Chhattisgarh has become a testing ground for a new experiment in agriculture. To curb the alleged “black marketing of paddy”, the state government has announced a new paddy procurement policy. Under the Krishi Unnati Yojana (Farmers’ Progress Scheme), paddy farmers will receive an additional bonus for their crops picked up by the state government, but now this amount will be based on acreage and not on production.Every farmer could receive up to Rs 13,839 per acre from the state government under the new system, regardless of how much paddy they actually bring to the procurement system.The decision to hand bonuses based on acerage has consequences for both farmers and food security, and questions remain unanswered on its exact impact on the black marketing of the staple foodgrain. Chhattisgarh has of late struggled with a virtual boom in paddy smuggling and a “paddy mafia” – people bringing the grain into the state to take advantage of the additional bonus and the new policy.This policy swerve began in 2023, when the state government announced a bonus over and above the Union government’s Minimum Support Price (MSP) for paddy. Since 2023, farmers have been getting Rs 3,100 per quintal for paddy. The state government also hiked the per-acre procurement limit for paddy from 15 to 21 quintals. It also assured farmers that the payment of their paddy dues would be credited within three days.At present, the MSP for paddy is Rs 2,441 per quintal, and the Chhattisgarh government has offered Rs 659 bonus per quintal. The government, therefore, has maintained the Rs 3,100 per quintal procurement price for farmers for over three years.YearUnion government (MSP)State government shareTotal per quintal2023-242,1839173,1002024-252,3008003,1002025-262,3697313,1002026-272,4416593,100(Author’s calculations based on official data.)There has, alongside these changes, been another adjustment in the procurement system itself. Before 2023, farmers had to register with the government through cooperative societies or local nodal departments. Once they harvested the crops, they would cart it to procurement centres.Paddy that met the government’s requirements was purchased and the state transferred the money to the farmer’s bank account. This included the state bonus, if any, but this depended on how much paddy a farmer was selling to the state procurement system.Note that the government procurement system exists so that states can supply food grains and staples to the disadvantaged via the Public Distribution System (PDS).The new policy in Chhattisgarh changes an essential feature of this system. Now, a registered paddy farmer, whether he sells 1 quintal or 10 quintals of paddy, will still be paid the entire state government bonus amount for all 21 quintals per acre. In other words, even a farmer selling just 1 quintal to the state government will still receive Rs 13,839 from it.Also read: Chhattisgarh Polls: Farmers’ Votes at Centre of Politics on Paddy Prices, Loan Waivers, DevelopmentThe policy also appears to clash with some other changes in the procurement system. For instance, farmers are now issued digital tokens for their produce before they bring it to procurement centres. This is supposed to be a protective measure for farmers and their families, ensuring the system works seamlessly.Further, religious societies, trusts and other bodies are barred from supplying into Chhattisgarh paddy procurement system. The government has also promoted digital crop surveys and digital crop verification, removing the need for physical verification of standing crops or at the procurement centres. But the question remains: how effective are these systems if the illegal smuggling of rice is going on?Building a paddy mafia?Average paddy production in Chhattisgarh is about 10.7 quintals per acre, as per the government’s Agricultural Statistics at a Glance, 2024–25. Other available government data from 2017-2023 shows a far lower average paddy production figure in the state. In the given years, the state average is 1.97 tonnes per hectare (around 7.97 quintals per acre).Districts like Surguja, Bastar, Balrampur, Raigarh, Dantewada and some others report much lower production than the state average, chiefly because they are mainly rain-fed regions and use traditional seed varieties.Reportedly, 67% of Chhattisgarh’s farmlands are rain-fed and use heirloom varieties, which are nutritionally dense but have yields below commercial paddy varieties. Now, regardless of how much all these farmers bring to procurement yards, they will all be entitled to the bonus meant for 21 quintals per acre (Rs 13,839 per acre).Rice: Area, production and yield during 2023-24 and 2024-25 in major producing states along with irrigation coverageSource: Agricultural Statistics at a Glance, 2024-25, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers WelfareSince the changes made in 2023, many farmers no longer produce all this grain from their own farms. Instead, farmers (as also traders) in other paddy-growing states such as Jharkhand, Odisha, Telangana, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, which offer states lower bonuses and more average production, have been caught sending their produce to take advantage of the policy.Also read: As Paddy Procurement by Odisha Govt Fails Farmers, It’s Time to Think of SolutionsFarmers in many of these other states are only entitled to recieve MSP for paddy and much less lucrative bonuses. Besides, their payment are also often delayed – sometimes by several months.The Union government has been critical of state bonus schemes. Odisha, Kerala, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal, Jharkhand Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh also offer state bonus over the central MSP.The situation this has created is that black marketers and smugglers bring paddy into Chhattisgarh, sell it to the farmers or use their connections to sell the produce to the procurement agencies directly. This practice is said to run into thousands of crores each season, especially in the border districts of Chhattisgarh.In just two weeks after the paddy harvest in November 2025, PTI reported that state authorities caught 19,000 quintals of paddy being illegally transported into the state. The state government was so alarmed that it reportedly put the state on high alert for paddy smuggling.Raigarh, in the last season, reported illegal paddy seized worth 1 crore during early procurement. Baloda Bazaar reported illegal paddy worth Rs 25 lakh being caught. Raids in Balrampur, Jashpur and two other districts reportedly led to the recovery of over 30,000 quintals in January 2026.Overall, say reports, between November 1 and December 6, 2025, approximately 1.5 lakh (1,51,809) quintals of paddy were caught across Chhattisgarh. Mahasamund topped the chart with 25,718 quintals.Even as the new procurement for 2026-27 has now started, reports are flooding in of paddy being smuggled into Chhattisgarh. Mahasamund has reported about 970 quintals of paddy seized by the authorities. Local newspapers and police circulars in Chhattisgarh report huge caches of paddy on a daily basis.Conservative estimates this reporter spoke to point to hundreds of crores being minted by these smugglers each season. The reason – the per-acre paddy procurement limit and a governance system whose wheels appear ready to be oiled.The mechanicsA social activist from Raigarh, Anil Agrawal ‘Chiku’ says, “Around a third of Chhattisgarh shares a border with Odisha, where the cost of paddy production is much lower. Hence, farmers here commonly believe that some 16–18% of all illegal smuggled paddy comes to Chhattisgarh from there. There are unmonitored jungle paths, and even if there are CCTV cameras, when the trucks come with the rice supplies, they miraculously turn off.”“The BJP government even got a new software to measure the crop and land, but software is failing and misreporting all the time. When the software is failing, how can humans not fail? The whole system, from patwaris to officers, are profiting from this illegal trade,” he said.The Chhattisgarh government’s land survey app – Physical Verification app – experienced a major failure in November 2026, soon after it was introduced. The malfunction was such that farm data merged across location and farm locations themselves popped up in different places around the world. This has added to the burden on Patwaris, who are not trained to handle the app.Patwaris have raised concerns about the reliability of the digital crop-survey records and even launched a strike against the app.To understand the situation along the Jharkhand-Chhattisgarh border, this reporter spoke with a former paddy smuggler anonymously. He said that paddy smugglers buy paddy as cheaply as at Rs 19-20 per kg in Jharkhand, and then truck it, mostly using smaller roads, but also the national highway into Chhattisgarh. “The paddy is then sold to farmers between Rs 22-25 per kg, who then go on to sell it to the government for Rs 31 per kg,” he said.“My own trucks were seized last season, after which I stopped doing this,” he admits. But usually, with a little money, the trucks are released in 3-4 months’ time. Even small-time smugglers can earn up to 1 crore in the season – it’s worth the risk,” he said.Many of these details are also backed by people in the know of things in the state.Also read: Farm Laws: What the Centre Can Learn From Chhattisgarh’s Raman Singh EraFarmers living in other border districts and remote areas, also speaking on condition of anonymity, said that local land revenue officials are easily bribed with Rs 500 to Rs 1,000 to add the “extra” paddy to the local farmers’ crop records. Even if the farmers is growing maize, one said, with a small amount of money, they can get it changed to “paddy” on the official records. Then they buy paddy from traders from across the border, and sell it to the procurement agencies.With the new policy, many of them say, they don’t even have to grow paddy – they can just buy paddy from traders, register it on the crop sowing map, get a digital token and receive the MSP and the hefty bonus amount. Else, they can keep the paddy and sell a little as a kilo to the government, and still claim the Rs 13,000-plus bonus. The procurement season has brought a time of double incomes, but without actually selling the paddy they are paid for.Corruption to food insecurity?This new policy may appear like one of those rare windfalls for farmers, its foundation built on acreage instead of production fails to encourage the farmers to grow more paddy or adopt more productivity-enhancing methods.One might try to argue that farmers work hard enough – it’s all right if they gain this bonus. But the question arises: Why exclude the landless farmer, the farm worker and the share-croppers in that case? After all, those with no land title in their name would gain nothing from the policy.In its intention the new policy is built to combat corruption because the reports about the high frequency of paddy entering the state illegally since 2023 has forced the authorities to be on high alert.The heavy reliance on digitisation has, instead, provided newer ways for corruption to creep into the system. While the procurement on paper will rise, the actual paddy supplied into the PDS could very well diminish. Crop survey and digital tokens often don’t work. The training for digital adaptation for local land revenue officials is also lacking, sparking both protests and the fear that the data being fed into the system is not real.Finally, a state has limited resources and sources of revenue, and Chhattisgarh’s strengths are its forests, rivers and farmlands, which the government must use to promote climate resilient agriculture aligned with the production capacities of local farmers.Neighbouring states should also heed the warnings – if Chhattisgarh does clean up its paddy act, they must raise what MSP and bonuses they give to their farmers. Raising farm incomes is ideal, so long as it is based on production, not on acreage. Instead of allowing corruption to seep into rural societies, governments should bolster the dignity of labour – not just hand out cheques to those who own land.Indra Shekhar Singh is an independent journalist, agri-policy analyst and writer.