Cities & Architecture

History Needs Informed Debate, Not the Erasure of Aurangzeb to Install Kalam

A man who should be commemorated with a museum of science for children has been fobbed off with a road-sign

A young Prince Aurangzeb facing Sudhakar the elephant. 1633 painting. Credit: Wikimedia Commons

So all those who live on Aurangzeb Road will now have to get new letterheads, and postmen will have to be taught where Dr A.P.J. Abdul Kalam Road is. Given the significance invested in naming, it makes one pause to recall how often one has seen the former President being called Abul Kalam (the “Master of Conversation”) rather than the “Servant of the Word”—Abdul Kalam.

Why was Aurangzeb there in the first place? And how do place names relate to history and our imagination of our cities? Delhi has a millennium of history, and many place names go back a long way. New Delhi has many points of difference with Delhi, and one is in place names. Shahjahanabad has galis named for individuals who had havelis there, while mohallas were often named for the dominant trade or occupation of the neighbourhood. Even these were not necessary when giving directions. The writer Intezar Husain, now in Pakistan, told me where his home in Delhi had been, “Woh gali jahaan aam ka ped hai” (‘the lane where there is a mango tree’).

New Delhi was designed by British architects and engineers, and each street had bungalows of a standard design and size, was lined by a particular species of tree, and as in Britain, was thought to need a name.

Historic highways—Qutab Road and Mathura Road—were not renamed, but the New Delhi that lay between them became a record of rulers of the subcontinent. “Many of the streets have been given the names of historical characters in the history of India,” wrote Percival Spear, one of the first teachers of history in Delhi University, in Delhi: Its Monuments and History, which he wrote for children in 1943. “Look at the names of the streets” he urged, “and see if you know anything about the names given”. He himself had been asked to suggest names of figures in Indian history for these streets. A fun way of learning these might have been to take schoolchildren on walks in New Delhi in the winter sunshine, to tick off Prithviraj or Wellesley or Shahjahan in their books.

Aurangzeb RoadIn the late 19th century, children in Britain and in India learned history as political history. The monotony was relieved by the adjectives—Ivan was ‘the Terrible’, Peter was ‘the Great’. So in Indian history we had Ashoka and Akbar as ‘Great’. No one was ‘the Terrible’, but Aurangzeb and Curzon were described in terms so unfavourable as to be just as damning. My hunch is that it was because both of them became unpopular in their own court—in Curzon’s case with his Commander-in-Chief Kitchener—just as Mohammed Tughlaq had a bad press because of the hostility of some members of the court.

Of them all, Aurangzeb has received the most attention. Any mishap could be blamed on him—even a swarm of bees in a well in a Bihar village was confidently attributed by a little girl to Aurangzeb. He is like the kuttichathu of Malayalis—responsible for anything that went wrong. So our New Delhi Municipal Councillors have, in their wisdom, decided to exorcise him from the streets of the Capital. In doing so, they have treated Abdul Kalam Sahib shabbily—a man who should be commemorated with a museum of science for children has been fobbed off with a road-sign!

“There were requests from certain sections of the society for changing the name of the road as a tribute to the former President,” PTI quoted NDMC vice-chairman Karan Singh Tanwar as saying on Friday. “The matter was placed before the council today, which unanimously gave a go ahead for the same.”

Informed debate should be the material of history, neither hero stones nor erasure. History teachers may think street names do not matter. Maybe they do not look at the sky or see the straws in the wind.

Narayani Gupta is an author and historian of Delhi

  • अमित/Амит/অমিত/Amit

    आदरणीया,
    आपने ये कैसे मान लिया कि कलाम साहब को महज़ किसी रोड के नाम तक सीमित कर दिया गया है? क्या महात्मा गांधी, पंडित नेहरू या अन्य वो महान व्यक्ति जिनके नाम पर किसी रोड के नाम रखे गए हैं, वे सब सीमित कर दिए गए? क्या उनके नाम पर फिर कुछ और स्मारक, भवन, पुस्कालय, संग्रहालय, विश्वविद्यालयों के नाम नहीं रखे गए? थोड़ा तो इंतज़ार किया होता या कम से कम भारत सरकार की योजनाओं/मिशनों पर ही गौर किया होता.(Rashtriya Avishkar Abhiyan to be renamed as APJ Abdul Kalam Rashtriya Avishkar Abhiyan. Bussiness Standard http://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ani/rashtriya-avishkar-abhiyan-to-be-renamed-as-apj-abdul-kalam-rashtriya-avishkar-abhiyan-115072800290_1.html ) इतना ही नहीं उत्तरप्रदेश सरकार ने भी UPTU का नाम कलाम साहब के नाम पर करने का फैसला किया है.(UPTU renamed after APJ Abdul Kalam – The Financial Express)
    मेरा हमेशा मनना रहा है कि हमें आने वाली पीढ़ी के सामने इतिहास के उन नायकों का गुणगान करना है जिन्होंने मानवता के कल्याण के लिए प्रयास किए न कि उनका गुणगान करना है जिन्होंने इतिहास को दूषित किया. आखिर जर्मनी क्यों हिटलर से जुड़ीं अपनी सभी यादें भूलना चाहता है? क्या हम पुष्पमित्र शुंग का गुणगान कर सकते हैं? नहीं.
    अतः न सिर्फ औरंगज़ेब बल्कि डलहौजी, कर्जन, बाबर, अलाउद्दीन और बलबन जैसे क्रूर शासकों से जुड़ी स्मृतियों को मिटाया जाना चाहिए. यशगान होना चाहिए तो शेरशाह, अकबर, टीपू सुल्तान, शिवाजी या मुहम्मद बिन तुग़लक़ जैसों का… (ऐसे शासकों की सूची बहुत लंबी है. सबका उल्लेख संभव नहीं) जिन्होंने नवाचार के प्रयोग किए. भले ही उनके हिस्से में सफलता उसी अनुपात में आई हो या नहीं.
    अब आप मुझे किसी खास रंग का समझें तो आपकी मर्जी.

    • Yogesh Jain

      Good response.

  • naraharijavaji

    so many articles on road name change-what is the use for society.?There are so many issues which are very important than this.Please provide space for them.
    This is over reaction(journalistic jingoism) to a small issue

  • Anil Maheshwari

    This write-up says, “The writer Intezar Husain, now in Pakistan, told me where his home in Delhi had been, “Woh gali jahaan aam ka ped hai” (‘the lane where there is a mango tree’).” His name is Intizar Hussain, the most celebrated Urdu writer of the day in the sub-continent. He was born in Dibai, a town in district Bulandshahr, brought up at Hapur (at that time in Meerut district) and educated at Meerut College, Meerut from where he got his graduation degree. And then he migrated (made a hijrat) to Pakistan and settled in Lahore. As the write of this piece is a renowned historian, Prof. K.A. Nizami, a noted historian (whom the left/liberal would refuge to acknowledge) was the class fellow of Intizar Hussain.

  • m1

    Please feel free to name their own kids as Aurangzeb if anyone holds him with such respect.

  • Pingback: Renaming Victoria Terminus to Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus is a Clear Message to….... - Skeptic Indus()