Politics

Audio Tapes Raise More Suspicions Over Bhopal Encounter

The growing amount of evidence suggests that the police were under orders to shoot the undertrials and not re-arrest them.

Bhopal: Police investigate the encounter site at the hillocks of Acharpura village after the STF killed 8 Students of Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) activists who escaped Central Jail killing a security guard in Bhopal on Monday. Credit: PTI

Bhopal: Police investigate the encounter site at the hillocks of Acharpura village after the STF killed 8 Students of Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) activists who escaped Central Jail killing a security guard in Bhopal on Monday. Credit: PTI

Two audio tapes said to contain recordings of conversations between the policemen who shot and killed eight SIMI members, who has escaped from a prison in Bhopal, have raised more questions about the police’s claims that the deaths were a result of an encounter. The tapes and the videos of the interaction between the policemen and the escapees, which surfaced the day after they were killed, add to a growing amount of evidence that suggests the police were under orders to shoot the undertrials and not re-arrest them.

Catch News, which first released the audio tapes, reported, “At 7:42 AM, policemen can be heard saying “Sab peeche hat jao…kuch aur farzi operation karana pade to.” (All of you move back…we might need to do some more fake operations.”

In snippets of the audio tapes, a policeman can also be heard saying, “bilkul peeche nahin hathna hai, kaam tamam karna hai (you don’t have to retreat, just finish all of them).”

Men can also be heard saying that firing from the other side has started and that they should take positions, signalling that the escapees may have fired at the police from their position on top of a hill in Eintkhedi village on the outskirts of Bhopal where the police eventually cornered them, the Hindu reported.

It appears the tapes are recordings of the communication between the control room and policemen on the ground who were in pursuit of the SIMI members. On the tapes, some police officers are referred to by “standard codes like Mic1 and Mic2”, the Indian Express reported.

The voices in the tapes seem to congratulate each other and celebrate after all the men have been shot, “Surround them from all sides. They should not escape alive… Congrats aantho mar gaye DSP Crime ne bataya. Very good… beech mein pade hain (Congratulations, all eight have been killed, DSP Crime has said. Very good. The bodies are lying in the middle),” the voices are heard saying, according to the Indian Express. 

The Indian Express report adds another part of the tapes, where policemen can be heard updating each other. A voice says, “Aaye hai sir, 5 ko goli lag gayi jai, chalo shabash, koi dikkat nahin hai, hum log pahunch rahe hain (five have taken bullets, congrats. No problem, we are reaching).” Another person asks for ambulances to be sent to Khejrawadi and comments on the cost of treating the escaped men, “Ilaaj karne me kitna paisa kharcha hoga (How much money will be spent on treatment).”

While the Hindu reported that the tapes have not been verified as yet, in a more recent report the Indian Express quotes Superintendent of Police of the CID Anurag Sharma, who is heading the investigation into the operation as saying, “We will include everything in our investigation,” implying that he does not question the authenticity of the tapes, although he also told the paper that he had not heard the tapes yet.