Scholars, Activists Decry ‘Collective Onslaught On Reason’

New Delhi: A collective assault on reason – that is how a gathering of academics and activists this weekend described the ongoing attack on individuals, institutions, history, ideas and education that has been gathering pace across the country “ever since the RSS-dominated BJP government” came to power at the Centre.

Organised here by Sahmat on Saturday, the immediate context for the meeting was the killing of the Karnataka scholar M M Kalburgi – the third in a series of assassinations targeting individuals known for their opposition to orthodoxy and communalism. The first two victims were the well-known Maharashtra rationalists Govind Pansare and Narendra Dabholkar.

Supreme Court lawyer Anil Nauriya noted that the police had said that there was nothing common in the three murders, barring the ‘morning walker’ aspect – referring to the fact that all were killed in the morning. “There was far more in common – they were rationalists and running campaigns on social justice and equity.” Nauriya also linked the murders of Pansare and Dhabolkar with their association to the Rashtra Seva Dal, an organization founded to combat communal organizations.

“Pansare and Dhabolkar were close associates. Soon after Dhabolkar’s assassination, Pansare received messages that he would be next.”

If the law enforcement machinery says it knows how to get to the bottom of every crime, why has it not solved the triple killings, asked activist Teesta Setalvad, also referring to threats on social media to Mysore professor KS Bhagwan.

The attack on individuals and ideas was being felt in the field of education too. Tracing attempts to bring about a ‘value-based education policy’ by the NDA government since its first stint in 1999, Setalvad said: “The RSS, which represents an unconstitutional ideology, is governing both government and educational policy.”

She referred to the need for an audit of the textbooks by Dinanath Batra of the Shiksha Bachao Andolan being taught in 40,000 schools in Gujarat – books with distorted content – and the urgency of revisiting the 2004 committee, which recommended the formation of an all-India textbook board to examine books in state and private schools, and schools run by religio-social political organisations.

Referring to the renaming of Delhi’s Aurangzeb Road, and also to the appropriation of Maratha warrior Shivaji by the right-wing, Setalvad said: “Pansare’s book Shivaji Kon Hota has letters from Shivaji to Aurangzeb which shows that Shivaji’s battle with Aurangzeb was not religious.”

Academic Prabhat Patnaik, noting the destruction of institutions, said: “Second rate mediocre people are being placed in charge of institutions, destroying any possibility of rational discourse.” In recent times, heads appointed to the the Indian Council of Historical Research (ICHR) and Film and Television Institute of India (FTII), are known to be close to the government, and have been accused of saffronising these institutes. Warning of the approaching ‘fascification of state’, Patnaik said: “A part of the process towards fascism of the state is the destruction of reason. A symptom of this destruction has been the obliteration of the distinction between history and mythology.” This process ran contrary to both the social emancipation movement of Ambedkar and others and anti-colonial struggles, Patnaik said.

Historian Irfan Habib saw a historical parallel in the “replacement of history by mythology” that he said was currently underway in India. “Textbooks from the NDA regime portray Gandhi and Nehru as if they had nothing to contribute to the national movement, only Hindu rashtra people like Savarkar and others made worthwhile sacrifices. Nehru is censored and Gandhi’s murder is given a skip in these books. This is inventing of facts and history just like in Nazi Germany which tried to portray Germans as governing the world.”

Noting prior efforts to rename Lucknow to ‘Lakshmanpuri’ and also attempts to rename Allahabad, Habib said any drive to rename places would result in continued communalisation.

“The renaming of the Aurangzeb Road is an ominous augury for a campaign to change names on communal grounds,” a statement released by Sahmat said.

Setalvad, whose organisation Citizens for Justice and Peace played an important role in securing 120 convictions related to the 2002 Gujarat riots, and who the government accuses of illegal financial activities, told The Wire: “This government does not want an opposing voice. We are against the ideology of the government. Being against the government and its ideology is different from being against the state.”

  • S Thiyagarajan

    History writing is the most controversial and contentious issue always. Can people forget the ‘TIME CAPSULE’ burried during Indra Gandhi’s regime totally distorting the history of India. For a long time, the history of Indian independence has been distorted to emphasise as though only Gandhi and Nehru got us freedom. For many years after independence, many of the supreme sacrifices of countless freedom fighters were ignored or blacked out for the sack of glorifying handful of persons close to the ruling establishment. Is this not history distortion? what were the so called intellectuals doing then? For a long time left leaning historians were leading the ICHR and were distorting history as they wished. Now when course correction is undertaken, a handful of assorted individuals, Teesta included, are crying hoarse as though they are the only custodians of all facts. RSS is a nationalistic, patriotic organisation unlike some of the shadowy organisations that Teesta is getting funded? what right she has got to criticise RSS when her activities are being probed for impropriety and wrong doing?Yes, the majority of indians have problem with Aurangazeb name. Aurangazeb was a tyrant who terrorized the majority Hindus and destroyed many treasures and monuments of our motherland. What is wrong in replacing the name with one of the shining diamonds of India APJ Kalam. Do they have any problem with APJ? Name changing of places is nothing new or recent. Rhodesia has been changed to Zimbabwe for erasing a tyrant Rhodes. Burma has become Myanmar. Malaya has become Malaysia. Ceylon has become Sri Lanka.Tanganika has been renamed Tanzania. The list is endless. So dont get worked up over a routine name change except to show of your loyalty to a tyrant or to show off your (pseudo) secularism.