Media

After Editor’s Exit, Hindustan Times Pulls Down Controversial ‘Hate Tracker’

The development comes just days after former editor Bobby Ghosh stepped down from the organisation and a month after the organisation slowly distanced itself from the editorial initiative.

New Delhi: The Hindustan Times appears to have taken down its hate tracker initiative, a microsite that aimed at being a “national database on crimes in the name of religion, caste and race”.

Readers and viewers who tried to access the tracker on Wednesday morning were greeted with a 404 error message that indicated that its contents are currently no longer available on newspaper’s website.

Although the official reason behind the hate-tracker’s take-down is unknown at the moment, two journalists within the organisation that The Wire spoke to confirmed that it had been removed for the moment.

A detailed emailed questionnaire has been sent to current editor R. Sukumar and chief content officer Rajesh Mahapatra and the story will be updated if and when they respond.

The hate-tracker, which was intended to be a “crowd-sourced database of hate crimes in India since September 2015” was an editorial initiative driven by former Hindustan Times (HT) editor Bobby Ghosh, who joined the publication in May 2016.


Also Read: Hindustan Times Editor’s Exit Preceded by Meeting Between Modi, Newspaper Owner


As The Wire has reported, Ghosh’s 16-month stint, which formally ended this week, may have rubbed the BJP-led political establishment the wrong way. The months leading up to his exit saw a personal meeting between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and HT proprietor Shobhana Bhartia and sustained objections raised by top-level government officials to editorial decisions taken during Ghosh’s tenure.

Over the last month, HT has slowly started distancing itself from the hate-tracker. On September 13, 2017, two days after Ghosh’s departure was announced, Geetika Rustagi, the organisation’s content engagement editor, sent an email to editorial heads in Bombay and Delhi with the subject head: “Hate tracker tweets and RTs”.

The email, which The Wire reported on, simply stated that “Rajesh” has directed that no hate tracker tweets or hate tracker-related tweets are to be retweeted “until further notice.”

At the time, journalists within the organisation who The Wire spoke to indicated that the tracker could have been among the “last straws” that precipitated Ghosh’s exit.  HT employees confirmed that while work on the hate tracker still “officially continued”, social media teams were informally told that it should be publicised less on platforms such as Facebook and Twitter.

  • Amitabha Basu

    The Hate Tracker did perform its role in highlighting the hate crimes being perpetrated against muslims, dalits and marginalised sections of our people, on the basis of religion, caste, etc. The HT management must have been pressurised by the government to stop it. These hate crimes have become more and more widespread, with the inbuilt bigotry and biases in the police, administration and other authorities encouraging the perpetrating hoodlums to continue their nefarious activities and get away unscathed. Further, the deafening silence of the ‘Pradhan Sewak’ and the vitriolic utterances of his cohorts like the Yogis, Sakshis, Sadhvis and others enables these hate crimes to continue with ‘official sanction’ or at least by feigning ‘official ignorance’. Those who speak of ‘Hindu oppression’ are merely trying to cover up the nefarious Sanghi agenda of trying to create their ideal of a ‘Hindu India’.