New Draft Wind Power Guidelines Seek to Reform Sector Through Payment Security

Wind power generation has only the variable tariff, no fixed tariff, which means that wind power generated in times of zero demand is not paid for, leading to revenue losses for companies.

Credit: kliemphoto/pixabay

Credit: kliemphoto/pixabay

New draft guidelines on wind power procurement released by the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy give some respite to wind developers, who have suffered revenue losses due to unavailability of grid and payment delays from distribution companies. The guidelines have introduced a payment security mechanism that guarantees a partial compensation to wind power developers even if power is not transmitted to the grid.

The improvements in the regulations and guidelines are a step in the right direction – especially if the government plans to eliminate generation-based incentives for the wind sector.

The guidelines were released on April 7 and will be open for comments and suggestions until April 21. The development follows the successful wind power auctions conducted by the Solar Energy Corporation of India for installing 1,000 MW of wind power. These auctions saw a drop in wind tariff (feed-in tariff set earlier set by state electricity regulatory commissions) from around Rs 4-5.5 per unit to a record low of Rs 3.46 per unit of power generated.

Wind’s woes

Wind is the largest source of India’s renewable energy, contributing 57% of all energy from renewable sources. As of February 28, India’s installed capacity of wind power was 29,151 MW.

But poor transmission and evacuation have mired the sector’s progress. For instance, Tamil Nadu has more than 10,000 MW of wind installation but developers there are unable to sell their power due to congestion and a shortage of evacuation facilities. The grid is usually unavailable when the wind power plants generate electricity, so the power thus remains unutilised.

This is a problem for wind developers, who only get paid when the generated power is fed into the grid. If not, it means loss of revenue.

The tariff rules for thermal power are different from wind power. Thermal power plants have two-part-revenue: fixed and variable. If a thermal power plant is asked not to feed generated power to the grid, it will still be compensated the fixed part of the tariff. Wind plants do not receive this since there is no cost of fuel, so there is no fixed-part tariff.

Distribution companies (discoms), which source electricity from developers and supply it to consumers, have been deferring payments for electricity generators. A delay of six to eight months has become the norm in making payments. Per a news report from July 2016 quoting a wind industry executive, there is a total backlog of around Rs 5,000 crore in payments from distribution companies in Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Gujarat, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh.

A part of the reason for delayed payments is the lowering of solar tariffs. Discoms do not want to pay Rs 5 for one unit of electricity when solar costs close to Rs 3 per unit. As a result, Rajasthan, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra have stopped signing new power purchase agreements (PPA) for wind projects.

What the draft guidelines entail

According to the payment security mechanism, if the power is being sold directly to discoms, the payment guarantee must be given through a revolving letter of credit. This ensures payment of at least a month’s average billing and a security fund to support the payment for at least three months’ billing – for all projects. In addition, discoms can choose to provide a state government guarantee that will be legally enforceable for additional protection.

A similar payment security will also be given in case an intermediary is involved who procures power from the developer and sells it to the discoms.

The guidelines also specify the compensation for wind power developers in case of grid unavailability or backing-down of the grid. It also asks for rules to be specified in the PPA. In case of grid unavailability, the developer will be compensated for the generation loss based on the average generation and hours of unavailability. In case of a back-down, 50% of the payment will be made again based on average generation and hours of unavailability.

The new guidelines also solve a lot of issues troubling the sector. For instance, the bidding process ensures that the tariff to be paid by the state discoms is competitive compared to the feed-in tariff being paid and to solar tariffs, which have reduced to just Rs 3.15 per unit. The payment security clause also appeases developers that there will be no delay in payment, but if there is, that alternate compensation will be given. Finally, in case of a back-down or grid unavailability, there will be partial compensation so revenue losses can be minimised.

This article was originally published on Down To Earth and is republished here with permission.