Outlawing moderate opposition might only push Shi’ite youth into extremism as well as destabilise the Middle East, say opponents.
Dubai: Bahrain aims to end years of instability with a crackdown on Shi’ite political parties, but it could be a gamble that risks further destabilising the Western-allied kingdom and the wider Middle East.
Five years after it crushed street protests with Saudi military support, the Sunni Muslim royal family that rules over a population with a Shi’ite majority appears convinced it will again weather international disapproval for tough measures.
In a series of moves over the past three weeks, authorities closed down the main Shi’ite opposition al-Wefaq Islamic Society, doubled the prison sentence on the group’s leader, Sheikh Ali Salman, detained prominent rights campaigner Nabeel Rajab and stripped Ayatollah Isa Qassim, Bahrain‘s Shi’ite spiritual leader, of his citizenship.
Authorities have managed to muzzle anger each time by deploying extra police officers to the streets, but the move against Qassim this week brought thousands in spontaneous protests outside his home west of the capital Manama.
The US and other Western countries have expressed alarm, but Bahrain appears to be calculating that the distaste will not translate into concrete reprisals against a country closely allied to key US partner Saudi Arabia.
However, opponents say that by limiting peaceful ways to express their views through a recognised group like al-Wefaq, the government will only push Shi’ite youths into the arms of extremists, including some responsible for bomb attacks.
“Dangerously, by outlawing the moderate opposition, the authorities are pushing all opposition into illegality, which strengthens hardliners on all sides,” said Ali Alaswad, a former member of parliament from al-Wefaq, now in exile.
“That clearly leaves the prospect for dialogue and reconciliation completely dead in the water. This will not take the country forward.”
The concern is shared even by some who support the authorities.
“Extremism is currently confined to small arenas, involving mostly young men, many of them living abroad,” said a former Bahraini official who asked not to be identified in a country where open criticism of official policy is often muted.
“When the main group [al-Wefaq] is struck, I believe that even without intending it, you are opening the arena to all kinds of extremism,” he added.
Regional analysts worry that an intensification of sectarian animosity in Bahrain could spill over into the wider region, where allies of Sunni Saudi Arabia and Shi’ite Iran are fighting proxy wars from Syria to Yemen.
Anger and dismay
The US, which maintains its navy’s Middle East headquarters in Bahrain, expressed alarm at the stripping of Qassim’s citizenship. The UN human rights office said it was very concerned by what it called a “clearly unjustified” step.
Bahrain has defended its actions as necessary for national security. The authorities accuse al-Wefaq and Qassim of promoting sectarianism and of links to Iran, which they blame for backing militants who have used improvised bombs to attack security forces, killing 17 officers since 2011, according to the interior ministry.
Iran denies fomenting violence. But the commander of an elite force in Iran’s powerful Revolutionary Guards, Qassem Soleimani, responded to the stripping of the cleric’s citizenship by suggesting Bahrainis may have no choice but to resort to “armed resistance” against the ruling Al Khalifa dynasty.
Some critics say Bahrain may have been encouraged to launch its latest crackdown by a timid response from Washington to the kingdom’s suppression of protests five years ago, when ‘Arab Spring’ demonstrations were sweeping the region.
“This is the most naked show of brutal force since the violent 2011 crackdown,” wrote Brian Dooley of the US group Human Rights First, which lobbies Washington to stress the importance of rights in its foreign policy.
“It leaves the US government’s approach of quiet diplomacy and big rewards for small gestures of reform in tatters.”
After an international inquiry into the government’s handling of the 2011 unrest, Bahrain made some reforms and opened political dialogue with Shi’ite parties.
However, talks with the opposition ended without agreement in 2013, and since then Bahrain has remained gripped by political deadlock. More recently, the smouldering discontent on the streets has been exacerbated by financial strains caused by lower oil prices.
Bahrain‘s close ally Saudi Arabia, which allows no independent political parties of its own, has been sceptical of pro-democracy measures.
Bahrain is connected by a causeway to Saudi Arabia’s oil-rich Eastern Province, home to a large Shi’ite minority, and Riyadh worries that its own Shi’ites could be emboldened by gains by Shi’ites in Bahrain.
Some experts attribute the crackdown to a resurgence in the influence of Bahraini government hardliners who see limiting Shi’ite power as a natural part of Arab opposition to non-Arab Iran, and who have been emboldened since reform talks stalled.
However, others say al-Wefaq shares the blame, after it, along with three smaller opposition groups, boycotted parliamentary elections in November 2014. That made the opposition vulnerable to accusations that it was not interested in dialogue.
Al-Wefaq said it chose not to take part in the vote because the elected parliament would not have enough power and because voting districts favoured the Sunni minority.
“This is all still a fallout from the decision of al-Wefaq not to participate in the most recent parliamentary elections, and they see Ali Salman as someone who is not willing to compromise,” said Justin Gengler, a Qatar-based Bahrain expert.