Having faced her father about her decision to marry Rajiv, she also held her own with her imperious mother-in-law. The memoir is at its best when describing life at 1 Safdarjung Road, Indira’s official residence – who knew that the prime minister’s Magh cook often served “silicon cren”, a desi substitute for chili con carne? Mrs. Gandhi, warm, kindly, but accustomed to having her own way, bustled in and out of Sonia’s rooms to her initial discomfiture. Despite her warmth, Indira had a temper, sometimes exploding in rage and sweeping her thali across the table; other times freezing people with her silences, described by Nayantara Sahgal as “having the warmth of an Egyptian mummy’s embrace.”To manage – and gauge – “mummy’s” moods, Sonia would often use her children, both of which Indira doted on. Who knew, for instance, that she’d joke about how baby Rahul resembled Kamalapati Tripathi! Also read: Sonia Gandhi’s ‘Belonging’ Launched: Where Personal, Political and ‘Non-Political’ Fell Into Place Like a JigsawFor all of Rajiv’s sensitivity and compassion, he too possessed the family temper. On their wedding day, when he discovered that media photographers were present, he stormed in “tearing his achkan open, sending buttons flying”; it took all his mother’s tact to calm him down. These rages would continue through his life with longer-lasting consequences, notably one when he upbraided the hapless T. Anjaiah in Hyderabad in 1982, and in his summary all-but-dismissal of foreign secretary A.P. Venkateswaran in 1987. In the latter case, Sonia herself mentions Rajiv’s regret at his impetuosity. Sonia Gandhi’s book, after all, is about belonging, not only to India, but also to the Gandhi family. She first confronted the weight of this legacy in 1970, when she visited Allahabad when Indira Gandhi donated Anand Bhavan to the Jawaharlal Nehru Memorial Fund. On that trip, Rajiv, Sanjay and she immerse a portion of Jawaharlal, Motilal and Kamala’s ashes, kept in the house, into the Sangam. Again, this family is very much Indira Gandhi’s family – not Jawaharlal’s; while Kamala Kaul and Feroze Gandhi’s siblings and their children are mentioned affectionately, the only members of the wider Nehru family to find any but a passing mention are B.K. and Fori Nehru – nice guys who did not, in this memoir at least, come second. Even Maneka Gandhi – at least initially – is described as “high-spirited and vivacious”, though tensions emerged during the Emergency, and increased after the family moves to the 12, Willingdon Crescent (“baarah number”) address after Indira Gandhi’s drubbing in the 1977 elections. After Sanjay’s death, Sonia’s account of the split between Indira Gandhi and her chhoti bahu is closer to what Maneka herself suggested in the press at the time than her later version, assiduously circulated in talk shows from the early 2000s, portraying a Machiavellian Sonia manipulating Indira Gandhi to force the young widow out of her marital home. However, as Buckingham Palace said in the context of another high-profile exit, “recollections may vary” in these situations. In spite of all the furour and performative “book burnings” that have accompanied the book, there are few insights about Indian politics before Sonia herself enters politics. One useful nugget of information is how Sonia learnt how to use silence to freeze out errant party members from Indira Gandhi. Mrs. Gandhi also punished staff and colleagues alike, making them stand facing the wall like errant schoolchildren; this perhaps tells us as much about the quality of Congressmen in the 1970s, prone to falling at Indira Gandhi’s feet and being unable to get up, as it does about Gandhi herself. Her description of the Emergency underscores Sanjay Gandhi’s role in decision-making, often supplanting his mother’s authority, and Indira Gandhi is portrayed as a “democrat at heart” who was “overtaken by events.” Indeed, Indira Gandhi’s decision to hold elections was taken after Rajiv, among others, alerted her to the excesses of the Emergency. If contemporary observers criticise her attempts to “foist the blame” onto Sanjay Gandhi, she was only saying what was amply supported both by archival evidence and contemporary hearsay, even by those who have otherwise not been particularly well-disposed to Sonia. Ultimately, however, the responsibility for the Emergency was squarely that of the constitutional head of the government. Sonia’s discomfiture at Rajiv Gandhi joining politics after Sanjay’s death – an earlier book mentions how she “fought like a tigress” to prevent this – is deeply heartfelt. We learn that perhaps Indira Gandhi connived at the pressure being brought on to Rajiv while suggesting she was doing no such thing.Any memoir written by Sonia Gandhi would have had to grapple with the events of 1984, the Bofors scandal, and the corruption scandals of UPA-II. To her credit, Sonia addresses all these issues. How she does so, however, is ambivalent. The visceral shock of her mother-in-law’s assassination is accompanied by an acknowledgment of the 1984 pogrom, occurring at a time of “cataclysmic upheaval…where effective governance had floundered.” Sonia Gandhi’s words convey her horror and sorrow at what happened but stop short of blaming either the Union or Delhi government for the violence.Rajiv Gandhi may well, as she writes, have been personally innocent of complicity in the carnage in northern India, but his government was certainly guilty of omission in taking decisive steps to combat the violence; some of the electoral advertisements asking whether one could trust (Sikh) taxi-drivers in subsequent weeks were grotesquely iniquitous. Similarly, her faith in Rajiv’s motives shines through in the memoir, but she refrains from trying to assess his domestic and international legacy – with its successes and failures. “There had indeed been agents”, she writes about the Bofors scandal, but who they were is never identified. Merely a few months after India’s Supreme Court finally closed the case, a more forthright denial would have helped. The chapter closes with a comparison to Rajiv as the young Abhimanyu; like Abhimanyu, Rajiv would meet his political and personal end caught in a labyrinth their parents had not prepared them to navigate. Also read: Sonia Gandhi’s Autobiography Brings Love Back Into the Public LifeAs a politician, Sonia Gandhi’s commitment to a pluralist India shines through. Arguably, this commitment has been stronger in practice than that of her mother-in-law and husband during their prime ministerial terms. Indeed, the closest she comes to criticising Rajiv’s politics is over the Shah Bano decision, a decision that, in Neerja Chaudhary’s words, “permanently altered the course of Indian politics.” In Sonia’s telling, it is this commitment that compelled her to enter electoral politics in 1998 – possessing, in her words, little more than the armour of the Gandhi name and an understanding of the Bhagavad-Gita. She skims over the internal Congress politics of the next six years – the sidelining of Sitaram Kesri, the formation of the Nationalist Congress Party, and not-quite revolt in 2003. With consummate skill, Sonia Gandhi was able to cobble together the UPA, uniting erstwhile rivals to lead the Congress to a shock victory in 2004, and, what is more, to hold it together – a task that had previously been beyond any other Congress politician. The most fascinating portion is when the personal intersects with the political: the pages that speak of her inner conflict – her responsibility to herself, her children, her party, in the wake of what many of us remember as a shrill outcry about her “foreign origins” – including some high-pitched dramatics by the otherwise dignified Sushma Swaraj. Her decision to hold firm, refrain from becoming prime minister, and instead become, in her narration, the conscience of the government is lightly handled, and suggests a “smooth functioning” which seems more stable in the memoir than it did at the time. Of the many foreign politicians she has met, the ones she feels a particular closeness to are, unsurprisingly, both South Asian women, Chandrika Kumaratunge and Sheikh Hasina, themselves members of dynasties, and no strangers to violent death within their families. The memoir’s last few chapters have a somewhat detached tone, suggesting a gentle, but firm, withdrawal from the hurly-burly of electoral politics. She is graceful about her colleagues and opponents, showing a courtesy that many of them have not extended to her. While exceedingly critical of Narendra Modi’s politics, increasing authoritarianism, and personality cult, she acknowledges his rise from obscurity, even claiming there are “elements of his discomfort” with Lutyen’s Delhi that she agrees with. At the end, however, the memoir turns back to the family, with Sonia speaking both as a politician and as a mother. Her only regret seems to be that she has not succeeded in defending her “idea of India” politically in the short term; she does not explain how this is attributable, not only to the BJP’s unprecedented control over material resources and institutions since 2014, but also to decisions taken by the party she has such pride in belonging to. Manav Kapur is an assistant professor of History at the University of Texas at Austin.