Communalism

Bengalis Bear the Brunt of Linguistic Polarisation Ahead of Assam Elections

As 72,000 more people in Assam join the ranks of ‘declared foreigners’, the issue of ‘illegal foreigners’ has reared its head once again, leaving the fate of the Bengali community of the Barak Valley  both Hindu and Muslim  uncertain.

Silchar_barak

An aerial view of Silchar and the Barak river. Credit: Wikimedia Commons

Silchar (Assam): Piles of black sewage from open drains composting in reeking heaps: this is the image one leaves with of Silchar, the main city of the Barak Valley in Assam. Why is there such squalor everywhere? As far as one can see, there are open drains everywhere – around homes, hospitals, schools, and people’s gardens.

In some places, these drains are a carpet of neon green, in others, they are covered with concrete, causing fewer people to fall into them – which they otherwise frequently do. There is a pestilence of mosquitoes, spawning underneath footbridges, as big and heavy as house flies, the kind that are easy to swat, and that smear the swatter scarlet. Mosquitoes generally don’t bother me, but these things are monstrous, embittered, and radicalised.

Silchar is at the heart of the monument of neglect that is the majority Bengali region along the Barak river. This protrusion is south of the better-off Brahmaputra Valley in the marginality that is Assam, which is deeply divided on the lines of ethnicity, and more so, language. If Assam is a marginality, the Barak Valley is a calamity; with Bangladesh to its west, it is the hole that the much-maligned ‘foreigners’ from that country escape into.

People here blunder about, earning low wages, wading through squelching garbage, falling sick and into drains, and living like Tiberius condemned to this, their miserable wayside valley (but why use a five-dollar allusion to describe anything in this 99 cent town?).

As for commerce, there are kiosks – rows and columns of them, and where there are pucca shops most are the size of large pigeon coups; the buildings look like monochrome Rubik’s cubes: small, uncomfortable, cookie-cut.

Everywhere, there is a uniform film of grey slough – on the edges of roads, on windowsills, on buses, even on people. Where are the clean spaces here, I wonder. Where do the rich people live? What do they do for fun, I wonder, as I walk past all the garishly dressed pigeon-chested mannequins with matted hair in the market area.

The Bengalis here suffer the strange fate of not quite being part of Assam. They did not have the advantages of their brethren in West Bengal who were richer, better educated and more influential nationally. Bengalis in Assam have had to agitate to retain their language at schools for their communities, and most aggressively, here, in the Barak valley, the seat of Bengali ‘dominance’. This valley demanded a central university of its own with English and Bengali (and not Assamese) as the languages of instruction, and got one only in 1994. It got a few more higher education institutions but there are still too few jobs to go round.

Everywhere in this state, Bengali identities are marred by Assamese nationalist pressures, and some migrants in upper Assam have accepted Assamese as the language of instruction at their community’s schools in order to ingratiate themselves.

But in Silchar, which is lower Assam, the signs are strictly in Bengali, and not Assamese.

Guilty until proven innocent

Recently, 72,000 people in the state were declared foreigners to be seized and expelled from the country,  their names and addresses published in the press by Assam Police. These are individuals whose citizenship status could not be established due to a lack of papers to prove they were citizens of India before 1971 – though the cutoff year has been moved forward and back by several administrations.

These names were produced from the 1.43 lakh names that existed on blacklists as of 2014 – when Narendra Modi visited the region just before the general elections as a prime ministerial candidate. He said he would shut down ‘detention camps’ if he came to power and remove the D label from people’s names so they may cast their votes (for him).

In 2011, the Gauhati high court ordered that once referred to a foreigners’ tribunal, the superintendent of police (border) will have to ensure they do not vanish and are kept in a detention camp with access to the law to defend themselves. They are guilty until proven innocent. There are three such facilities in the state: at Silchar, Kokrajhar and Goalpara. Thanks to this rule, thousands are at risk of arrest.

These ‘detention camps’ are common jails where detainees – often the poorest of the poor – are treated at par with judicial detainees and criminals. The better off on the D list are not to be found at these facilities.

They do exist, though. A local journalist tells me BJP MLA from Silchar, Dilip Paul’s brother Pradip Paul appeared on the list. As did senior BJP leader Kabindra Purkayastha, a former Union minister with the 1998-99 Atal Bihari Vajpayee government.

The way that people have been declared D Voters is itself doubtful, “Suppose the police goes to someone’s house and for some reason they are not there, or if those at home – usually the poorer people – can’t answer properly, the absentee is marked ‘doubtful’,” said local Congress MP Sushmita Dev.

She said that in 2005, Sarbananda Sonwal – now the BJP’s chief ministerial candidate – went to the Supreme Court and had the Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunal) Act, 1983 struck down as being unconstitutional on the basis of two cases: “When that rule existed, if the administration suspected someone of being a foreigner, the burden of proof lay with the administration.”

“With the Foreigners Act now in its place, the burden of proof has reverted to the so-called suspected citizen. If you go to the border area of Cachar, my constituency, you’ll see that Bangladesh is just across the river, you know? So people end up in jail for going and seeing their relatives,” she said.

Indeed, at the Silchar facility a woman with her two children (five and seven years-old) has been jailed for doing exactly that. “The relatives are so scared they haven’t even tried to come see her,” a source at the jail in Silchar tells me.

Even in 2014, Modi’s generosity extended only to Hindu Bengalis, of course, who would be taken in as citizens because of religious persecution across the border. All others whose intentions were ‘nefarious’ would be deported, he had said.

Two years on, during last Sunday’s visit to the Barak valley, Modi, this time as prime minister, landed with his customary three-chopper entourage on a field in Hailakandi – a Muslim majority district – and said absolutely nothing about immigration. In any case, no bill regarding sheltering aggrieved Bangladeshi Hindus has yet been tabled in parliament though the home ministry has issued new rules making it easier for Hindu migrants from Bangladesh to obtain Indian citizenship.

“He is doing a flip flop on the issue,” says Sushmita. “When he goes to Assamese-dominated areas he says I’m not going to allow foreigners. When he comes to this valley, he sings a different song. This time basically he had nothing to say about the Bengalis.”

A Bengali local said: “Modi never said a word about D voters. He knows if he says anything about them, his Assamese vote bank will be totally cashed out.”

The embattled electoral roll

Politics in Assam can sometimes be alarmingly shallow: since the 1980s, it has almost completely been about where parties stood on the ‘foreigner issue’, an obsessive insecurity of losing land to acquisitive Bengali immigrants, with a shade of Islamophobia that finds validation in the belief that Muslims don’t treat their women as well as the Assamese do.

As a political card, it is genius: it unites (or divides) villagers, townsfolk, farmers, industrial workers, government officers, and, of course, politicians. Not surprisingly, much blood has been shed over the matter.

So what makes this issue so central to every election, and to Assamese politics itself?

It started with the death of Hiralal Patowary, the MP from Mangaldoi constituency in 1979. The Election Commission ordered fresh elections and a re-look at the state’s voter lists when electoral officers noticed a disproportionate increase of 70,000 names, suspected as being illegitimate. Of these, 45,000 claims were upheld by tribunals. These numbers shocked the public, and united opposition groups.

The nationalist All Assam Students’ Union (AASU) perceived this as a threat to Assam and the Assamese people, and stepped up to call for state-wide bandhs demanding the deportation of foreign nationals. They won support from all parties, barring the Congress, and some Muslim MLAs who, “opposed the revision of voters’ lists, for this would mean the deletion of…their supporters who had been installed illegally…to establish vote banks,” Sanjoy Hazarika writes in his 1994 book Strangers of the Mist.

The findings of the tribunals created renewed crises for the government, as strikes became full-fledged confrontations and agitators threatened to stall elections unless electoral rolls were revised. It was deemed that no party was fit to form a stable government and president’s rule was proclaimed.

Sham Lal Shakdher, then the election commissioner, was one of the first to express alarm at the rise in the number of voters. However, he capitulated to the Indira Gandhi government at the Centre, which wanted the elections to go ahead as planned. He said that voters would be checked after the elections as the process of establishing citizenship was a time-consuming one.

Tensions remained on the boil: in 1983, a mob of Lalung tribespeople in Nellie massacred 1700 Bengalis, both Hindu and Muslim. This stunned even the student nationalists, who were in some way responsible for creating the atmosphere of violence. Perhaps out of remorse, they negotiated down their obstinacy over the deportations of those who moved to Assam after 1971, i.e. mostly Hindu and Muslim Bengalis who settled in Assam following riots in East Pakistan.

In 1985, the Asom Gana Parishad (AGP) – formed by the leaders of the students’ movement – came to power. Many demands made by the agitators were turned down, none of the immigrants were immediately deported. Ironically, a voters’ list drawn from the fatal 1971 rolls was used for these elections.

Today, a third of Assam is Muslim. According to the 2011 census, nine out of 27 districts are Muslim-majority, compared to six in the 2001 census. Of the three main administrative areas in the Barak valley, Hailakandi and Karimganj are majority Muslim.

A never ending process

Sadhan Purkayastha, who runs the Citizen’s Rights Preservation Committee, said: “There are Assamese chauvinist groups who don’t want non-Assamese people in Assam at all. They want to oust them one way or another, send them to another state or to Bangladesh – wherever, whatever.”

“New cases are created everyday. It’s a never ending process,” he said.

What is it like being a Bengali in Assam, I ask Sushmita. “When the Assam agitation was going on, we didn’t notice anything – nobody dared do anything to us. But for the Bengalis in upper Assam it was difficult. Now in the census if they are asked what language they speak, they say Assamese. The politics that the BJP is doing is not of religion: it is linguistic communalism going on here.”

“If people have been living here for the past 45 years, how can you tell them you are outsiders? The law says you can be a naturalised citizen in 12 years. The AGP says you have to leave Assam even if you get citizenship. What is that supposed to mean? Why should we leave Assam? Even my mother came from Bangladesh during the partition. How many years do we have to keep hearing we are outsiders? How many times do we have to prove that we are Indian?”

The writing is on the wall. It is in Assamese, and Bengali communities have been told: ‘We don’t need you anymore.’

Note: The story has been edited to correctly identify the BJP leader who went to the Supreme Court on the migrants issue as Sarbananda Sonowal and not Himanta Biswa Sarma.

Divya Guha is an independent journalist based in Assam

  • N Motwani

    Good article summarising the situation in Assam and the elections here. Except that the author Guha failed to talk about (1) why Assam Agitation was crucial for sustaining Assamese identity and (2) the fact that Bengalis residing in Assam before the Agitation tried to force their culture on the Assamese people, which led to a backlash from the Assamese.

  • http://passionbeat.com/ Mahasish Shome

    When writing an article it should not be baised and should be from neutral point of view but this article is highly partial. Assamese people try to have a broad mindset so that Assam gets a few industries and generates job for unemployed. TheWire is a reputed website and I didn’t expect such baised articles.

  • Debanjana Dey

    ‘Bengalis bearing the burnt in Assam’ and in the process the Bengali dominated areas remaining underdeveloped for years is a political issue and needs sensitivity to deal with. In this respect the above article is quite disappointing, as it has not been able to represent the issue rather the context, moreover, the author has misrepresented facts. Underdevelopment of Barak Valley, Silchar for example is familiar but the article misleads the reader, by mentioning wide drains, mosquitoes, shops like pigeon coup etc. which actually is not at all the issue concerning people there, rather it trivializes the matter.

  • Barooah

    Well, let me get straight to the point, Miss Guha! 



    “The Bengalis here suffer the strange fate of not quite being part of Assam. They did not have the advantages of their brethren in West Bengal who were richer, better educated and more influential nationally” 



    Well, even though you claim (and is quite evident) Bengalis have lived in Assam for years, still your pseudo Bengali superiority will always reckon brethen in West Bengal, and not in Assam! How hard was it for you to leave a positive remark to constitute Assamese brotherhood? Guess, it was! Because you and others in your community have never tried to establish ties with fellow Asamiyas, instead have a self-inflicting alienating psyche! You walk with your head held high being a proud Bengali however, is it so difficult to embrace another language of a region (where you have long survived)? Everyone respects your language sentiments and aspirations, but the fact remains (although unfortunate) that you’ve never embraced or appreciated anything related to Asamiya social conduct! 



    Your brethen in West Bengal were richer, better educated; but so were Asamiyas! The only difference is, we are even better culturally as we don’t brag ourselves like you intend to do! The so called marginal Assam, as you’ve referred, has to it’s credits – an indian classical dance form (which Bengal doesn’t), a celebrated folk dance, an evolved language system, an evolved writing system, an established literature, an established indigenous textile technology (mekhela), a historical motion picture industry, a way better Panenthestic form of Hinduism (Vaishnavite), but still in harmony with traditional practices and no casteism, and above all a society free from dowry system! This is known as being better educated and culturally evolved! If you analyse, these credits aren’t easy to earn for a small state and community of Assam!

    And richness? Were there no Asamiya tea planters and business houses or is it that you just want to present a maligned picture of Assam? In fact until 1950, Assam’s per capita income was higher than rest of India (flourishing tea industry, if you remember). And as for education, there were many Asamiya littérateurs in pre-independence era, so nothing to do with your perception of Assam! Your longing to be with West Bengal is so strong that you and many others have ‘grass is greener syndrome’! Get a reality check!

    And coming to being influential, well of course we aren’t, because we are gentle in our speech and our conduct! We are progressive in our attitudes and hence don’t believe in shouting our lungs out to seek attention or to do self-bragging! That’s a cultured society in true terms! Have a read through Khuswant Singn’s (a celebrated Punjabi writer) write-up about “This above all/ Who is the friendliest of them all” in India here:

    http://www.tribuneindia.com/20

    http://www.telegraphindia.com/

    Might help you to question how is that you been deprived of that friendliness (in case you perceive)? 



    Honestly, I didn’t want to emphasise anything on the above, but the thing is, sometimes we need to speak up to set records straight! Of course Bengalis are influential! With a highly populated community living worldwide and blessed with self-bragging and superiority complex, who else stands a chance to be influential?

    “an obsessive insecurity of losing land to acquisitive Bengali immigrants” – how is that obsessive? Should we now loose present Assam as well?!

    Isn’t this the only state (in the history Indian demographics) that had been divided 7 times to cater to tribal aspirations!? The so-called northeastern states have been carved out of this Assam, in case if you’ve forgotten! So please don’t try to imply obsession to Asamiyas!

    Haven’t we moved our seat of Government, the Secretariat from Shillong (former capital of Assam to Gauhati)? If we had wanted, couldn’t we have contested for a joint capital (much like Chandigarh)?!!

    But we chose not to! Because we respected tribal aspirations and had the conviction in our minds that we would be able to manage, no matter what! That’s what Assam and Asamiya society stands for – tolerance and being accommodative like no other! Imagine your Bengal (or any other state for that matter) to undergo such series of divisions – none would’ve survived!

    You can never compare Assam with Bengal or any other state!

    So, without establishing any parity, avoid giving any frivolous remark about obsession! – This is also a response to Mr Manish Shome who has commented Asamiyas should be have a broad mindset! Sure thing!

    Sorry, sir! No! We are tired, hence we can’t! If the existing marginal Assam is under threat then people will need to speak up, whether or not the self-alienating Bengalis are in terms with!

    And also, if Barack isn’t a place to be, why haven’t you guys reached out to your brethren in West Bengal? Lots of avenues, rich people, educated – sure they would be able to help and get you sorted! But don’t try to malign this region!

    And regarding education institution in Bengali, how about opening an Asamiya institution in West Bengal? We have a sizeable population in West Bengal, but do you think that would be possible there?

    Darjeeling Hills demand Nepali as their primarily language, haven’t Bengalis imposed Bangla upon them? In Assam you have disregarded our language and have thrown it out of enforcement, but how is that in West Bengal you have kept Bangla as the primary language besides Nepali?!!

    We have always shown endurance, but Bengalis can never follow suit!

    Well, your biased opinion is evident anyway, so nothing much I need to say about it!

    The fact is, Assam is in serious identity crisis, and with people like you (many thanks!), it seems, Assam is in image crisis as well! Citizenship is in question for everyone in Assam alike, so if identity can’t be established people will need to move on. Our marginal state, as you have pointed out, can’t absorb everyone or tolerate everything!

    End of my rant!